呼吸照护的人力代价:多学科囊性纤维化团队的专业生活质量与职业倦怠
该研究对美国囊性纤维化(CF)多学科照护团队成员进行64条目问卷调查,包含专业生活质量量表和Maslach倦怠量表,共569名受访者,涵盖医师(24.9%)、高级实践提供者/护士(21.9%)、相关健康人员(29.4%)和心理健康提供者(23.8%)。结果显示受访者共情满意度中等、个人成就感低,倦怠低至中等,情绪耗竭和去人格化中等。不同职业间存在显著差异:与心理健康提供者相比,医师、高级实践提供者/护士和相关健康人员个人成就感更低、倦怠更高;医师和相关健康人员去人格化更高;医师情绪耗竭更高。女性个人成就感低于男性;西班牙裔提供者倦怠和情绪耗竭更高、个人成就感更低;在CF领域工作≥15年者倦怠低于工作10至14年者。倦怠主要贡献因素为行政任务(80.0%)、过多文书工作(79.4%)、人员不足(74.6%)、与患者相处时间不足(73.4%)和职责过多(72.7%)。心理健康提供者中一半曾因倦怠寻求专业帮助,而医师仅三分之一;女性医师寻求帮助的比例(40%)显著高于男性医师(19%)。作者认为,尽管已有成熟的团队照护模式,倦怠仍然严重,医师风险最高,其次为高级实践提供者/护士和相关健康人员;除促进个人健康外,系统层面的举措对支持多学科团队至关重要。
要点
- 569名美国CF多学科团队成员中,医师倦怠风险最高,其次为高级实践提供者/护士和相关健康人员,心理健康提供者相对最低。
- 倦怠前五位贡献因素:行政任务80.0%、过多文书工作79.4%、人员不足74.6%、与患者相处时间不足73.4%、职责过多72.7%。
- 医师中仅三分之一曾因倦怠寻求专业帮助,心理健康提供者中为一半;女性医师寻求帮助比例40%高于男性医师19%。
- 在CF领域工作≥15年者倦怠低于工作10至14年者;女性个人成就感低于男性,西班牙裔提供者倦怠和情绪耗竭更高。
- 作者认为,除个人健康促进外,系统层面举措对支持多学科团队照护慢性肺病患者至关重要。
适用人群与场景
- 美国囊性纤维化多学科照护团队成员,包括医师(24.9%)、高级实践提供者/护士(21.9%)、相关健康人员(29.4%)和心理健康提供者(23.8%),共569名受访者。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为问卷调查,共569名美国CF照护提供者完成64条目调查,包含专业生活质量量表和Maslach倦怠量表。
- 受访者报告共情满意度中等、个人成就感低,倦怠低至中等,情绪耗竭和去人格化中等。
- 不同职业间存在显著差异(F3,585=3.77-5.07;P<.05-.01):与心理健康提供者相比,医师、高级实践提供者/护士和相关健康人员个人成就感更低、倦怠更高;医师和相关健康人员去人格化更高;医师情绪耗竭更高。
- 女性报告个人成就感低于男性;西班牙裔提供者报告倦怠和情绪耗竭更高、个人成就感更低。
- 在CF领域工作≥15年者报告倦怠低于工作10至14年者。
- 倦怠主要贡献因素:行政任务80.0%、过多文书工作79.4%、人员不足74.6%、与患者相处时间不足73.4%、职责过多72.7%。
- 心理健康提供者中一半曾因倦怠寻求专业帮助,医师中仅三分之一;女性医师寻求帮助比例40%高于男性医师19%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为问卷调查(横断面研究)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,尽管已有成熟的团队照护模式,倦怠仍然严重,医师风险最高,其次为高级实践提供者/护士和相关健康人员。
- 作者认为,除促进个人健康外,系统层面举措对支持多学科团队照护慢性肺病患者至关重要。
- 原文未据此给出针对急诊或ICU的具体推荐。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Burnout is characterized by emotional exhaustion, reduced personal accomplishment, and increased depersonalization. Over one-half of physicians, nurses, and allied health professionals report substantial burnout, with consequences including decreased empathy and quality of care, increased medical errors, and increased health care costs. Team-based care, common in chronic respiratory conditions such as cystic fibrosis (CF), may be protective.
RESEARCH QUESTION: What is the risk of burnout among multidisciplinary CF care teams and does it differ by profession?
STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: US CF health care providers received a 64-item survey including 2 standardized measures (Professional Quality of Life Scale and Maslach Burnout Inventory). Respondents (N = 569) included physicians (24.9%), advanced practice providers (APPs)/nurses (21.9%), allied health (29.4%) and mental health providers (23.8%).
RESULTS: Providers reported moderate compassion satisfaction and low personal accomplishment, with low-moderate burnout and moderate emotional exhaustion and depersonalization. Significant differences were found by profession (F3,585 = 3.77-5.07; P < .05-01): in comparison with mental health providers, physicians, APPs/nurses, and allied health providers reported lower personal accomplishment and higher burnout; physicians and allied health providers reported higher depersonalization; and physicians reported higher emotional exhaustion. Overall, women reported lower personal accomplishment than men. Hispanic providers reported higher burnout and emotional exhaustion and lower personal accomplishment. Providers working in CF ≥ 15 years reported less burnout than those working 10 to 14 years. Top contributors to burnout were the following: administrative tasks (80.0%), excessive documentation (79.4%), insufficient staffing (74.6%), insufficient time with patients (73.4%), and excessive responsibility (72.7%). One-half of mental health providers had sought professional help for burnout vs only one-third of physicians; significantly more female physicians sought help (40%) than male physicians (19%).
INTERPRETATION: Our results show that despite well-established, team-based models of pulmonary care, burnout remained substantial, with physicians at highest risk, followed by APPs/nurses and allied health providers. In addition to promoting individual well-being, systems-level initiatives are critical to support multidisciplinary teams caring for people with chronic pulmonary disease.
参考来源
- Quittner AL, Seng E, Smith BA, et al. The Human Cost of Respiratory Care: Professional Quality of Life and Burnout Across Multidisciplinary Cystic Fibrosis Teams. Chest. 2026. PMID: 41839363. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2026.03.003
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。