指南与共识创伤与烧伤

创伤骨科资源与干预优先排序(PRIORI-T):一项改良德尔菲共识研究

PRIoritisation of orthopaedic resources and interventions in trauma (PRIORI-T): A modified delphi consensus study.
指南 / 共识 · Injury · 2026-06-23
一句话结论南非公立医院骨科临床医生通过改良德尔菲共识,确定6项患者因素和6项损伤因素应纳入稳定孤立骨科损伤住院患者的手术优先排序框架,急性骨筋膜室综合征和肢体血管受威胁为自动红旗 override。

本研究在南非公立医院骨科临床医生中开展三轮改良德尔菲研究,旨在建立稳定、孤立骨科损伤住院患者手术优先排序因素的共识。第一轮开放式生成候选因素,第二轮用1-9重要性量表评分,第三轮核实操作定义、锚定水平和红旗处理。共分析第一轮65份、第二轮55份、第三轮63份回复。6项患者因素和全部6项损伤因素达到纳入共识,其中软组织状态、解剖部位和神经血管状态达到强纳入共识;急性骨筋膜室综合征和相关肢体血管受威胁达到共识作为自动红旗 override。未提出任何打破平局的指标达到共识。作者认为该框架为初步框架,而非经过验证的评分系统,正式实施前需前瞻性权重、评分者间信度测试和结局验证。

要点

  • 纳入共识定义为中位评分至少4分且至少75%的应答者评分在4-9分;强纳入共识要求中位评分至少7分且至少75%评分在7-9分。
  • 6项患者因素达到纳入共识:年龄、糖尿病、严重心脏或呼吸疾病、病前功能状态、生理储备、当前精神病或严重精神不稳定。
  • 全部6项损伤因素达到纳入共识;软组织状态、解剖部位和神经血管状态达到强纳入共识。
  • 急性骨筋膜室综合征和相关肢体血管受威胁达到共识,作为自动红旗 override。
  • 未提出任何打破平局的指标达到共识;该框架为初步框架,正式实施前需前瞻性权重、评分者间信度测试和结局验证。

适用人群与场景

  • 南非公立医院中已入院、病情稳定、孤立骨科损伤的患者。
  • 排除多发伤、脊髓损伤和不稳定椎体骨折患者,因其需通过既有急诊路径进行个体化、时间紧迫的优先排序。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 纳入共识:中位评分至少4分且至少75%的应答者评分在4-9分。
  • 强纳入共识:中位评分至少7分且至少75%的应答者评分在7-9分。
  • 二元共识:至少75%同意。

红旗征与不能漏的情况

  • 急性骨筋膜室综合征达到共识作为自动红旗 override。
  • 相关肢体血管受威胁达到共识作为自动红旗 override。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 三轮回合分别分析65份、55份和63份回复。
  • 6项患者因素达到纳入共识:年龄、糖尿病、严重心脏或呼吸疾病、病前功能状态、生理储备、当前精神病或严重精神不稳定。
  • 全部6项损伤因素达到纳入共识;软组织状态、解剖部位和神经血管状态达到强纳入共识;骨折类型或模式、损伤能量和已等待手术时间达到纳入共识。
  • 急性骨筋膜室综合征和相关肢体血管受威胁达到共识作为自动红旗 override。
  • 未提出任何打破平局的指标达到共识。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:改良德尔菲共识研究。
  • 局限:作者指出该框架为初步框架,而非经过验证的评分系统;正式实施为优先排序工具前需前瞻性权重、评分者间信度测试和结局验证。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为该共识框架可为南非公立医院稳定孤立骨科损伤住院患者的手术优先排序提供参考因素。
  • 作者指出该框架为初步框架,而非经过验证的评分系统;正式实施前需前瞻性权重、评分者间信度测试和结局验证。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Operative orthopaedic care in resource-constrained systems is frequently limited by theatre time, staffing, peri-operative support, implants, instruments and bed availability. In the absence of an explicit prioritisation framework, decisions about patients awaiting surgery may vary between clinicians and institutions. This modified Delphi study aimed to establish consensus on factors that should structure prioritisation of operative orthopaedic care in South African public hospitals.

METHODS: A three-round modified Delphi study was conducted among South African public-sector orthopaedic clinicians. Round 1 used open-ended responses to generate candidate prioritisation factors. Round 2 used a structured 1-9 importance scale to rate patient-specific factors, injury-specific factors, red-flag conditions and potential tie-breakers. Round 3 verified operational definitions, anchor levels and red-flag handling. The scope was confined a priori to admitted patients with stable, isolated orthopaedic injuries; polytrauma, spinal cord injuries and unstable vertebral fractures were excluded because they require individualised, time-critical prioritisation through established emergency pathways. Inclusion consensus was defined as a median score of at least 4 with at least 75% of respondents rating the factor 4-9. Strong inclusion consensus required a median score of at least 7 with at least 75% rating the factor 7-9. Binary consensus required at least 75% agreement.

RESULTS: Following exclusion, 65, 55 and 63 responses were analysed in Rounds 1, 2 and 3, respectively. Six patient-specific factors reached inclusion consensus: age, diabetes mellitus, severe cardiac or respiratory disease, premorbid functional status, physiological reserve and current psychosis or severe psychiatric instability. All six injury-specific factors reached inclusion consensus. Soft-tissue status, anatomical site and neurovascular status reached strong inclusion consensus; fracture type or pattern, injury energy and time already waited for surgery reached inclusion consensus. Acute compartment syndrome and threatened vascular status of the relevant limb reached consensus as automatic red-flag overrides. No proposed tie-breaker reached consensus.

CONCLUSIONS: This study provides a consensus framework for factors influencing the prioritisation of patients awaiting operative orthopaedic care in a low- and middle-income country (LMIC) setting. The findings support a preliminary framework, rather than a validated scoring system. Prospective weighting, inter-rater reliability testing and outcome validation are required before implementation as a formal prioritisation tool.

来源:Injury,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Kotze JD, Amod M, Breedt C, et al. PRIoritisation of orthopaedic resources and interventions in trauma (PRIORI-T): A modified delphi consensus study. Injury. 2026. PMID: 42341351. doi:10.1016/j.injury.2026.113465

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。