心脏负荷试验中的性别偏倚是否仍然存在?一项嵌套于随机对照试验的视频分析
该研究嵌套于胸痛选择试验(Chest Pain Choice trial),为单中心患者层面随机对照试验,急诊科胸痛考虑行心脏负荷试验的患者随机接受共享决策或常规诊疗,并录制医患互动视频。共纳入204例患者(决策辅助组101例,常规组103例),女性120例(58.8%);评估75名医生,女性20名(26.7%)。女性急性冠脉综合征平均验前概率低于男性[3.7%(2.2)对6.7%(4.4),P=.0002]。讨论时长、临床医生建议、OPTION评分、患者感知或最终处置均无性别效应。当医生与患者性别相同时,OPTION评分更低(交互作用P=.002),患者认为信息非常有帮助的可能性更低(交互作用P=.10)。
要点
- 女性急性冠脉综合征平均验前概率低于男性[3.7%(2.2)对6.7%(4.4),P=.0002]。
- 讨论时长、临床医生建议、OPTION评分、患者感知及最终处置均无性别效应。
- 医生与患者性别相同时OPTION评分更低(交互作用P=.002)。
- 医患性别相同时患者认为信息非常有帮助的可能性更低(交互作用P=.10)。
适用人群与场景
- 急诊科胸痛并考虑行心脏负荷试验的患者,纳入胸痛选择试验,随机接受共享决策或常规诊疗。
研究设计与关键结果
- 单中心患者层面随机对照试验的嵌套视频分析,共纳入204例患者(决策辅助组101例,常规组103例),女性120例(58.8%);评估75名医生,女性20名(26.7%)。
- 女性急性冠脉综合征平均验前概率低于男性[3.7%(2.2)对6.7%(4.4),P=.0002]。
- 讨论时长、临床医生建议、OPTION评分、患者感知或最终处置均无性别效应。
- 医生与患者性别相同时OPTION评分更低(交互作用P=.002)。
- 医生与患者性别相同时患者认为信息非常有帮助的可能性更低(交互作用P=.10)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:嵌套于单中心患者层面随机对照试验的视频分析。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 本研究未观察到女性与男性在临床医生建议或患者处置上的显著性别差异。
- 作者认为,当医患性别相同时,医生在决策过程中对患者的参与度更低,且所提供信息的帮助性更差。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Despite a high prevalence of coronary heart disease in both genders, studies show a gender disparity in evaluation whereby women are less likely than men to undergo timely or comprehensive cardiac investigation. Using videographic analysis, we sought to quantify gender differences in provider recommendations and patient evaluations.
METHODS: We analyzed video recordings from our Chest Pain Choice trial, a single center patient-level randomized trial in which emergency department patients with chest pain being considered for cardiac stress testing were randomized to shared decision-making or usual care. Patient-provider interactions were video recorded. We compared characteristics and outcomes by gender.
RESULTS: Of the 204 patients enrolled (101 decision aid; 103 usual care), 120 (58.8%) were female. Of the 75 providers evaluated, 20 (26.7%) were female. The mean (SD) pretest probability of acute coronary syndrome was lower in women [3.7% (2.2) vs 6.7% (4.4), P=.0002]. There was no gender effect on duration of discussion, clinician recommendations, OPTION scores, patient perceptions, or eventual patient dispositions. When the clinician and patient gender matched, OPTION scores were lower (interaction P=.002), and patients were less likely to find the information to be very helpful (interaction P=.10).
CONCLUSIONS: Despite a lower pretest probability of acute coronary syndrome in women, we did not observe any significant gender disparity in how patients were managed and evaluated. When the patients' and providers' gender matched, the provider involved them less in the decision making process, and the information provided was less helpful than when the genders did not match.
参考来源
- Nestler DM, Gilani WI, Anderson RT, et al. Does gender bias in cardiac stress testing still exist? A videographic analysis nested in a randomized controlled trial. Am J Emerg Med. 2016. PMID: 27825694. doi:10.1016/j.ajem.2016.09.054
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。