负压伤口治疗在低收入和中等收入国家骨科创伤及复杂创面中应用的改良德尔菲共识建议:一项非洲共识研究
该研究针对低收入和中等收入国家开放性骨折和复杂创伤性创面处理困难、负压伤口治疗证据有限的问题,通过叙述性文献回顾和写作委员会起草建议,再由非洲多国骨科创伤与整形外科专家进行改良德尔菲法外部验证。45名专家受邀,40名完成调查(应答率88.9%),共评估14条草案建议;2条达到非常强共识(一致率≥90%),8条达到强共识(80%~89%),4条未达预设阈值并根据专家组主流意见修订。共识最强的内容包括:负压伤口治疗作为开放性骨折标准处理的辅助措施、应用前充分外科清创、及时行确定性软组织重建;技术参数和组织实施方面共识较低,反映证据有限和当地资源差异。这些建议为资源受限环境中安全、因地制宜地实施负压伤口治疗提供了实用框架。
要点
- 负压伤口治疗应作为开放性骨折标准处理的辅助措施,而非替代标准处理;该条共识一致率最高。
- 应用负压伤口治疗前须进行充分的外科清创,该条共识一致率最高。
- 应及时行确定性软组织重建,该条共识一致率最高。
- 14条草案建议中,2条达到非常强共识(一致率≥90%),8条达到强共识(80%~89%),4条未达预设阈值并根据专家组主流意见修订。
- 技术参数和组织实施方面共识较低,反映证据有限和当地资源差异。
适用人群与场景
- 低收入和中等收入国家中发生开放性骨折或复杂创伤性创面的患者。
- 因就诊延迟、重建能力有限、专科创面处理可及性受限而使处理复杂化的患者。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 负压伤口治疗作为开放性骨折标准处理的辅助措施(共识一致率最高)。
- 应用负压伤口治疗前须进行充分的外科清创(共识一致率最高)。
- 及时行确定性软组织重建(共识一致率最高)。
- 14条草案建议中,2条达非常强共识(一致率≥90%)、8条达强共识(80%~89%)、4条未达预设阈值并根据专家组主流意见修订;技术参数和组织实施方面共识较低。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:改良德尔菲共识研究;45名专家受邀,40名完成调查(应答率88.9%),专家来自非洲多国的骨科创伤与整形外科。
- 方法:叙述性文献回顾后由写作委员会起草建议,经改良德尔菲法外部验证;预设共识为对建议类别的同意率≥80%,≥90%为非常强共识。
- 共评估14条草案建议:2条达到非常强共识(≥90%),8条达到强共识(80%~89%),4条未达预设阈值并根据专家组主流意见修订。
- 一致率最高的建议为:负压伤口治疗作为开放性骨折标准处理的辅助措施、应用前充分外科清创、及时行确定性软组织重建;技术参数与组织实施方面一致率较低。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:基于叙述性文献回顾和改良德尔菲法的专家共识。
- 共识定义:同意率≥80%为达成共识,≥90%为非常强共识。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性
对床旁实践的改变
- 在资源受限环境中,负压伤口治疗应作为开放性骨折标准处理的辅助措施,而非替代标准处理。
- 应用负压伤口治疗前须进行充分的外科清创。
- 应及时行确定性软组织重建。
- 技术参数和组织实施方面因证据有限和当地资源差异共识较低,实施时需结合具体情境。
指南或共识出处
- Modified Delphi consensus recommendations for the use of negative-pressure wound therapy in orthopedic trauma and complex wounds in low- and middle-income countries: an African consensus study(非洲多国改良德尔菲共识研究)
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Open fractures and complex traumatic wounds remain a major cause of morbidity in low- and middle-income countries, where delayed presentation, limited reconstructive capacity, and restricted access to specialized wound care complicate management. Although negative-pressure wound therapy is increasingly used as an adjunct in complex wound management, evidence specific to low- and middle-income countries remains limited and practical consensus recommendations are lacking.
PURPOSE: To develop evidence-informed consensus recommendations for negative-pressure wound therapy use in orthopedic trauma and complex wounds in low- and middle-income countries and validate them through a multinational African modified Delphi process.
METHODS: A narrative literature review identified evidence regarding negative-pressure wound therapy in orthopedic trauma and complex wounds, with particular emphasis on low- and middle-income countries settings. Draft recommendations were developed by the writing committee and externally validated through a modified Delphi process involving orthopedic-trauma and plastic surgeons from across Africa. Recommendations were initially classified as strong, moderate, or conditional and evaluated by the expert panel. Consensus was predefined as ≥ 80% agreement with the proposed recommendation category, while ≥ 90% agreement was considered very strong consensus.
RESULTS: Forty-five experts were invited to participate, and forty completed the survey (response rate 88.9%). Fourteen draft recommendations were evaluated. Two achieved very strong consensus (≥90% agreement), eight achieved strong consensus (80-89%), and four did not reach the predefined threshold and were revised according to the predominant opinion of the panel. Agreement was highest for recommendations emphasizing negative-pressure wound therapy as an adjunct to standard open fracture management, adequate surgical debridement before negative-pressure wound therapy application, and timely definitive soft-tissue reconstruction. Lower agreement concerned technical parameters and organizational aspects, reflecting limited evidence and variability in local resources.
CONCLUSION: These recommendations represent a multinational African modified Delphi consensus on negative-pressure wound therapy use in orthopedic trauma and complex wounds in low- and middle-income countries. By integrating the best available evidence with broad expert experience, they provide a pragmatic framework to support safe, context-adapted negative-pressure wound therapy implementation in resource-constrained settings while identifying areas requiring further clinical research.
参考来源
- Manegabe JDT, Englebert A, Kabakuli AN, et al. Modified Delphi consensus recommendations for the use of negative-pressure wound therapy in orthopedic trauma and complex wounds in low- and middle-income countries: anAn African consensus study. Injury. 2026. PMID: 42691887. doi:10.1016/j.injury.2026.113615
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。