心脏骤停模拟教育中反馈的有效性与感知价值:一项混合方法系统评价
该混合方法系统评价纳入160篇文献(154篇定量、3篇定性、3篇混合方法),评估心脏骤停模拟教育中反馈的有效性与感知价值。结果显示,无论人工反馈还是设备反馈均能改善表现,但客观设备反馈更受偏好。当前文献主要关注定量方法测量的技术技能,对非技术方面及参与者体验的定性探索有限。结论认为反馈应与学习者教育目标一致,未来研究需整合定量与定性方法以全面了解复苏指南推荐的技术与非技术技能获取。
要点
- 所有反馈(人工或设备)均能改善心脏骤停模拟中的表现,但客观设备反馈更受偏好。
- 反馈与模拟本身同等重要,应与学习者教育目标一致。
- 当前文献主要聚焦定量方法测量的技术技能,非技术方面研究有限。
- 纳入160篇文献(154篇定量、3篇定性、3篇混合方法),共筛选3455篇。
- 未来研究需整合定量与定性方法以评估复苏指南推荐的技术与非技术技能。
适用人群与场景
- 医疗、护理、医学生及专业人员的院前或院内模拟教育场景,纳入在心脏骤停模拟前、中、后提供反馈的研究。
- 排除聚焦非心脏骤停模拟、不以反馈为结局或报告真实心脏骤停经历的研究。
研究设计与关键结果
- 混合方法系统评价,筛选3455篇文献,203篇评估合格性,最终纳入160篇(154篇定量、3篇定性、3篇混合方法)。
- 呈现三个主题:所有反馈(人工或设备)均改善表现;客观设备反馈更受偏好;文献主要聚焦定量方法测量的技术技能,非技术方面及参与者体验的定性探索有限。
- 结论:反馈在心脏骤停模拟教育中与模拟本身同等重要,应与学习者教育目标一致;非技术方面报告不足,未来研究需整合定量与定性方法。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:混合方法系统评价,纳入定量、定性与混合方法研究,采用收敛整合方法(定量结果「质性化」)及定性内容分析进行叙事综合。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为反馈在心脏骤停模拟教育中与模拟本身同等重要,应与学习者教育目标一致。
- 作者认为未来研究需整合定量与定性方法,以获取复苏指南推荐的技术与非技术技能获取的必要见解。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: This review evaluated the effectiveness and perceived value of feedback methods in cardiac arrest simulation-based education for healthcare, nursing, medical students and professionals.
METHODS: A mixed-method systematic review was conducted, incorporating quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-method studies on feedback provided before, during, or after cardiac arrest simulations. Studies focusing on non-cardiac arrest simulations, not focusing on feedback outcomes, or reporting on real cardiac arrest experiences were excluded. A convergent integrated approach to data synthesis was used, with quantitative findings "qualitised" and a qualitative content analysis providing a narrative synthesis.
RESULTS: Out of 3455 articles screened, 203 were assessed for eligibility, and 160 were included (154 quantitative, 3 qualitative, 3 mixed method). Three themes emerged regarding feedback effectiveness and value in cardiac arrest simulation education. All feedback, whether human or device-based, improves performance. However, objective, device-based feedback is preferred. Current literature primarily focuses on technical skills measured by quantitative methods, with limited research on non-technical aspects and qualitative explorations of participant experiences.
CONCLUSION: Feedback in cardiac arrest simulation education is just as important as the simulation itself and should align with the learner's educational objectives. There is a notable underreporting of integral non-technical aspects of cardiac arrest management and the use of appropriate use of qualitative methodologies to investigate them. To gain the necessary insights into both the technical and non-technical skill acquisition recommended in resuscitation guidelines, future research needs to integrate quantitative and qualitative approaches.
参考来源
- Vella R, Baker E, Akerjordet K, et al. The effectiveness and perceived value of feedback used in cardiac arrest simulation education: a mixed-method systematic review. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med. 2025. PMID: 41074008. doi:10.1186/s13049-025-01456-6
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。