南非资源有限环境下被转诊但拒绝收入ICU患者的特征与结局
该研究为南非两家公立医院的描述性回顾性队列,纳入2022年1-6月866例成人ICU转诊患者,按临床医生评估的急性程度和ICU分诊状态分为四组。469例(54.2%)收入ICU,397例(45.8%)被拒;收入ICU者30天全因院内死亡率为27.7%。在327例有分诊优先评分的被拒患者中,76.5%因预后被拒、23.5%因床位容量被拒;高急性期因容量被拒者死亡率为26.0%,高急性期因预后被拒者为53.2%,低急性期因预后被拒者为7.2%。被拒者较少为外科/创伤患者,更多为来自病房和急诊的内科患者。
要点
- 866例ICU转诊中397例(45.8%)被拒,收入ICU者30天全因院内死亡率为27.7%。
- 有分诊评分的327例被拒者中250例(76.5%)因预后被拒,77例(23.5%)因容量被拒。
- 高急性期因容量被拒者(77例,占全部转诊9.7%)死亡率为26.0%,74.0%存活。
- 高急性期因预后被拒者(111例,13.9%)死亡率为53.2%;低急性期因预后被拒者(139例,17.5%)死亡率为7.2%。
- 被拒ICU转诊者较少为外科/创伤患者,更多为来自病房和急诊的内科患者。
适用人群与场景
- 南非KwaZulu-Natal省卫生厅下属两家公立医院2022年1月至6月的成人ICU转诊患者。
- 按临床医生评估的急性程度和ICU分诊状态分为四组:ICU收入组、高急性期因容量被拒组、高急性期因预后被拒组、低急性期因预后被拒组。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 分诊分组依据临床医生评估的急性程度(高急性期/低急性期)与ICU分诊状态(收入/因容量被拒/因预后被拒)。
- 327例被拒转诊者有分诊优先评分,其中250例(76.5%)因预后被拒、77例(23.5%)因容量被拒。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 原文未提及
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 高急性期因预后被拒(「太重不收」)者30天死亡率为53.2%,提示该类患者病情极重、分诊预期可能偏差。
- 高急性期因容量被拒(「合适患者但无床位」)者死亡率为26.0%,提示床位容量限制下仍有74.0%存活。
- 部分被拒患者出现与分诊预期轨迹不符的临床偏离(原文结论)。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:描述性回顾性队列研究;场景:南非两家公立医院;时间:2022年1月至6月。
- 样本:866例成人ICU转诊,469例(54.2%)收入ICU,397例(45.8%)被拒。
- 收入ICU者30天全因院内死亡率为27.7%。
- 有分诊评分的被拒者(n=327)中,76.5%因预后被拒、23.5%因容量被拒。
- 高急性期因容量被拒组(77例,占转诊9.7%)死亡率26.0%(存活74.0%);高急性期因预后被拒组(111例,13.9%)死亡率53.2%(存活46.8%);低急性期因预后被拒组(139例,17.5%)死亡率7.2%。
- 被拒者较少为外科/创伤患者,更多为来自病房和急诊的内科患者。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:描述性回顾性队列研究。
- 局限:单国两家公立医院、资源有限环境、回顾性设计、描述性统计、分诊评分为非缺失子集(n=327),原文未给出证据等级或推荐强度。
对床旁实践的改变
- 在资源有限环境中,ICU转诊被拒者中高急性期因预后被拒者死亡率高(53.2%),提示「太重不收」的判断需结合潜在临床偏离轨迹复核。
- 因床位容量被拒的高急性期患者仍有74.0%存活,提示容量限制下的分诊决策需关注可存活人群。
- 被拒转诊者更多为来自病房和急诊的内科患者,提示内科患者转诊评估与床位分配需重点审视。
- 原文未提供干预措施,不能据此改变具体药物或操作方案。
指南或共识出处
- 原文未提及
以上提炼依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取,或许可不允许翻译转载);全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: ICU beds are a limited resource and assessing net benefit from ICU admission remains incompletely understood. We sought to examine characteristics and outcomes of patients referred but declined for ICU admission, stratified by clinician-perceived likelihood of ICU benefit.
DESIGN: Descriptive, retrospective cohort study.
SETTING: Two public hospitals in the KwaZulu-Natal Department of Health, South Africa, from January 2022 to June 2022.
PATIENTS: Adult ICU-referred patients classified into four triage cohorts by clinician-assessed acuity and ICU triage status: ICU admissions; high-acuity capacity-declined ICU referrals; high-acuity prognosis-declined ICU referrals; and low-acuity prognosis-declined ICU referrals.
INTERVENTIONS: None.
MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: We report descriptive statistics of ICU-referred patient characteristics stratified by triage cohorts and mortal status. Among 866 ICU referrals, 469 patients (54.2%) were admitted, and 397 patients (45.8%) were declined for ICU admission. ICU admissions had an observed all-cause 30-day hospital mortality of 27.7%. Among declined ICU referrals with nonmissing triage priority scores (n = 327), 250 patients (76.5%) were declined ICU admission for prognosis reasons, and 77 patients (23.5%) were declined for capacity reasons. Seventy-seven (9.7% of ICU referrals) high-acuity capacity-declined ICU referrals ("appropriate patient; no bed capacity; not admitted") had a 26.0% mortality (74.0% survival), 111 (13.9%) high-acuity prognosis-declined ICU referrals ("too sick; not admitted") had a 53.2% mortality (46.8% survival), and 139 (17.5%) low-acuity prognosis-declined ICU referrals ("too well; not admitted") had a 7.2% mortality. Declined ICU referrals were less likely surgical/trauma patients and more likely medical patients coming from wards and emergency departments.
CONCLUSIONS: In one sampling in the South African public healthcare system, many patients are referred but declined for ICU admission due to perceptions of being both "too well" or "too sick" to benefit and due to bed capacity, with a proportion of such patients experiencing potential clinical deviations from triage-expected trajectories.
参考来源
- Anesi GL, Ndadane N, Invernizzi J, et al. Characteristics and Outcomes of Patients Referred but Declined for ICU Admission in a Resource-Limited Setting in South Africa. Crit Care Explor. 2026. PMID: 42825612. doi:10.1097/CCE.0000000000001498
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。