文献速递重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

金钱激励对同行评审接受与完成的影响:一项准随机干预试验

Effect of Monetary Incentives on Peer Review Acceptance and Completion: A Quasi-Randomized Interventional Trial.
PubMed 文献 · Crit Care Med · 2025-03-06
一句话结论向《Critical Care Medicine》审稿人提供250美元现金激励,使邀请至完成评审的转化率从42.2%升至49.8%(p=0.04),完成速度约快1天。

该研究在《Critical Care Medicine》期刊开展准随机、盲法、交替处理设计的干预试验,纳入2023年9月至2024年3月共6个月(排除2周假期窗口)所有收到审稿邀请的审稿人。以2周为交替区块,邀请函随机附250美元审稿完成报酬(干预组)或不附现金(对照组)。主要结局邀请至完成评审转化率干预组49.8%(206/414)高于对照组42.2%(127/301),p=0.04;Cox比例风险比1.30(1.04-1.62),p=0.02,评审时间约快1天(11 vs 12天);编辑评估的评审质量两组无差异。

要点

  • 在《Critical Care Medicine》6个月研究中,附250美元现金的审稿邀请完成率49.8%(206/414),无现金邀请为42.2%(127/301),p=0.04。
  • 现金激励组审稿完成更快:Cox比例风险比1.30(1.04-1.62),p=0.02,评审时间约缩短1天(11 vs 12天)。
  • 审稿邀请接受率现金组52.7%(218/414),对照组47.8%(144/301)。
  • 编辑评估的333份提交报告中205份(61.6%)被评估,两组评审质量无差异。
  • 作者结论:现金激励使受邀审稿人完成评审的比例出现适度增加。

适用人群与场景

  • 2023年9月至2024年3月共6个月(排除2周假期窗口)期间收到《Critical Care Medicine》研究论文审稿邀请的所有审稿人。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 以2周为交替区块发送审稿邀请函:干预组邀请函附接受审稿请求可获250美元报酬,对照组为标准邀请函无现金报酬。
  • 完成激励邀请的审稿人由期刊寄出250美元支票。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 设计:准随机、盲法、交替处理设计的干预试验,在同行评审专科期刊《Critical Care Medicine》进行。
  • 共发出715份审稿邀请,其中414份(57.9%)包含激励提议。
  • 主要结局邀请至完成评审转化率:激励组49.8%(206/414)vs 对照组42.2%(127/301),p=0.04。
  • 邀请接受率:激励组52.7%(218/414)vs 对照组47.8%(144/301)。
  • 生存分析:附激励邀请平均完成更快,Cox比例风险比1.30(1.04-1.62),p=0.02,对应评审时间约快1天(11 vs 12天)。
  • 共333份审稿报告提交,其中205份(61.6%)由编辑评估,研究组间评审质量无差异。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:准随机、盲法、交替处理设计的干预试验。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者结论认为,为完成审稿报告提供现金激励可使专科医学期刊受邀审稿人完成评审的比例出现适度增加。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: Peer review typically relies on experts volunteering their time to review research. This process presents challenges for journals that may face a shortage of qualified referees, resulting in either delay in handling papers or less thorough review than is optimal. We experimentally tested the impact of providing cash incentives to complete peer review assignments at Critical Care Medicine .

DESIGN: Quasi-randomized, blinded, interventional study with an alternating treatment design.

SETTING: Critical Care Medicine (CCM ), a peer-reviewed specialty journal.

SUBJECTS: All reviewers receiving requests from CCM to review research articles during a 6-month period from September 2023 to March 2024 (excluding a 2-wk holiday window).

INTERVENTIONS: In alternating 2-week blocks, reviewer invitation letters were sent out, including either an offer of $250 for accepting the peer review request (treatment) or the standard letter with no cash offer (control). Reviewers who fulfilled incentivized invitations received a $250 check from the journal.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Our primary outcome was the rate of invitation-to-completed-review conversion, defined as the number of reviews submitted divided by the number of reviewer invitations sent out. Secondary outcomes included the "on-time" conversion rate, invitation acceptance rate, time to invitation acceptance, time to review submission, and review quality. Seven hundred fifteen reviewer invitations were sent out, 414 of which (57.9%) included an incentive offer. Two hundred eighteen (52.7%) of the incentivized invitations were accepted, compared with 144 (47.8%) in the control group. A greater proportion of reviewer invitations led to submitted peer review reports in the incentive group than in the control group (49.8% [206/414] vs. 42.2% [127/301]; p = 0.04). In a "survival analysis," invitations sent with an incentive offer were fulfilled faster on average (Cox proportional hazard ratio, 1.30 [1.04-1.62]; p = 0.02), corresponding to quicker review times of approximately 1 day (11 vs. 12 d). Of the 333 reviewer reports submitted, 205 (61.6%) were assessed by editors, with no difference in review quality noted between study arms.

CONCLUSIONS: Providing cash incentive for completing peer review reports resulted in a modest increase in the share of invited reviewers who complete reviews for a specialty medical journal.

来源:Crit Care Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Cotton CS, Alam A, Tosta S, et al. Effect of Monetary Incentives on Peer Review Acceptance and Completion: A Quasi-Randomized Interventional Trial. Crit Care Med. 2025. PMID: 40047491. doi:10.1097/CCM.0000000000006637

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。