院前创伤汇编:疑似骨盆骨折的评估与管理——NAEMSP立场声明与资源文件
该文件为NAEMSP基于结构化文献回顾制定的院前疑似骨盆骨折管理推荐。核心要点包括:血流动力学不稳定患者应仔细排查骨盆骨折以外的休克原因;单纯体格检查(包括骨盆手法稳定性测试)识别骨盆骨折既不敏感也不特异且可能造成伤害;骨盆周径压迫装置(PCCD)缺乏降低创伤性出血或死亡率的充分证据且存在医源性损伤风险,应重新考虑其院前使用;若使用PCCD,须确保置于转子上方且双足内旋固定;符合国家创伤分诊指南其他分诊标准者应尽可能送往主要创伤中心,特定情况下可考虑空中转运。
要点
- 骨盆周径压迫装置缺乏降低创伤性出血或死亡率的充分证据,且可能造成医源性损伤,NAEMSP认为应重新考虑其院前使用。
- 骨盆手法稳定性测试既不敏感也不特异,且可能造成伤害,EMS临床医师应认识到单凭体格检查准确识别骨盆骨折的挑战。
- 若使用PCCD,须确保置于转子上方的解剖适当位置,并通过将双足固定在一起使双腿内旋。
- 疑似骨盆骨折且符合国家创伤分诊指南其他分诊标准的患者,应尽可能送往主要创伤中心;特定情况下空中EMS转运可能适当。
- 骨盆夹板固定是低频技能且并非无风险,将其纳入方案的机构应确保EMS临床医师接受由质量改进项目指导的初始及持续培训。
适用人群与场景
- 院前环境中由EMS临床医师接诊的、因多种损伤机制导致疑似重大骨盆骨折的创伤患者。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 疑似骨盆骨折且符合国家创伤分诊指南其他分诊标准的患者,应送往主要创伤中心。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 血流动力学不稳定的疑似骨盆骨折创伤患者,应仔细评估其他休克来源,因休克常由合并损伤所致而非直接归因于骨盆骨折。
- 若使用PCCD,须确保置于转子上方的解剖适当位置,并通过将双足固定在一起使双腿内旋。
- 疑似骨盆骨折且符合国家创伤分诊指南其他分诊标准者,尽可能送往主要创伤中心;特定情况下空中EMS转运可能适当。
- 将PCCD纳入方案的机构应确保EMS临床医师接受初始及持续培训教育,涵盖骨盆骨折识别与管理的认知与精神运动能力,培训应全面并由质量改进项目指导,强调骨盆骨折识别、患者选择及骨盆夹板适当放置与张力。
- EMS医师应在制定课程和领导质量管理项目中发挥作用,确保EMS临床医师在骨盆骨折识别与管理方面得到适当培训,且干预措施适当、安全、有效。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 血流动力学不稳定的疑似骨盆骨折创伤患者,休克常由合并损伤引起,须排查其他休克来源。
- 骨盆手法稳定性测试既不敏感也不特异,且可能造成伤害。
- PCCD缺乏降低创伤性出血或死亡率的充分证据,且存在医源性损伤可能。
研究设计与关键结果
- NAEMSP进行了结构化文献回顾,以制定疑似骨盆骨折院前管理的循证推荐。
- 院内证据显示骨盆骨折稳定可改善患者结局,但该证据被外推以推广EMS临床医师在院前使用骨盆稳定干预。
- 院前准确识别骨盆骨折存在显著挑战,PCCD院前骨盆稳定干预的临床获益存疑。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:NAEMSP立场声明与资源文件,基于结构化文献回顾制定。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- NAEMSP认为应重新考虑PCCD的院前使用,因缺乏其降低创伤性出血或死亡率的充分证据且可能造成医源性损伤。
- EMS临床医师应认识到单凭体格检查准确识别骨盆骨折的挑战,骨盆手法稳定性测试既不敏感也不特异且可能造成伤害。
- 对血流动力学不稳定的疑似骨盆骨折创伤患者,EMS临床医师应仔细评估其他休克来源。
- 使用PCCD时须确保置于转子上方且双足内旋固定。
- 符合国家创伤分诊指南其他分诊标准的疑似骨盆骨折患者应尽可能送往主要创伤中心,特定情况下空中EMS转运可能适当。
- 将PCCD纳入方案的机构应确保EMS临床医师接受由质量改进项目指导的全面初始及持续培训。
- EMS医师应在制定课程和领导质量管理项目中发挥作用。
指南或共识出处
- 院前创伤汇编:疑似骨盆骨折的评估与管理——NAEMSP立场声明与资源文件(Prehospital Trauma Compendium: Evaluation and Management of Suspected Pelvis Fractures - An NAEMSP Position Statement and Resource Document),来源:Prehosp Emerg Care。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Emergency Medical Services (EMS) clinicians may encounter trauma patients with major pelvic fractures from multiple mechanisms of injury. In-hospital evidence that stabilization of pelvic fractures leads to improved patient outcomes has been extrapolated to promote the use of pelvic stabilization interventions by EMS clinicians in the prehospital setting. However, there are significant challenges in accurately identifying pelvic fractures in the field, and the clinical benefit of prehospital pelvic stabilizing interventions with use of pelvic circumferential compression devices (PCCDs) is questionable. Therefore, NAEMSP conducted a structured review of the literature to develop evidence-guided recommendations for the prehospital management of suspected pelvic fractures.
While hemorrhagic shock directly attributable to pelvic fractures may occur, concomitant injuries are commonly the cause of shock. EMS clinicians should carefully evaluate for other sources of shock in the hemodynamically unstable trauma patient with suspected pelvic fractures.EMS clinicians should recognize the challenges in accurately identifying pelvic fractures by physical exam alone. Manual stability testing of the pelvis is neither sensitive nor specific and may cause harm.Prehospital use of PCCDs should be reconsidered given lack of proven clinical benefit including insufficient evidence that PCCDs reduce traumatic hemorrhage or mortality, and potential for iatrogenic injuries.If PCCDs are used, care must be taken to ensure they are placed in anatomically appropriate position over the trochanters, and that the legs are internally rotated by securing the feet together.EMS clinicians should transport patients with suspected pelvis fractures who also meet other triage criteria of the National Trauma Triage Guidelines to a major trauma center, when possible. Transport via air-based EMS may be appropriate in select circumstances.Pelvic splinting is a low-frequency skill that is not without risk to the patient. Agencies that include use of PCCDs in their protocols should ensure their EMS clinicians receive initial and ongoing training and education that addresses the development of both cognitive and psychomotor aptitudes related to pelvic fracture identification and management. The training should be comprehensive and directed by quality improvement programs. Pelvic fracture identification, proper patient selection, and appropriate placement and tension of pelvic splints should be emphasized.EMS physicians play an important role in developing curricula and leading quality management programs to both ensure that EMS clinicians are properly trained in the recognition and management of pelvis fractures and that interventions for pelvis fractures are performed appropriately, safely, and effectively.
参考来源
- Lyng JW, Corsa JG, Raetzke BD, et al. Prehospital Trauma Compendium: Evaluation and Management of Suspected Pelvis Fractures - An NAEMSP Position Statement and Resource Document. Prehosp Emerg Care. 2025. PMID: 40729523. doi:10.1080/10903127.2025.2540420
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。