公众号 / 文章重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

床旁死亡判定:超越标准的临床判断

Death determination at the bedside: clinical judgement beyond criteria.
PubMed 文献 · Crit Care · 2026-08-28
一句话结论死亡判定不仅是应用标准,更是在科学局限与隐含假设下,结合语境进行解释性与表演性临床判断的过程。

本文为教学性文章,通过一个临床场景的四种轨迹(明显死亡、心脏骤停与复苏、神经学标准死亡、撤除生命支持后的循环死亡)阐述死亡判定。作者指出,死亡判定在医学标准、临床判断、科学局限和隐含假设的交汇处运作,存在关于循环、脑灌注与脑功能关系、全脑与部分脑功能丧失、永久与不可逆丧失、神经恢复预测等不确定性。临床医生并非简单观察离散生物学事件,而是在医学法律框架内解释濒死过程,死亡宣告也具有表演性,改变患者医学、法律和社会状态。结论建议在重症医学教育中明确这些局限与判断,以帮助医生承担责任、改善家庭沟通并维持公众信任。

要点

  • 死亡判定不能仅视为标准化医学和法律标准的技术应用,还需解释性与表演性临床判断。
  • 死亡判定存在科学不确定性:循环、脑灌注与脑功能的关系,全脑与部分脑功能丧失的区分,永久与不可逆丧失的区分,以及神经恢复预测。
  • 不同临床语境(明显死亡、心脏骤停与复苏、神经学标准死亡、撤除生命支持后循环死亡)对不确定性的管理方式不同。
  • 临床医生在医学和法律框架内解释濒死过程,死亡宣告改变患者医学、法律和社会状态。
  • 重症医学教育应明确死亡判定中的科学局限、隐含假设和语境依赖的临床判断,以改善家庭沟通和公众信任。

适用人群与场景

  • 原文未提及

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 原文未提及

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 原文未提及

红旗征与不能漏的情况

  • 原文未提及

研究设计与关键结果

  • 本文为教学性文章,通过单一 illustrative 临床场景的四种轨迹(明显死亡、心脏骤停与复苏、神经学标准死亡、撤除生命支持后的循环死亡)阐述死亡判定的不确定性。
  • 死亡判定涉及循环、脑灌注与脑功能关系、全脑与部分脑功能丧失区分、永久与不可逆丧失区分、神经恢复预测等不确定性,在不同临床语境下管理方式不同。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:教学性文章(综述/专家意见);无证据等级或推荐强度;局限:单场景示例,非系统评价。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 提示急诊/ICU医生死亡判定不仅是应用标准,还需在医学法律框架内结合语境进行临床判断,并注意向家庭沟通科学局限与隐含假设。
  • 原文未给出具体改变做法、适用/不适用人群或常见陷阱的推荐。

指南或共识出处

  • 原文未提及

以上提炼依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取,或许可不允许翻译转载);全文请点「阅读原文」。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: In clinical practice, death determination-a core responsibility of critical care clinicians-is commonly taught as the technical application of standardized medical and legal criteria. However, contemporary practices, including resuscitation, death determination by neurological criteria, withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment, and controlled donation after circulatory determination of death, show that determining death also requires interpretative and performative, context-dependent clinical judgement operating within persistent scientific limits and implicit assumptions about human life and its end.

MAIN BODY: Using a single illustrative clinical scenario followed across four trajectories-obvious death, cardiac arrest and resuscitation, death determined by neurological criteria, and circulatory death following withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment-we examine how death determination operates at the intersection of medical criteria, clinical judgement, scientific limits, and implicit assumptions. Particular uncertainties concern the relationships between circulation, cerebral perfusion, and brain function; the distinction between complete and partial loss of brain function; the distinction between permanent and irreversible loss; and the prediction of neurological recovery, acceptable functional outcome, and meaningful life. These uncertainties are managed differently across clinical contexts. Across these contexts, clinicians do not simply observe a discrete biological event: they interpret an evolving process of dying within established medical and legal frameworks. The declaration of death is therefore also performative, transforming the patient's medical, legal, and social status.

CONCLUSION: Death determination should not be understood or taught solely as the application of criteria and protocols. Making explicit in critical care education the scientific limits, implicit assumptions, and context-dependent clinical judgement involved in determining and declaring death may help clinicians better assume this responsibility, improve communication with families, and sustain public trust in end-of-life care and organ donation.

来源:Crit Care,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Le Dorze M, Nicolas-Robin A, Carvallo S, et al. Death determination at the bedside: clinical judgement beyond criteria. Crit Care. 2026. PMID: 42693466. doi:10.1186/s13054-026-06255-8

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。