文献速递中毒与环境急症

法国毒物控制中心中毒因果关系评估方法的可重复性与有效性评价

Evaluation of the reproducibility and validity of the use of the causality assessment method for poisonings designed and applied by the French poison control centres.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Toxicol (Phila) · 2025-07-14
一句话结论法国毒物控制中心使用的标准化因果关系评估方法在真实中毒病例中评者间一致性为中等(加权Light's kappa=0.55),区分I0与I1-I4的敏感度为0.90、特异度为0.62。

本研究评估法国毒物控制中心设计的标准化中毒因果关系评估方法(决策树,含I0-I4五个等级和六个决定因素)的评者间信度和有效性。参考组毒理学家从法国国家中毒数据库随机选取86例病例并共识确定参考因果关系等级,19名非参考组毒理学家作为评分者独立评估。评者间一致性加权Light's kappa为0.55(中等一致),I0 versus I1-I4的敏感度为0.90、特异度为0.62。暴露途径类别中眼部暴露kappa最高(0.70),各决定因素kappa从0.31(暴露)到0.54(文献参考)不等。作者结论认为该方法有用,但部分决定因素的编码需改进。

要点

  • 19名评分者评估86例真实中毒病例,评者间一致性加权Light's kappa=0.55(中等一致)。
  • 以参考组共识等级为标准,区分I0 versus I1-I4时敏感度0.90、特异度0.62。
  • 五种病例类别中眼部暴露途径的kappa最高(0.70)。
  • 六个决定因素的kappa从0.31(暴露)到0.54(文献参考)不等,暴露因素一致性最低。
  • 评者间一致性随经验增加而提高,但最经验丰富的组除外。

适用人群与场景

  • 涉及多种外源物质的中毒病例,来自法国国家中毒数据库的真实病例。
  • 病例按暴露途径分为五类,其中口服途径包含两种情形。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 因果关系评估方法基于决策树,包含五个递增等级(I0-I4)和六个决定因素。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型为方法学评价研究,参考组毒理学家共识确定86例随机选取病例的参考因果关系等级,19名非参考组毒理学家作为评分者独立评估。
  • 评者间一致性加权Light's kappa=0.55(中等一致)。
  • 与参考组比较,I0 versus I1-I4的敏感度为0.90、特异度为0.62。
  • 五种病例类别中眼部暴露途径kappa最高(0.70)。
  • 六个决定因素的kappa从0.31(暴露)到0.54(文献参考)不等。
  • 评者间一致性随评分者经验增加而提高,但最经验丰富的组除外。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型为方法学评价研究,评估法国毒物控制中心因果关系评估方法的评者间信度和有效性。
  • 局限:部分决定因素的编码需要改进;需进一步改进因果关系评估方法以增强其效用。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为法国毒物控制中心使用的因果关系评估方法有用,但部分决定因素的编码应改进。
  • 作者认为进一步改进因果关系评估方法将增强其效用。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

INTRODUCTION: French poison control centres have developed and use a standardised causality assessment method based on a decision tree for poisoning cases involving a wide range of xenobiotics, which includes five ascending levels (I0-I4) and six determinants. This study was designed to evaluate inter-rater reliability and the validity of using this method.

METHODS: A reference group of toxicologists identified five categories of cases - based on the route of exposure with two circumstances for the oral route - recorded in the French National Database of Poisonings. The reference group assessed by consensus the level of causality of each randomly selected case as the reference level. Toxicologists from poison centres, not belonging to the reference group, were selected as raters. Inter-rater reliability was assessed using weighted Light's kappa. The results of raters were compared against the reference to test the validity of the method. A subgroup analysis of inter-rater reliability was also performed according to rater experience, case category, and causality determinant.

RESULTS: Nineteen raters reviewed the 86 cases selected by the reference group. Kappa was equal to 0.55 (moderate agreement). Sensitivity was 0.90 and specificity was 0.62 when comparing I0 versus I1-I4 classes. The agreement between raters increased with experience except for the most experienced group. Ocular route of exposure had the highest kappa (0.70) among the five case categories. Kappa for the causality determinants varied from 0.31 (exposure) to 0.54 (bibliographical references).

DISCUSSION: The causality assessment of poisonings was carried out on real-life cases. Our results are close to those of studies on causality methods in pharmacovigilance and nutrivigilance, despite a wider scope of application.

CONCLUSION: Causality assessment method employed by French poison control centres is useful, although coding of some determinants should be improved. Further refinement of the causality assessment method will also further enhance its utility.

来源:Clin Toxicol (Phila),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Sinno-Tellier S, Délepine D, Vodovar D, et al. Evaluation of the reproducibility and validity of the use of the causality assessment method for poisonings designed and applied by the French poison control centres. Clin Toxicol (Phila). 2025. PMID: 40654115. doi:10.1080/15563650.2025.2515239

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。