定义急诊科镇痛需求:一项国际共识声明
该研究采用三阶段改良德尔菲法,第一阶段63名来自15个国家的国际专家组成员(包括临床医生、研究者、患者及患者代表)通过三个开放式问题生成候选预测变量;第二阶段同一批参与者用五点李克特量表评分,共识定义为≥80%的参与者选择「同意」或「强烈同意」;第三阶段在国际范围内随机招募临床医生和患者对共识衍生变量进行评分。第一阶段生成20个潜在临床预测变量,第二阶段6个变量达到共识阈值,第三阶段这6个变量的合并同意率(「同意」或「强烈同意」)范围为72%至91%。这6项变量为以患者为中心的多维疼痛评估框架奠定基础,将用于开发和验证新工具以改善急诊急性疼痛患者的镇痛。
要点
- 共识定义镇痛需求的6项变量:患者疼痛感知、患者镇痛意愿、疼痛耐受度、患者观察、照护者/亲属对患者疼痛的感知、提供者对患者疼痛的感知。
- 第三阶段前线临床医生和患者对这6项变量的合并同意率(「同意」或「强烈同意」)为72%至91%。
- 共识适用于无沟通或认知障碍的急诊急性疼痛患者。
- 共识定义为第二阶段≥80%的参与者选择「同意」或「强烈同意」的变量入选最终共识条目。
- 作者认为这6项变量为多维、以患者为中心的疼痛评估框架奠定基础,将作为开发和验证新工具的基础以改善急诊急性疼痛患者的镇痛。
适用人群与场景
- 急诊科无沟通或认知障碍的急性疼痛患者。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 共识定义:第二阶段≥80%的参与者选择「同意」或「强烈同意」的变量入选最终共识条目。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:三阶段改良德尔菲共识;第一阶段63名国际专家组成员(包括临床医生、研究者、患者及患者代表,来自15个国家)通过三个开放式问题生成候选预测变量。
- 第一阶段生成20个潜在临床预测变量。
- 第二阶段同一批参与者用五点李克特量表评分,6个变量达到共识:患者疼痛感知、患者镇痛意愿、疼痛耐受度、患者观察、照护者/亲属对患者疼痛的感知、提供者对患者疼痛的感知。
- 第三阶段在国际范围内随机招募临床医生和患者对共识衍生变量进行评分,合并同意率(「同意」或「强烈同意」)范围为72%至91%。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:国际改良德尔菲共识。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为这6项共识衍生变量为多维、以患者为中心的疼痛评估框架奠定基础,将作为开发和验证新工具的基础以改善急诊急性疼痛患者的镇痛。
指南或共识出处
- Defining the need for analgesia in the emergency department: an international consensus statement(Eur J Emerg Med)。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND IMPORTANCE: The high prevalence of acute pain in the emergency department (ED) underscores the need for accurate pain assessment to guide effective interventions. A pain assessment tool for ED patients with acute pain should enable clinicians to distinguish those who require analgesia from those who do not. However, a universally accepted definition of the 'need for analgesia' is lacking.
OBJECTIVE: To identify predictors of the need for analgesia in ED patients through a consensus-based interdisciplinary approach.
DESIGN/SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: A three-stage modified Delphi was conducted. In stage 1, 63 international panel members, including clinicians, researchers, patients, and patient representatives from 15 countries, answered three open-ended questions to generate candidate predictor variables. In stage 2, the same participants rated these variables using a five-point Likert scale. In stage 3, randomly selected clinicians and patients were recruited internationally to complete a survey rating the consensus-derived variables.
OUTCOME MEASURES AND ANALYSIS: The primary outcome was the identification of variables defining the need for analgesia in ED patients without communication or cognitive impairments. Consensus was defined a priori as more than or equal to 80% of participants selecting 'agree' or 'strongly agree' after stage 2. Variables meeting this threshold were considered in the final consensus-derived items. Stage 3 aimed to evaluate agreement with these variables among a broader panel of frontline clinicians and patients, to assess alignment with the expert panel, primarily composed of researchers, while also addressing potential geographic and professional biases.
RESULTS: Stage 1 generated 20 potential clinical predictor variables to define the need for analgesia. In stage 2, the six consensus-derived variables were: (a) patient's perception of pain, (b) patient's desire for analgesia, (c) pain tolerance, (d) patient observation, (e) caregiver/relative's perception of the patient's pain, and (f) provider's perception of the patient's pain. In stage 3, the rating of these variables reached combined agreement ('agree' or 'strongly agree') ranging from 72% to 91%.
CONCLUSION: The six consensus-derived variables provide a foundation for a multidimensional, patient-centered pain assessment framework, which will serve as the basis for developing and validating a new tool to improve analgesia for ED patients with acute pain.
参考来源
- Scotti B, Nickel CH, Degen B, et al. Defining the need for analgesia in the emergency department: an international consensus statement. Eur J Emerg Med. 2026. PMID: 41739103. doi:10.1097/MEJ.0000000000001321
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。