蛇咬伤急救教育材料质量评估的德尔菲共识清单
研究通过两轮德尔菲法,由21个国家的38名蛇咬伤管理、急诊医学与毒理学专家对24条初拟清单进行评分,共识阈值为≥75%专家给出≥7分。最终形成20条清单,涵盖安全(3条)、呼救(1条)、评估(2条)、转运(1条)、生命体征(1条)、恢复体位(1条)、心肺复苏(1条)、支持(1条)、体位(1条)、观察(1条)、处理咬伤部位(3条)、限制体力活动(1条)、制动(2条)及避免不必要操作(1条)。作者认为该清单可作为教育者、医疗专业人员和机构确保教育材料准确性与完整性的工具。未来工作应聚焦验证清单有效性并适配不同语言和区域实践。
要点
- 清单共20条,涵盖安全、呼救、评估、转运、生命体征、恢复体位、心肺复苏、支持、体位、观察、处理咬伤部位、限制体力活动、制动及避免不必要操作。
- 共识标准为≥75%专家对每条给出≥7分方可纳入。
- 38名完成两轮德尔菲的专家来自21个国家,急性医学与毒理学经验中位数16年。
- 作者认为该清单可用于核查蛇咬伤急救教育材料的准确性与完整性。
- 作者指出未来需验证清单有效性并适配不同语言和区域实践。
适用人群与场景
- 蛇咬伤急救教育材料的编写者、教育者、医疗专业人员和相关机构。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 德尔菲共识阈值:每条项目需≥75%的专家给出≥7分方可纳入。
研究设计与关键结果
- 两轮德尔菲研究,初始48名参与者中38名(79.2%)完成两轮,代表21个国家,急性医学与毒理学经验中位数16年。
- 最终清单20条,包括安全(n=3)、呼救(n=1)、评估(n=2)、转运(n=1)、生命体征(n=1)、恢复体位(n=1)、心肺复苏(n=1)、支持(n=1)、体位(n=1)、观察(n=1)、处理咬伤部位(n=3)、限制体力活动(n=1)、制动(n=2)及避免不必要操作(n=1)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:德尔菲共识。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为该清单可作为教育者、医疗专业人员和机构确保蛇咬伤急救教育材料准确性与完整性的工具。
- 作者指出未来工作应聚焦验证清单有效性并适配不同语言和区域实践。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Distribution of inaccurate or misleading information concerning snakebite first aid can potentiate inappropriate and harmful practices in real-life snakebite incidents. This study aimed to develop a consensus-based checklist for evaluating the quality of educational materials on snakebite first aid.
METHODS: Experts in snakebite management, emergency medicine and toxicology were recruited through a structured invitation process. In a two-round Delphi exercise, the experts completed questionnaires to rate each item of a pre-developed 24-item checklist. Item inclusion was determined by a consensus threshold of ≥ 7 points from ≥ 75% of the expert panel. Anonymous inputs on modifying or adding items were solicited.
RESULTS: Of the 48 initial participants, 38 (79.2%) completed both rounds (representatives of 21 nations with a median of 16 years of experience in acute medicine and toxicology). The Delphi process resulted in a 20-item final checklist encompassing critical aspects of snakebite first aid, including safety (n = 3), call for help (n = 1), assessment (n = 2), transport (n = 1), vital signs (n = 1), recovery position (n = 1), CPR (n = 1), support (n = 1), positioning (n = 1), observation (n = 1), handling the bite site (n = 3), restricting physical activity (n = 1), immobilisation (n = 2) and avoidance of unnecessary actions (n = 1).
CONCLUSION: The formulated consensus-based checklist may serve as a tool for educators, healthcare professionals and organisations to ensure the accuracy and completeness of educational materials, ultimately contributing to improved snakebite first aid management outcomes. Future work should focus on validating the checklist's effectiveness and adapting it to various languages and regional practices, contributing to a standardised framework for snakebite education globally.
参考来源
- Gautam A, Birkun AA. A Delphi Consensus Checklist for Evaluating the Quality of Snakebite First Aid Education Materials. Trop Med Int Health. 2025. PMID: 40984752. doi:10.1111/tmi.70038
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。