文献速递消化、代谢与肾脏急症

非营利医院使用管理咨询公司后的财务、运营与医疗质量变化

Changes in Nonprofit Hospitals' Finances, Operations, and Quality of Care After Using Management Consultants.
PubMed 文献 · JAMA · 2026-01-01
一句话结论观察性研究显示,非营利医院聘请管理咨询公司后,财务、运营与医疗质量指标未出现实质性、统计学显著或系统性的改善。

该观察性研究采用堆叠双重差分设计,比较2010-2022年首次使用管理咨询公司的306家美国非营利医院与2009-2023年未使用的513家匹配医院。研究期间超过20%的非营利医院聘请了管理咨询公司,平均每家支付1570万美元,2009-2023年合计支出超过78亿美元。分析显示,财务表现(如净患者收入相对变化-2.22%,95%CI -5.11%至0.76%,P=.14)、运营指标(如住院时长相对变化1.71%,95%CI -0.34%至3.81%,P=.10)及基于理赔的30天死亡率和再入院率均无显著改善,唯一例外是卒中30天再入院率(1.37个百分点,95%CI 0.14至2.61,P=.03),但该结果对替代规格不稳健。作者认为,这些发现对非营利医院从管理咨询服务中获得的净价值提出疑问。

要点

  • 研究期间超过20%的美国非营利医院首次聘请管理咨询公司,平均每家支付1570万美元。
  • 2009-2023年非营利医院在管理咨询服务上合计支出超过78亿美元。
  • 净患者收入相对变化-2.22%(95%CI -5.11%至0.76%,P=.14),无统计学显著改善。
  • 卒中30天再入院率相对变化1.37个百分点(95%CI 0.14至2.61,P=.03),但该结果对替代规格不稳健。
  • 作者认为,这些发现对非营利医院从管理咨询服务中获得的净价值提出疑问。

适用人群与场景

  • 2010-2022年首次使用管理咨询公司的306家美国非营利医院,与2009-2023年未使用管理咨询公司的513家匹配医院进行比较。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型为观察性研究,采用堆叠双重差分设计,比较306家首次使用管理咨询公司的非营利医院与513家匹配的未使用医院。
  • 研究期间超过20%的非营利医院聘请了管理咨询公司,平均每家支付1570万美元,2009-2023年合计支出超过78亿美元。
  • 净患者收入相对变化-2.22%(95%CI -5.11%至0.76%,P=.14),运营费用相对变化-1.07%(95%CI -3.56%至1.49%,P=.41)。
  • 固定资产相对变化2.05%(95%CI -6.54%至11.42%,P=.65),坏账相对变化-6.31%(95%CI -19.82%至9.48%,P=.41)。
  • 现金持有天数相对变化-8.56%(95%CI -28.00%至16.13%,P=.46),总利润率变化-0.19个百分点(95%CI -1.20至0.82,P=.71)。
  • 营业利润率变化0.15个百分点(95%CI -0.94至1.23,P=.79),住院时长相对变化1.71%(95%CI -0.34%至3.81%,P=.10)。
  • 总住院日相对变化0.29%(95%CI -2.57%至3.23%,P=.85),基于理赔的30天死亡率和再入院率一般无显著差异。
  • 唯一例外为卒中30天再入院率变化1.37个百分点(95%CI 0.14至2.61,P=.03),但该结果对替代规格不稳健。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型为观察性研究,采用堆叠双重差分设计。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,这些发现对非营利医院从管理咨询服务中获得的净价值提出疑问。
  • 作者建议,需要仔细审视医院及医疗行业其他组织对管理咨询公司的广泛使用。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

IMPORTANCE: The presence of management consultants in the US health care industry has increased dramatically in recent decades and is now higher than in most other sectors of the US economy. Hospitals hire management consultants to provide external expertise and advise on strategic planning, organizational change, cost cutting, and revenue-enhancement activities. Despite the prominence and influence of these firms, there is no empirical evidence in the US documenting either how much is spent on these services or whether that spending leads to measurable improvements.

OBJECTIVE: To quantify nonprofit hospitals' spending on management consultants and to evaluate changes in finances, operations, and quality of care following the initiation of a contract with a management consulting firm.

DESIGN, SETTING, AND POPULATION: Observational study using a stacked difference-in-differences design to compare 306 US nonprofit hospitals that used a management consultant firm for the first time in 2010-2022 with 513 matched hospitals that did not use management consultants during 2009-2023.

EXPOSURE: First use of a management consulting firm.

MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Financial performance (eg, revenues, expenses, margins, cash reserves, and fixed assets), operational measures (eg, inpatient utilization, staffing, executive and worker compensation, charity care, and community benefits), and quality-of-care measures (eg, claims-based 30-day mortality and readmission for acute myocardial infarction, pneumonia, and stroke).

RESULTS: More than 20% of nonprofit hospitals hired management consultants during the study period. Nonprofit hospitals that hired management consultants paid an average of $15.7 million for their services, and nonprofit hospitals collectively spent more than $7.8 billion on these services from 2009 to 2023. Despite this substantial investment, analyses of hospitals' financial performance, operational decisions, and claims-based patient outcomes revealed little evidence of substantial, statistically significant, or systematic improvements attributable to consulting engagements. Relative changes were estimated for financial measures, such as net patient revenue (-2.22%; 95% CI, -5.11% to 0.76%; P = .14), operating expenses (-1.07%; 95% CI, -3.56% to 1.49%; P = .41), fixed assets (2.05%; 95% CI, -6.54% to 11.42%; P = .65), bad debt (-6.31%; 95% CI, -19.82% to 9.48%; P = .41), days' cash on hand (-8.56%; 95% CI, -28.00% to 16.13%; P = .46), total margin (-0.19 [95% CI, -1.20 to 0.82] percentage points; P = .71), and operating margin (0.15 [95% CI, -0.94 to 1.23] percentage points; P = .79). Relative changes were estimated for operational measures, such as inpatient length of stay (1.71%; 95% CI, -0.34% to 3.81%; P = .10) and total inpatient days (0.29%; 95% CI, -2.57% to 3.23%; P = .85). Relative changes for quality-of-care outcomes were also generally not significant. The sole exception was 30-day readmission for patients with stroke (1.37 [95% CI, 0.14 to 2.61] percentage points; P = .03), which was not robust to alternative specifications.

CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Nonprofit hospitals expend substantial resources on management consultants, but there was no evidence of meaningful changes in hospital finances, operations, or quality of care. These findings raise questions about the net value that nonprofit hospitals receive from management consulting services and suggest the need to carefully examine the widespread use of management consultants by hospitals and other organizations across the health care industry.

来源:JAMA,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Bruch JD, Fang CC, Zeng YB, et al. Changes in Nonprofit Hospitals' Finances, Operations, and Quality of Care After Using Management Consultants. JAMA. 2026. PMID: 42081210. doi:10.1001/jama.2026.5027

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。