文献速递重症综合管理与镇静镇痛消化、代谢与肾脏急症

缓慢抢救的伦理意涵:美国医院缓慢抢救伦理的系统综述

Ethical Implications of the Slow Code: A Systematic Review of Ethics of Slow Codes in U.S. Hospitals.
PubMed 文献 · Crit Care Med · 2026-06-25
一句话结论多数伦理文献认为缓慢抢救不可接受,其使用常反映代理决策者可能未完全理解心肺复苏的含义或操作机制。

本文为定性系统综述,检索 MEDLINE、Embase、CINAHL 和 Web of Science,2024年5月16日初检、2025年8月7日更新,去重后12,863篇文献经双人独立筛选,最终纳入34篇伦理文献(学术文章、评论和观点文章),排除实证研究。61.8%(n=21)认为在医疗无效情况下应允许医生拒绝心肺复苏,23.5%(n=8)支持在患者或家属要求全力复苏时进行缓慢/部分抢救,26.5%(n=9)描述了更细致的方法。伦理关切包括欺骗、患者伤害、违反自主权、家长主义、道德困扰、法律考量和沟通障碍。结论指出多数伦理文献认为缓慢抢救不可接受,其使用常反映对代理决策者理解的担忧,医生实践仍存分歧,需要清晰沟通和伦理指导。

要点

  • 61.8%(n=21/34)的伦理文献认为在医疗无效情况下应允许医生拒绝心肺复苏。
  • 23.5%(n=8/34)支持在患者或家属要求全力复苏时进行缓慢/部分抢救。
  • 26.5%(n=9/34)描述了更细致的方法来处理全力抢救与舒适措施之间的空间。
  • 缓慢抢救的伦理关切包括欺骗、患者伤害、违反自主权、家长主义、道德困扰、法律考量和沟通障碍。
  • 多数伦理文献认为缓慢抢救不可接受,其使用常反映代理决策者可能未完全理解心肺复苏的含义或操作机制。

适用人群与场景

  • 美国医院中处于医疗无效情况、介于「全力抢救」与「舒适措施」之间的患者。
  • 患者或家属要求全力复苏而医生不愿拒绝无益复苏的情境。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 定性系统综述,检索 MEDLINE、Embase、CINAHL 和 Web of Science,初检2024年5月16日,更新检索2025年8月7日,去重后12,863篇文献经双人独立筛选,最终纳入34篇伦理文献(学术文章、评论和观点文章),排除实证研究。
  • 34篇中61.8%(n=21)认为在医疗无效情况下应允许医生拒绝心肺复苏。
  • 23.5%(n=8)支持在患者或家属要求全力复苏时进行缓慢/部分抢救。
  • 26.5%(n=9)描述了更细致的方法。
  • 伦理关切包括欺骗、患者伤害、违反自主权、家长主义、道德困扰、法律考量和沟通障碍。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:定性系统综述,纳入伦理文献(学术文章、评论和观点文章),排除实证研究。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 多数伦理文献认为缓慢抢救不可接受,其使用常反映代理决策者可能未完全理解心肺复苏的含义或操作机制。
  • 在医疗无效情况下,在「什么都不做」与「做一切」之间选择可能令家属痛苦,而实施复苏可能令临床医生痛苦。
  • 医生实践仍存分歧,作者认为需要清晰沟通和伦理指导以支持透明、以患者为中心的临终照护。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: Policies that make cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) the default or require it at patient or family request, combined with physician reluctance to decline nonbeneficial resuscitation, may contribute to the practice of a "slow code," in which clinicians appear to perform advanced cardiac life support without fully committing to resuscitative efforts. The space between "full code" and "comfort measures" in medically futile situations presents significant ethical challenges. This systematic review examines the ethical implications of slow codes and factors influencing their use.

DATA SOURCES: We conducted a qualitative systematic review of slow codes in U.S. hospitals. A librarian searched MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, and Web of Science using terms related to CPR, futility, and ethics. The initial search was performed on May 16, 2024, with an updated search on August 7, 2025, including "slow code" and "partial code."

STUDY SELECTION: After duplicate removal, 12,863 articles underwent dual, independent screening. Thirty-four studies met inclusion criteria. Included articles were ethics literature (academic articles, commentaries, and opinion pieces) and excluded empirical studies.

DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Of 34 articles analyzed, 61.8% ( n = 21) argued physicians ought to be allowed to refuse CPR in futile cases, whereas 23.5% ( n = 8) supported slow/partial codes when patients or families request full resuscitation. A further 26.5% ( n = 9) described nuanced approaches. Ethical concerns included deception, patient harm, violation of autonomy, paternalism, moral distress, legal considerations, and communication breakdown.

CONCLUSIONS: Most ethics literature deems slow codes impermissible. Their use often reflects concerns that surrogate decision-makers may not fully understand the implications or mechanics of CPR. In medically futile situations, choosing between "do nothing" and "do everything" can be distressing for families, whereas performing resuscitation can be distressing for clinicians. Physicians remain divided in practice, highlighting the need for clear communication and ethical guidance to support transparent, patient-centered end-of-life care.

来源:Crit Care Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Fontenot T, Grisel B, Freeman J, et al. Ethical Implications of the Slow Code: A Systematic Review of Ethics of Slow Codes in U.S. Hospitals. Crit Care Med. 2026. PMID: 42339875. doi:10.1097/CCM.0000000000007233

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。