急性上消化道出血管理培训课程:欧洲胃肠内镜学会(ESGE)立场声明
该文件为欧洲胃肠内镜学会(ESGE)发布的立场声明,以20条条款规定急性上消化道出血内镜管理的培训前知识、技术准备、监督下操作例数、胜任力评估与培训后跟踪。声明要求学员在开始培训前达到上消化道内镜关键绩效指标的最低推荐标准,培训初期至少参加半天专用模拟器培训,并在直接监督下完成至少20例内镜近期出血征象操作。胜任力定义为评估内镜需求并计划实施成功止血的能力,学员应在成功止血30例后接受胜任力评估,采用UGIB-CAT作为形成性评估工具并进行正式终结性评估。达到胜任力后仍需至少6个月的结果跟踪与导师指导实践,并建立急诊医学、外科和介入放射学等支持专科的转诊路径。
要点
- 学员应在直接监督下完成至少20例内镜近期出血征象操作,以防止止血失败并确保技能获得。
- 胜任力定义为评估内镜需求并计划实施成功止血的能力,学员应在成功止血30例后接受胜任力评估。
- 成功止血定义为无任何再出血(持续性或复发性出血),是内镜治疗上消化道出血培训的终极目标。
- 再出血患者应由经验丰富的内镜医师或在其直接监督下的学员治疗,因常规内镜治疗失败风险较高。
- 达到胜任力后应继续至少6个月的结果跟踪与经验丰富同事的指导实践,并建立关键支持专科的转诊路径。
适用人群与场景
- 接受急性上消化道出血内镜管理培训的学员及其培训师。
- 培训中心,包括上消化道出血病例量有限的中心。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 胜任力定义:评估内镜需求并计划实施成功止血的能力。
- 成功止血定义:无任何再出血(持续性或复发性出血)。
- 学员在开始上消化道出血管理培训前应达到上消化道内镜关键绩效指标的最低推荐标准。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 培训前应具备病理学、血管解剖、设备技术使用、临床诊疗路径及操作前后患者管理相关知识。
- 培训前技术技能包括充分的镜身操控、插管技术、残留物冲洗与吸引、黏膜检查及附件操作,应按胜任力框架个体化评估而非仅依据数值阈值。
- 培训开始时建议至少参加半天提供消化道出血培训的专用模拟器培训课程。
- 学员应在直接细致监督下完成至少20例内镜近期出血征象操作。
- 培训中应按ESGE指南推荐接触所有止血方式。
- 再出血患者应由经验丰富的内镜医师或在其直接监督下的学员治疗。
- 学员应接触多学科团队讨论及内镜治疗失败的上消化道出血诊疗路径。
- 病例量有限的培训中心鼓励提供至高病例量中心的短期沉浸式培训。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 再出血患者常规内镜治疗失败风险较高,应由经验丰富的内镜医师或在其直接监督下的学员治疗。
研究设计与关键结果
- 该文件为ESGE立场声明,以20条条款规定急性上消化道出血内镜管理培训的各方面要求。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:学会立场声明(ESGE Position Statement)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 学员在直接监督下完成至少20例内镜近期出血征象操作后方可独立操作。
- 学员应在成功止血30例后接受胜任力评估,培训中使用UGIB-CAT作为形成性评估工具并进行正式终结性评估。
- 达到胜任力后应继续至少6个月的结果跟踪与指导实践,并建立急诊医学、外科和介入放射学的转诊路径。
- 培训师在决定学员参与病例管理的适当性和程度时,应考虑预测结局的操作前和操作中因素、技术复杂性及止血失败风险。
指南或共识出处
- 欧洲胃肠内镜学会(ESGE)立场声明:急性上消化道出血管理培训课程。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
ABSTRACT: 1: Before commencing hands-on upper gastrointestinal bleeding (UGIB) training, trainees should have thorough knowledge of: pathology, vascular anatomy, technical use of devices, clinical care pathways, and all relevant components of pre-, intra-, and postprocedural patient care.
ABSTRACT: 2: Preadoption technical skills required for training in the management of UGIB include adequate scope handling, intubation technique, washing and suctioning of residue, mucosal examination, and handling of accessories.
ABSTRACT: 3: Preadoption technical skills required for training in the management of UGIB should be assessed individually based on a competency framework and not solely on numerical thresholds.
ABSTRACT: 4: The integrative skills required for the management of UGIB do not essentially differ from those needed in other endoscopic procedures and should include adequate situational awareness, collaboration, team leadership, and patient communication in order to ensure short- and long-term goals are achieved.
ABSTRACT: 5: The trainee should reach minimum recommended standards for key performance indicators in upper GI endoscopy before starting training in the management of UGIB.
ABSTRACT: 6: Attendance of at least one half-day training session on a dedicated simulator that provides GI bleeding training at the beginning of training for management of UGIB is advised.
ABSTRACT: 7: Trainees should be supervised directly and carefully during UGIB training for a minimum of 20 procedures with endoscopic stigmata of recent hemorrhage in order to prevent failure of hemostasis and ensure adequate trainee skill acquisition.
ABSTRACT: 8: Trainers should take into account pre-endoscopic and intraprocedural factors predicting outcome, technical complexity, and risk of hemostatic failure when deciding appropriateness and degree of trainee involvement in case management.
ABSTRACT: 9: During their training, trainees should be exposed to all hemostatic modalities, as per ESGE guideline recommendations, and the opportunities for teaching arising from the specifics of each UGIB case.
ABSTRACT: 10: Trainers should use "successful hemostasis," defined as the absence of any further bleeding (persistent or recurrent bleeding), as the ultimate goal of training in the endoscopic management of UGIB.
ABSTRACT: 11: Patients with recurrent bleeding should be treated by experienced endoscopists or by a trainee under their direct supervision owing to the higher risk of failure of conventional endoscopic treatment.
ABSTRACT: 12: Trainers who are teaching management of UGIB should fulfil the same standards as any trainer of basic endoscopy procedures.
ABSTRACT: 13: Trainees should be exposed to multidisciplinary team discussions and care pathways for failed endoscopic treatment of UGIB.
ABSTRACT: 14: Training centers with limited UGIB case volumes are encouraged to offer short-term immersive training in centers with high volume caseloads of UGIB in order to ensure sufficient exposure for trainees.
ABSTRACT: 15: Competency in managing UGIB is defined as the ability to assess the need for endoscopy, and plan and carry out successful hemostasis.
ABSTRACT: 16: Trainees should manage an indicative number of 30 cases in which successful hemostasis is achieved before evaluation of competence in management of UGIB.
ABSTRACT: 17: UGIB-CAT is advised as a formative assessment tool during training to track acquisition of competence and provide trainee feedback.
ABSTRACT: 18: Trainees should undergo a formal summative assessment of competence in managing UGIB during their training.
ABSTRACT: 19: Endoscopists should continue a period of tracking results and mentored practice with an experienced colleague for at least 6 months after achieving competence in managing UGIB.
ABSTRACT: 20: As trainees move to independent practice, they should have established access to or referral pathways for key supporting specialties involved in the nonendoscopic management of acute UGIB (including emergency medicine, surgery, and interventional radiology).
参考来源
- Voiosu AM, Camus M, Ibrahim M, et al. Curriculum on management of acute upper gastrointestinal bleeding: European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ESGE) Position Statement. Endoscopy. 2026. PMID: 42447876. doi:10.1055/a-2893-6920
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。