改良德尔菲法制定院前急救医疗服务中时间依赖性照护的共识定义
该研究采用改良德尔菲法,由22名加拿大两省关键知情人(医疗第一响应者、急救员和医生)进行四轮投票,先就时间依赖性照护的定义达成共识,再对29项临床干预和34项药理干预进行分类。共识定义为:根据省级方案应接受该干预的大多数患者,若在初始呼叫后8分钟内未单独实施该干预,其健康或安全将受到直接损害。专家组对63项干预中的52项(82.5%)达成共识,其中17项(32.7%)被投票认定为时间依赖性,包括11项临床干预(64.7%)和6项药理干预(35.3%)。临床干预包括气道吸引或解除梗阻、环甲膜切开术、正压通气、胸部减压、心肺复苏、除颤、心脏电复律、起搏和出血控制;药理干预包括拟交感神经药、热量剂、抗心律失常药、抗惊厥药或镇静剂类药物。
要点
- 时间依赖性照护共识定义:根据省级方案应接受该干预的大多数患者,若在初始呼叫后8分钟内未单独实施该干预,其健康或安全将受到直接损害。
- 22名加拿大两省专家经四轮德尔菲投票,对63项干预中的52项(82.5%)达成共识,其中17项(32.7%)被认定为时间依赖性干预。
- 被认定为时间依赖性的临床干预共11项(占17项的64.7%),包括气道吸引或解除梗阻、环甲膜切开术、正压通气、胸部减压、心肺复苏、除颤、心脏电复律、起搏和出血控制。
- 被认定为时间依赖性的药理干预共6项(占17项的35.3%),包括拟交感神经药、热量剂、抗心律失常药、抗惊厥药或镇静剂类药物。
- 专家组认为该定义和干预清单可作为工具用于改善院前照护和系统绩效。
适用人群与场景
- 加拿大两省院前急救系统,涵盖医疗第一响应者、急救员和医生。
- 针对院前急救场景中根据省级方案应接受特定干预的患者。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 时间依赖性照护共识定义:根据省级方案应接受该干预的大多数患者,若在初始呼叫后8分钟内未单独实施该干预,其健康或安全将受到直接损害。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:改良德尔菲法,四轮投票。
- 专家组:22名加拿大两省关键知情人,代表医疗第一响应者、急救员和医生。
- 评估干预:29项临床干预和34项药理干预,共63项。
- 共识达成:63项干预中52项(82.5%)达成共识。
- 时间依赖性认定:达成共识的52项中17项(32.7%)被投票认定为时间依赖性,其中临床干预11项(64.7%)、药理干预6项(35.3%)。
- 时间依赖性临床干预包括:气道吸引或解除梗阻、环甲膜切开术、正压通气、胸部减压、心肺复苏、除颤、心脏电复律、起搏和出血控制。
- 时间依赖性药理干预包括:拟交感神经药、热量剂、抗心律失常药、抗惊厥药或镇静剂类药物。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:改良德尔菲法共识(专家意见)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 专家组认为该时间依赖性照护定义和干预清单可作为工具用于改善院前照护和系统绩效。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Just as prospective differentiation between true emergencies and calls for subacute patients is critical to the delivery of prehospital care, retrospective differentiation is critical to research and quality improvement. Determining the acuity of patients based on the type of care they received could complement the vital-sign-based instruments currently popular, yet imperfect. The study aim was to create a consensus definition of time-dependent care and a list of time-dependent interventions in paramedicine.
METHODS: The study was a Delphi approach consisting of four rounds of voting by a bi-provincial panel of 22 Canadian key informants representing medical first responders, paramedics, and physicians - first to agree on a definition of time-dependent care - then to categorize 29 clinical and 34 pharmacological interventions.
RESULTS: Based on the consensus definition of "A majority of patients who should receive the intervention, according to provincial protocols, would suffer a direct prejudice to their health or safety if the intervention, provided on its own, was not performed within eight minutes of the initial call," the panel reached consensus on 52 of 63 interventions (82.5%), of which 17 (32.7%) were voted time-dependent (11 clinical [64.7%] and six pharmacological [35.3%]). Clinical interventions included airway suction or de-obstruction, cricothyrotomy, positive pressure ventilation, chest decompression, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, defibrillation, cardioversion, pacing, and hemorrhage control. Pharmacological interventions included medication classed as sympathomimetics, caloric agents, antiarrhythmic agents, anticonvulsants, or tranquilizers.
CONCLUSION: The panel reached a consensus on a definition of time-dependent care and used this to identify prehospital interventions that could serve as an instrument to improve care and system performance.
参考来源
- de Montigny L, Lee R, Lang ES, et al. A Modified Delphi Process to Develop Consensus Definitions of Time-Dependent Care by Paramedic Services Systems. Prehosp Disaster Med. 2025. PMID: 41257908. doi:10.1017/S1049023X25101519
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。