无呼吸机天数的最优分析方法是什么?一项模拟研究
该研究通过模拟16个各300人的数据集(对照组与干预组生存率和通气时长不同),比较12种统计方法对无呼吸机天数(VFDs)分析的I类错误率和统计功效,并应用于LIVE、ARMA、ACURASYS、COVIDICUS四项临床试验数据。多数方法能有效控制I类错误率,但零膨胀及跨栏泊松/负二项计数子模型和死亡原因别Cox回归模型除外。时间-事件方法、Mann-Whitney检验、比例优势模型和胜率比在检测生存获益和通气时长效应方面表现最佳。在真实数据集中,多状态模型、Mann-Whitney检验、比例优势模型和胜率比通常显示VFDs与随机分组间存在显著关联。作者结论认为多状态模型可推荐为分析VFDs的最优方法。
要点
- 模拟研究比较12种统计方法分析无呼吸机天数,多数方法能有效控制I类错误率。
- 零膨胀及跨栏泊松/负二项计数子模型和死亡原因别Cox回归模型未能有效控制I类错误率。
- 时间-事件方法、Mann-Whitney检验、比例优势模型和胜率比在检测生存获益和通气时长效应方面通常表现最佳。
- 在四项真实临床试验数据集中,多状态模型、Mann-Whitney检验、比例优势模型和胜率比通常显示VFDs与随机分组间显著关联。
- 作者结论推荐多状态模型作为分析VFDs的最优方法,因其表现优于其他方法且效应量更易解释。
研究设计与关键结果
- 模拟研究:模拟16个各300人的数据集,比较对照组与干预组在不同生存率和通气时长下的表现,评估12种统计方法的I类错误率和统计功效。
- 多数统计方法能有效控制I类错误率,但零膨胀及跨栏泊松/负二项计数子模型和死亡原因别Cox回归模型除外。
- 检测生存获益和通气时长效应的功效因方法而异,时间-事件方法、Mann-Whitney检验、比例优势模型和胜率比通常表现最佳。
- 敏感性分析观察到相似结果。
- 在四项真实临床试验数据集(LIVE、ARMA、ACURASYS、COVIDICUS)中,多状态模型、Mann-Whitney检验、比例优势模型和胜率比通常显示VFDs与随机分组间存在显著关联。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:模拟研究,并应用于四项临床试验数据集。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,多状态模型可推荐作为分析无呼吸机天数的最优方法,因其表现优于其他方法且效应量比比例优势模型和胜率比更易解释。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「适用人群与场景」「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Ventilator-free days (VFDs) are a composite outcome in critical care research, reflecting both survival and mechanical ventilation duration. However, analysis methods for VFDs are inconsistent, with some focusing on counts and others on time-to-event outcomes, while other approaches such as the multistate model and the win ratio have emerged. We aimed to evaluate various statistical models through simulations to identify the optimal approach for analysing VFDs.
METHODS: First, 16 datasets of 300 individuals were simulated, comparing a control group to an intervention with varying survival rates and ventilation durations. Various statistical models were evaluated for statistical power and Type I error rate. Four clinical trial datasets (LIVE study, NCT02149589; ARMA study, NCT00000579; ACURASYS study, NCT00299650; COVIDICUS study, NCT04344730) were then used to apply the same statistical models to analyse VFDs. Twelve statistical methods were evaluated, including count-based, time-to-event approaches, and the win-ratio. Additionally, sensitivity analyses were conducted.
RESULTS: Most statistical methods effectively controlled Type I error rate, except for the zero-inflated and hurdle Poisson/negative binomial count submodels, as well as the cause-specific Cox regression model for death. The power to detect survival benefit and ventilation duration effects varied, with time-to-event approaches, the Mann-Whitney test, the proportional odds model and the win ratio generally performing best. Similar results were observed in sensitivity analyses. In the real datasets, the multistate model, the Mann-Whitney test, the proportional odds model and the win ratio generally showed a significant association between VFDs and randomisation groups.
CONCLUSIONS: The multistate model could be recommended as the optimal approach for analysing VFDs, as it outperformed the other methods and offers a more interpretable effect size than the proportional odds model and the win ratio.
参考来源
- Renard Triché L, Jabaudon M, Molinari N, et al. What is the optimal approach to analyse ventilator-free days? A simulation study. Crit Care. 2025. PMID: 40537834. doi:10.1186/s13054-025-05474-9
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。