创伤相关群体伤亡事件中的院前延迟:高收入与中低收入国家视角的国际比较调查
该横断面在线调查于2024年5月至8月通过专业协会、校友网络和社交媒体在全球招募至少经历过一次创伤相关群体伤亡事件的院前急救人员,按世界银行国家收入分类分层,采用Mann-Whitney U检验、卡方或Fisher精确检验分析定量数据,并按Braun和Clarke框架对开放文本做主题分析。225份合格应答来自54个国家,其中158份(70.2%)来自高收入国家、67份(29.8%)来自中低收入国家。沟通不良与地理挑战是最常被提及的延迟因素,同意率分别为84%和80%;中低收入国家75%的应答者认为设备不足导致延迟,高收入国家为46%。定性分析归纳出八个延迟主题,行政与政策障碍仅见于高收入国家,应答者情绪负担与压力仅来自定性回答。定期培训与既往群体伤亡经验被广泛认为是优化因素,同意率分别为95%和90%。作者认为,将沟通改进纳入常规群体伤亡事件培训与运营规划,可能是减少所感知院前延迟的可改变环节。
要点
- 225名来自54国的院前人员中,沟通不良与地理挑战是最常被提及的延迟因素,同意率分别为84%和80%。
- 中低收入国家应答者中75%认为设备不足导致延迟,高收入国家为46%。
- 定性分析识别出八个延迟主题:沟通与协调问题、资源限制、基础设施与现场进入障碍、医院能力与准备、行政与政策问题、培训与准备不足、安全与安保障碍、应答者情绪负担与压力。
- 行政与政策障碍仅由高收入国家参与者报告;应答者情绪负担与压力仅来自定性回答,缺乏对应定量条目。
- 定期培训与既往群体伤亡经验被广泛认可为优化因素,同意率分别为95%和90%。
适用人群与场景
- 全球范围内至少经历过一次创伤相关群体伤亡事件的院前急救人员,通过专业协会、校友网络和社交媒体招募。
- 按世界银行国家收入分类分为高收入国家与中低收入国家两层。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:横断面在线调查,于2024年5月至8月进行,通过专业协会、校友网络和社交媒体全球招募。
- 样本:225份合格应答来自54个国家,其中158份(70.2%)来自高收入国家,67份(29.8%)来自中低收入国家。
- 定量分析采用Mann-Whitney U检验及卡方或Fisher精确检验;开放文本按Braun和Clarke框架做主题分析。
- 沟通不良与地理挑战是最常被提及的延迟因素,同意率分别为84%和80%。
- 中低收入国家应答者中75%认为设备不足导致延迟,高收入国家应答者为46%。
- 定性分析识别出八个延迟主题:沟通与协调问题、资源限制、基础设施与现场进入障碍、医院能力与准备、行政与政策问题、培训与准备不足、安全与安保障碍、应答者情绪负担与压力。
- 行政与政策障碍仅由高收入国家参与者报告;应答者情绪负担与压力仅来自定性回答,缺乏对应定量条目。
- 定期培训与既往群体伤亡经验被广泛认可为优化因素,同意率分别为95%和90%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:横断面在线调查。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,将沟通改进纳入常规群体伤亡事件培训与运营规划,可能是减少所感知院前延迟的可改变环节。
- 定期培训与既往群体伤亡经验被应答者广泛认可为优化因素,同意率分别为95%和90%。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Mass casualty incidents (MCIs) place substantial demands on pre-hospital systems. Extended pre-hospital times are associated with adverse patient outcomes. The factors perceived as contributing to these delays are poorly characterized across different resource settings. This study aimed to identify and compare pre-hospital care providers' perceptions of factors associated with pre-hospital delays during trauma-related mass casualty incidents across high-income and low- and middle-income countries.
METHODS: A cross-sectional online survey was conducted between May and August 2024. Pre-hospital care providers with experience of at least one trauma-related mass casualty incident were recruited globally via professional associations, alumni networks, and social media. The survey comprised expert-reviewed Likert-scale items and open-ended questions. Participants were stratified by national income level using World Bank classifications. Quantitative data were analyzed using the Mann-Whitney U test and chi-squared or Fisher's exact tests. Open-text responses were analyzed using thematic analysis following the framework of Braun and Clarke.
RESULTS: Of 225 eligible responses from 54 countries, 158 (70.2%) were from high-income countries and 67 (29.8%) from low- and middle-income countries. Poor communication and geographical challenges were the most frequently cited delay factors, with agreement rates of 84% and 80%, respectively. Agreement that equipment inadequacy contributed to delays was reported by 75% of respondents from low- and middle-income countries compared with 46% of respondents from high-income countries. Thematic analysis identified eight qualitative delay themes: communication and coordination issues, resource limitations, infrastructure and scene access challenges, hospital capacity and preparedness, administrative and policy issues, training and preparedness gaps, security and safety barriers, and responder emotional burden and stress. Administrative and policy barriers were reported exclusively by participants from high-income countries. Responder emotional burden and stress emerged solely from qualitative responses and lacked corresponding quantitative items. Regular training and prior mass casualty experience were widely endorsed as optimizing factors, with agreement rates of 95% and 90%, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: Clinician-perceived delay factors showed similar patterns across settings, particularly communication failures, while differing in emphasis by resource context. Communication improvement, integrated into routine MCI training and operational planning, may represent a modifiable area for reducing perceived pre-hospital delays.
参考来源
- Alruqi F, Althobiani MA, Cole E, et al. Pre-hospital care delays in trauma-related mass casualty incidents: a comparative international survey of high-income and low- and middle-income country perspectives. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med. 2026. PMID: 42919409. doi:10.1186/s13049-026-01664-8
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。