复杂腹股沟疝的定义及方法选择情境化:三轮德尔菲共识框架
该三轮德尔菲研究由54名意大利腹壁外科专家对85条陈述进行评分,覆盖 elective 与急诊场景下的复杂性定义、疝特征、患者特征和手术史。51.8%的陈述达到至少倾向共识(≥65%),其中34条同意、10条不同意;21.2%达到强共识(>80%)。择期手术中复杂性主要由升级需求定义,包括需要高经验术者和/或转诊至专门中心;急诊应视为时间敏感性复杂场景,共识集中在肠管受累/梗阻和污染或脏手术野作为严重度和规划标志而非转运标准。方法选择上,专家组趋向于复发时采用换平面原则;肥胖相关条目观点异质,未转化为单一首选方法;手术时间被视为路径规划修饰因素而非手术平面的固定决定因素。
要点
- 择期手术中,复杂腹股沟疝主要由升级需求定义,包括需要高经验术者和/或转诊至专门中心。
- 急诊表现应视为时间敏感性复杂场景,肠管受累/梗阻和污染或脏手术野是严重度和规划标志,而非转运标准。
- 复发疝的方法选择上,专家组趋向于换平面原则。
- 肥胖相关条目观点异质,未形成单一首选手术方法。
- 手术时间被视为路径规划修饰因素,而非手术平面的固定决定因素。
适用人群与场景
- 成人腹股沟疝患者,涵盖择期和急诊场景。
- 专家组为54名意大利腹壁外科专家。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 共识分级:无共识(<65%)、倾向同意/不同意(65-80%)、同意/不同意(>80%)。
- 复杂性定义涉及升级需求:需要高经验术者和/或转诊至专门中心(择期手术)。
- 急诊场景中,肠管受累/梗阻和污染或脏手术野作为严重度和规划标志,而非转运标准。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 择期手术中,复杂性由升级需求定义,包括需要高经验术者和/或转诊至专门中心。
- 急诊表现应视为时间敏感性复杂场景,以肠管受累/梗阻和污染或脏手术野作为严重度和规划标志,而非转运标准。
- 复发疝的方法选择趋向于换平面原则。
- 手术时间被视为路径规划修饰因素,而非手术平面的固定决定因素。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 急诊表现应视为时间敏感性复杂场景。
- 肠管受累/梗阻和污染或脏手术野是严重度和规划标志,而非转运标准。
研究设计与关键结果
- 三轮德尔菲过程,固定专家组54名意大利腹壁外科专家,评估85条陈述,覆盖择期和急诊场景下的复杂性定义、疝特征、患者特征和手术史。
- 44/85条陈述(51.8%)达到至少倾向共识(≥65%):34条同意,10条不同意;18条陈述(21.2%)达到强共识(>80%)。
- 择期手术中复杂性主要由升级需求定义,包括需要高经验术者和/或转诊至专门中心。
- 急诊表现应视为时间敏感性复杂场景,共识集中在肠管受累/梗阻和污染或脏手术野作为严重度和规划标志,而非转运标准。
- 方法选择上,专家组趋向于复发时换平面原则;肥胖相关条目观点异质,未转化为单一首选方法;手术时间被视为路径规划修饰因素而非手术平面的固定决定因素。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:三轮德尔菲共识。
- 共识分级:无共识(<65%)、倾向同意/不同意(65-80%)、同意/不同意(>80%)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者提出一个保守、非指令性框架来定义和报告复杂腹股沟疝。
- 作者认为最稳健的产出涉及专业技术升级、急诊风险标志和复发时换平面原则。
- 作者认为共识较弱的领域应被解读为对专业技术敏感的决策节点,需要外部验证。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: The term "complex groin hernia" is widely used in clinical practice but lacks a standardized operational definition and a structured framework to guide escalation, referral pathways, and approach selection.
METHODS: A three-round Delphi process was conducted with a fixed panel of 54 Italian expert abdominal wall surgeons evaluating 85 statements across elective and emergency scenarios spanning (1) definition of complexity, (2) hernia characteristics, (3) patient characteristics, and (4) previous surgical history. Items were scored on a 5-point Likert scale in Rounds 1-2 and on a 3-point scale in Round 3. Consensus was graded as no consensus (< 65%), leaning agreement/disagreement (65-80%), or agreement/disagreement (> 80%).
RESULTS: Overall, 44 of 85 statements (51.8%) achieved at least leaning consensus (≥ 65%): 34 in agreement and 10 in disagreement; strong consensus (> 80%) was reached for 18 statements (21.2%). In elective surgery, complexity was mainly defined by escalation needs, including requirement for a highly experienced surgeon and/or referral to a dedicated center. Emergency presentation should be regarded as a time-sensitive complexity setting; within this domain, consensus clustered around bowel compromise/obstruction and contaminated or dirty fields as severity and planning markers, not as transfer criteria. For approach selection, the panel converged toward a change-of-plane principle for recurrence. Obesity-related items showed heterogeneous views and did not translate into a single preferred approach. Operative time emerged as a pathway-planning modifier rather than a fixed determinant of operative plane.
CONCLUSIONS: This Delphi study proposes a conservative, non-prescriptive framework to define and report complex groin hernia. Its most robust outputs concern expertise escalation, emergency risk markers, and the change-of-plane principle for recurrence, while areas of weaker agreement should be interpreted as expertise-sensitive decision nodes requiring external validation.
参考来源
- Cavaliere D, Capoccia Giovannini S, Paratore F, et al. Defining complex groin hernia and contextualizing approach selection: a three-round Delphi consensus framework. Hernia. 2026. PMID: 42622861. doi:10.1007/s10029-026-03825-1
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。