急诊医学中可解释人工智能的研究趋势与伦理视角:文献计量分析
该文献计量分析基于Web of Science核心合集,检索1986年至2025年11月,纳入433篇与急诊医学、人工智能、可解释性和伦理相关的英文同行评议论文和综述。研究使用Bibliometrix(R)分析发文趋势、引用、期刊、作者和国家,并用VOSviewer可视化主题聚类和关键词共现。结果显示2018年后发文量急剧增加,2023年达峰约90篇,截至2025年累计引用超过1400次;美国、英国和中国发文最多。主题图谱揭示四个主要聚类:可解释模型方法学开发、分诊/影像/脓毒症风险预测的临床应用、伦理与人因维度(偏倚、问责、透明性)、以及大语言模型等新兴主题。多数研究仍为回顾性,缺乏标准化可解释性指标、多中心验证和可解释性输出的一致报告。
要点
- 2018年后急诊可解释人工智能发文量急剧增加,2023年达峰约90篇,截至2025年累计引用超过1400次。
- 美国、英国和中国是发文量最高的国家;Annals of Emergency Medicine、NPJ Digital Medicine和BMJ Open为最具影响力期刊。
- 主题聚类集中于可解释模型方法学、分诊/影像/脓毒症风险预测应用、伦理与人因维度(偏倚、问责、透明性)及大语言模型等新兴主题。
- 多数研究为回顾性,缺乏标准化可解释性指标、多中心验证和可解释性输出的一致报告。
- 作者认为需通过多学科协作、标准化评价指标和更强治理来支持可解释人工智能在急诊中的透明、问责和安全临床采用。
适用人群与场景
- 急诊医学场景下涉及人工智能与可解释性、伦理的英文同行评议研究论文和综述,检索时段1986年至2025年11月。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为文献计量分析,基于Web of Science核心合集纳入433篇出版物,检索1986年至2025年11月,限定英文同行评议研究论文和综述。
- 发文量在2018年后急剧增加,2023年达峰约90篇;截至2025年累计引用超过1400次。
- 美国、英国和中国为发文量最高的国家;Annals of Emergency Medicine、NPJ Digital Medicine和BMJ Open为最具影响力期刊;Ong M.E.H.、Dwivedi G.、Stewart J.、Wang Y.和Li J.为主要贡献者。
- 主题图谱揭示四个主要聚类:可解释模型方法学开发;分诊、影像和脓毒症风险预测的临床应用;伦理与人因维度(偏倚、问责、透明性);大语言模型等新兴主题。
- 多数研究仍为回顾性,缺乏标准化可解释性指标、多中心验证和可解释性输出的一致报告。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为文献计量分析。
- 局限:多数研究仍为回顾性,缺乏标准化可解释性指标、多中心验证和可解释性输出的一致报告;前瞻性研究有限、临床医生参与不足、伦理框架尚未完全针对急诊场景定制。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,解决前瞻性研究有限、临床医生参与不足和伦理框架未完全适配急诊场景等关键缺口,需通过多学科协作、标准化评价指标和更强治理来支持可解释人工智能在急诊中的透明、问责和安全临床采用。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) has become increasingly relevant for ensuring transparency, interpretability, and trust in clinical decision support systems. In emergency medicine, where decision-making is time-critical and data are often incomplete, XAI provides significant opportunities while also raising ethical and methodological challenges. Despite the rapid growth of AI applications in acute care, bibliometric studies explicitly integrating explainability and ethics remain limited.
METHODS: A bibliometric analysis of 433 publications on XAI in emergency medicine was conducted using the Web of Science Core Collection. The search covered 1986 through November 2025 and included peer-reviewed research articles and reviews in English related to emergency medicine, artificial intelligence, explainability, and ethics. Bibliometric indicators (publication trends, citation counts, journals, authors, and countries) were analyzed using Bibliometrix (R), while VOSviewer was used to visualize thematic clusters and keyword co-occurrence. Citations were analyzed as cumulative counts up to November 2025 and normalized to per-publication counts per year.
RESULTS: Research output increased sharply after 2018, peaking in 2023 with approximately 90 publications, reflecting the growing focus on interpretability and transparency in emergency care. Cumulative citations exceeded 1,400 by 2025. The United States, the United Kingdom, and China were the most productive countries. Annals of Emergency Medicine, NPJ Digital Medicine, and BMJ Open were the most influential journals, while Ong M.E.H., Dwivedi G., Stewart J., Wang Y., and Li J. emerged as leading contributors. Thematic mapping revealed four major clusters: (1) methodological development of interpretable models, (2) clinical applications in triage, imaging, and sepsis risk prediction, (3) ethical and human-factor dimensions (bias, accountability, transparency), and (4) emerging topics such as large language models. Despite rapid progress, most studies remained retrospective and lacked standardized interpretability metrics, multicenter validation, and consistent reporting of explainability outputs.
CONCLUSION: Research on XAI in emergency medicine is expanding rapidly and is increasingly shaped by a small group of influential journals and authors. However, critical gaps remain, including the limited availability of prospective studies, insufficient clinician involvement, and ethical frameworks that are not yet fully tailored to emergency settings. Addressing these gaps through multidisciplinary collaboration, standardized evaluation metrics, and stronger governance will be important to support transparency, accountability, and the safe clinical adoption of XAI in emergency medicine.
参考来源
- Fındık M. Research trends and ethical perspectives on explainable artificial intelligence in emergency medicine: a bibliometric analysis. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med. 2026. PMID: 41491985. doi:10.1186/s13049-025-01540-x
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。