协作领导与跨学科路径实现国家推荐:1884例疑似舟骨骨折快速MRI扫描的优异结果
该文介绍在A站点通过骨科、放射科和急诊科协作领导,共同创建疑似舟骨骨折的快速MRI路径,定义5分钟MRI扫描技术规格。将A站点100例患者与B站点100例传统路径患者比较,快速MRI站点临床预约和延迟诊断显著更少。8年间对1871例9至102岁患者完成1884例快速MRI扫描,无漏诊骨折,诊断为舟骨骨折阳性13.2%、其他损伤21.6%、其他情况27.3%、轻微损伤伴既存情况22.6%、正常扫描15.2%。结论认为强制NHS标准的指南可能无法实现改变,共同创建成功路径需要温和的临床领导、本地化解决方案、以患者为中心和响应性跨专业团队合作。
要点
- 8年间对1871例9至102岁患者完成1884例快速MRI扫描,无漏诊骨折,为全球最大疑似舟骨骨折系列。
- 快速MRI站点与B站点传统路径各100例比较,临床预约和延迟诊断均显著更少。
- 74.0%的MRI申请由急诊科护士或医生提出。
- 舟骨骨折阳性率13.2%;年龄≤50岁患者阳性率17.4%,年龄>50岁患者阳性率8.4%。
- 女性患者阳性率8.9%,男性患者阳性率18.9%。
适用人群与场景
- 疑似舟骨骨折患者,快速MRI路径队列年龄9至102岁。
- 比较分析纳入A站点100例患者与B站点100例传统路径患者。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 快速MRI路径包括:为急诊工作人员创建清晰的MRI申请表格,包含戒烟提示、夹板固定和带二维码的患者信息。
- 路径包括2周骨科骨折门诊预约,以审查扫描结果并个体化治疗。
- 使用教育视频进行入职培训。
- 跨员工群体合作,包括放射科、骨科、急诊科、接待员、放射技师、门诊预约和石膏固定人员。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为质量改进项目,比较A站点快速MRI路径100例与B站点传统路径100例,快速MRI站点临床预约和延迟诊断显著更少。
- 8年间对1871例患者完成1884例快速MRI扫描,无漏诊骨折。
- 诊断分布:舟骨骨折阳性13.2%、其他损伤21.6%、其他情况27.3%、轻微损伤伴既存情况22.6%、正常扫描15.2%。
- 74.0%的MRI申请由急诊科护士或医生提出。
- 47%的患者年龄超过50岁,其中8.4%阳性;年龄≤50岁患者阳性率17.4%。
- 57%为女性,其中8.9%阳性;男性患者阳性率18.9%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为质量改进项目报告。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,强制NHS标准的指南可能无法实现改变。
- 作者认为,共同创建成功路径需要温和的临床领导、本地化解决方案、以患者为中心和响应性跨专业团队合作。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
INTRODUCTION: National Institute of Clinical Effectiveness (NICE) guidance mandated early MRI scans for suspected scaphoid fractures in 2016. In national surveys, only 15% of NHS Emergency Departments achieve this. Missed fractures may require bone grafting surgery for non-union. NHS litigation costs are high. Conversely, over-treatment harms patients' lifestyle and income.
METHODS: With leadership across Orthopaedics, Radiology and the Emergency Department, we co-created a rapid MRI pathway for suspected scaphoid fractures at site A. We defined the technical specification for a 5 min MRI scan.100 patients from site A were compared with 100 from site B (traditional pathway).Features driving successful implementation are highlighted.Medical students helped analyse scan results, requests and demographics.
RESULTS: Statistically significantly fewer clinic appointments and fewer late diagnoses occurred at the rapid MRI site compared with the traditional site.Key features included:Working across staff groups (radiology/orthopaedics/emergency departments/receptionists/radiographers/clinic-booking/casting).Co-creating a pathway and clear proforma for Emergency staff to request MRI scans, including prompts for smoking cessation, splinting and patient information with QR codes.Using educational videos for induction.Pathway including a 2-week Orthopaedic fracture clinic appointment to review scan results and individualise treatment.Over 8 years, 1884 rapid MRI scans were performed on 1871 patients aged 9 to 102. This is the largest global series of suspected scaphoid fractures. There were no missed fractures. Diagnoses were: 13.2% scaphoid fracture positive, 21.6% other injury, 27.3% other condition, 22.6% minor injury with pre-existing condition and 15.2% normal scan. 74.0% were requested by Emergency department nurses or doctors. 47% of patients were over age 50, with 8.4% positive (17.4% positive in patients aged up to 50). 57% were female, with 8.9% positive (18.9% positive in male patients).
CONCLUSION: Guidance mandating NHS standards may not achieve change. Co-creating a successful pathway needs gentle clinical leadership, local organic solutions, patient-centredness and responsive cross-professional team-working.
参考来源
- McNally S, Kapoor S, Sambrook MG, et al. Using collaborative leadership and interdisciplinary pathways towards achieving national recommendations. Excellent results from 1884 rapid MRI scans for 'suspected scaphoid fracture'. BMJ Lead. 2026. PMID: 42760119. doi:10.1136/leader-2026-001638
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。