创伤后新发精神健康问题的长期结局与决定因素
该回顾性、基于人群的链接数据队列研究纳入澳大利亚西部5家成人创伤医院的29191例创伤患者(ISS>15及随机选取的ISS<16者),随访中位99.8个月。在无精神健康病史的26958例患者中,3299例(11.3%)新发精神健康问题。新发精神健康问题与创伤再入院(aHR 1.30;95%CI 1.23-1.37)、自杀(aHR 3.14;95%CI 2.00-4.91)及全因死亡(aHR 1.24;95%CI 1.12-1.38)风险升高相关。作者认为,对创伤患者尤其是脆弱亚群进行精神健康随访可能是有必要的。
要点
- 无精神健康病史的创伤患者中11.3%新发精神健康问题,药物依赖8.2%(其中阿片依赖1.4%)、神经症5.4%。
- 新发精神健康问题与自杀风险升高相关(aHR 3.14;95%CI 2.00-4.91;P<.001)。
- 新发精神健康问题与创伤再入院(aHR 1.30;95%CI 1.23-1.37)及全因死亡(aHR 1.24;95%CI 1.12-1.38)风险升高相关。
- 年轻、失业、单身/离异/分居(vs已婚)、原住民、低社会经济地位及创伤性脑损伤与新发精神健康问题相关。
- 吸烟和饮酒与创伤后新发精神健康问题风险升高显著相关。
适用人群与场景
- 1994年1月至2020年9月期间入住澳大利亚西部5家成人创伤医院(皇家珀斯医院、弗里曼特尔医院、乔达拉普医院、查尔斯·盖尔德纳爵士医院、菲奥娜·斯坦利医院)的17岁及以上创伤患者。
- 所有ISS>15的主要创伤患者均纳入,另按1:2随机选取ISS<16的创伤患者。
- 因轻伤未需专科治疗而留在区域医院的患者未纳入;仅在急诊就诊后离院的轻伤患者未纳入;仅纳入后续住院时诊断的精神健康问题,门诊诊断者未纳入。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为回顾性、基于人群的链接数据队列研究,纳入29191例成人创伤患者(中位年龄42岁,IQR 27-65;男性19383例,66.4%;中位ISS 9,IQR 5-16;ISS>15者9405例,ISS<16者19786例),随访中位99.8个月(IQR 61.2-148.5)。
- 2233例(7.6%)创伤前有精神健康问题;无精神健康病史的26958例中,3299例(11.3%)新发精神健康问题,包括药物依赖2391例(8.2%,其中阿片依赖419例[1.4%])和神经症1574例(5.4%,包括PTSD)。
- 新发精神健康问题与创伤再入院(aHR 1.30;95%CI 1.23-1.37;P<.001)、自杀(aHR 3.14;95%CI 2.00-4.91;P<.001)及全因死亡(aHR 1.24;95%CI 1.12-1.38;P<.001)风险升高相关。
- 年轻、失业、单身/离异/分居(vs已婚)、原住民、较低社会经济地位及创伤性脑损伤均与新发精神健康问题相关;吸烟和饮酒亦与风险升高显著相关。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:回顾性、基于人群的链接数据队列研究。
- 局限:因轻伤留在区域医院的患者未纳入,可能低估农村地区作为创伤后精神健康问题风险因素的重要性;仅纳入需住院的损伤及后续住院时诊断的精神健康问题,可能低估发生率及影响;数据库未充分捕捉处方药使用、活跃物质滥用及娱乐性药物使用数据,无法确定除吸烟和饮酒外的物质使用是否为风险因素。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,鉴于创伤后新发精神健康问题的负担及其对再入院、自杀和全因死亡风险的长期实质性影响,若有适当的精神健康照护资源提供随访和针对性干预(包括戒烟、酒精使用咨询及阿片依赖治疗),尤其针对脆弱亚群创伤患者,可能改善长期结局。
提炼说明
- 原文未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目。
全文中译12 节 · 点击展开
Introduction
(未能翻译,以下为原文)Injury accounts for substantial morbidity and mortality worldwide. The cost of care for traumatic injuries is staggering.1,2 The development of trauma systems and designated trauma centers has been proven to save lives of patients who would have died without advanced trauma care.3 Nonetheless, recent evidence suggests that trauma mortality and morbidities may follow a multiphasic pattern, with increasing number of survivors experiencing long-term morbidities after hospital discharge.
(未能翻译,以下为原文)Trauma most commonly affects young persons with few preexisting diseases; yet, the results from previous studies4,5,6,7,8 have shown that severely injured patients have a higher cumulative mortality in the years following the initial trauma admission. Many of the severely injured patients sustain trauma involving several body systems. They are at risk of developing long-term physical, mental, and psychological disabilities after their trauma admission. Previous studies9,10,11,12 have described adverse consequences, including the inability to return to previous levels of activity or employment and delayed mortality due to long-term complications of trauma, a second episode of major trauma, or suicides.
(未能翻译,以下为原文)The mental health issues following trauma are not limited to posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD).13 Other mental health conditions, such as suicidality, depression, and substance abuse, have also been reported as sequelae of trauma.14 The Victoria State Trauma Registry in Australia reported on 2757 adult patients with trauma and found that 50% of the survivors experienced ongoing pain or discomfort, and 41% had symptoms of anxiety or depression 3 years after their injuries.15 Although long-term health sequelae of trauma are common and substantial, most trauma hospitals and registries currently do not track patients’ trajectories after trauma hospitalizations, and longitudinal studies of the long-term health outcomes of seriously injured people are sparse. A 2018 Canadian study16 in Ontario with 19 338 patients examined mental health outcomes within 5 years following trauma and found that the survivors of major trauma were at a heightened risk of developing mental health conditions or death by suicide in the years after their injury. Maximizing long-term outcomes, based on data from longitudinal studies, including identifying which groups may benefit the most from intervention after trauma center discharge, is considered the next important challenge that trauma centers must face.17
(未能翻译,以下为原文)Currently, the long-term incidence and determinants of developing new mental health conditions after trauma beyond 5 years of follow-up, including PTSD, neurotic disorders, and suicides, remain uncertain. Furthermore, whether developing new mental health conditions after trauma admission contributes to trauma readmissions and long-term mortality has not been investigated. We hypothesized that among those without a mental health condition before trauma admission, developing a new-onset mental health condition is common, and this could be associated with an increased risk of adverse long-term outcomes. In this study, we aimed to report the incidence and determinants of developing a mental health condition after trauma and its potential long-term association with risk of suicides, trauma readmissions, and all-cause mortality.
Methods
Study Design
(未能翻译,以下为原文)This was a retrospective, population-based, linked-data cohort study of adult patients with trauma in the state of Western Australia. All patients aged 17 years and older with traumatic injuries with an Injury Severity Score (ISS) greater than 15 recorded in the Western Australia’s State Trauma Registry from January 1994 until September 2020 were included; in addition, for each patient with major trauma (ISS >15) included, 2 patients with trauma with a lower severity of injury (ISS <16) were randomly selected for this cohort study. This study was approved by the Department of Health Ethics Committee. Owing to the large number of patients included and the release of only deidentified data to the researchers, a waiver of consent was permitted by the Ethics Committee as per Section 2.3.10 of the Australian National Statement regarding medical research ethics. We adhered to the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) reporting guidelines in reporting our results.
Source of Data
(未能翻译,以下为原文)The Western Australia’s State Trauma Registry is a comprehensive dataset consisting of in-hospital events, from the time of trauma to discharge from the hospital and rehabilitation services. Until 2011, Trauma Registry data were collected individually on separate, but identical, Microsoft Access databases by the individual trauma hospitals. In 2011, all trauma registry data were combined into a single web-based database, the Western Australia State Trauma Registry. The criteria for inclusion into the registry are as follows: all patients with major and minor trauma who present to a hospital for treatment within 7 days of their date of trauma and who were hospitalized for greater than 24 hours at that hospital, unless trauma-related deaths occur within 24 hours of admission. Our cohort included patients who were aged 17 years and older and admitted to 1 or more of the following trauma hospitals in Western Australia: Royal Perth Hospital (1994 to 2020), Fremantle Hospital (2011 to 2020), Joondalup Hospital (2011 to 2020), Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital (2011 to 2020), and Fiona Stanley Hospital (2015 to 2020).
Data Linkage
(未能翻译,以下为原文)To ascertain a comprehensive picture of the trajectory of each individual patient with trauma, we linked the Trauma Registry data with the Department of Health Hospital Morbidity Data Set, Emergency Department Data Set, Mental Health Dataset, and Death Registry, including a 5-year look-back period before the first (or earliest arrival date) trauma admission. The 5-year look-back period aimed to ascertain whether subsequent clinical sequelae were related to preexisting conditions before the first (or index) trauma admission. The Health Hospital Morbidity Data Set contains a vast amount of health data including hospitalization data, such as length of stay, primary admission diagnosis, other codiagnoses, and procedures performed in all public as well as private hospital admissions, allowing us to determine comorbidities (eg, Charlson Comorbidity Index and mental health conditions) both before and after the index trauma admissions using International Statistical Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision, Clinical Modification codes. The Death Registry data were used to ascertain the causes of death, including whether it was suicide related. In this study, the censor date for mortality was December 11, 2020. In addition, we also obtained the socioeconomic status index at the local government areas on the basis of each patient’s residential address at the time of index trauma admission.18
Statistical Analysis
(未能翻译,以下为原文)Data were analyzed in April 2024 using SPSS for Windows version 29.0.2.0 (IBM), MedCalc for Windows version 12.5 (MedCalc Software, Ltd), or S-PLUS version 8.0 (Insightful Corp). Cox proportional hazards regression was used to determine factors associated with suicide after trauma, all-cause mortality, and trauma readmission. Logistic regression was used to determine factors associated with developing a new mental health condition after trauma. In choosing covariates for adjustment in the Cox and logistic regression analyses, only biologically plausible factors for these outcomes were included, and factors with an associated P > .25 were removed to generate the final parsimony model. In determining factors associated with a new-onset mental health condition after trauma, a subgroup analysis was also conducted among those with smoking and alcohol use data. All tests were 2-tailed, and P < .05 was considered significant without adjusting for multiple statistical testing.
Results
Characteristics of the Cohort
(未能翻译,以下为原文)Of the 29 191 adult patients with trauma included in the study (Figure 1), a total of 65 555 public or private hospitalizations before and 198 395 hospitalizations after the first (or index) trauma admissions were analyzed. Male patients were overrepresented (19 383 men [66.4%]). The median (IQR) age was 42 (27-65) years, the median (IQR) ISS was 9 (5-16) (9405 patients had ISS >15 and 19 786 had ISS <16), and the median (IQR) follow-up time for the cohort was 99.8 (61.2-148.5) months; 3868 patients (13.2%) died on or before the censor date. Of the 29 191 patients, 9010 (30.9%) had subsequent trauma admissions during the follow-up period after their first trauma admissions. The characteristics of the cohort are described in Table 1.
Differences in Mental Health Diagnoses Before and After Index Trauma Admission
(未能翻译,以下为原文)In total, 2233 patients (7.6%) had a mental health condition before their index trauma admission. Among the 26 958 patients (92.4%) who did not have a prior mental health condition, 3299 (11.3%) developed a mental health condition after their index trauma admission.
(未能翻译,以下为原文)There was a significant increase in number of hospitalizations with a mental health diagnosis after the first trauma admission (557 hospitalizations per 1000 patients; 95% CI, 499-614 hospitalizations per 1000 patients; P = .001), with most substantial increases for hospitalizations for drug dependence and neurotic disorders (Table 2). Among 26 958 patients without any mental health conditions before the first trauma admission, 1574 (5.4%) developed a neurotic disorder, including PTSD, and 2391 (8.2%) developed drug dependence diagnosis after trauma. Specifically, 130 patients (0.5%) were opioid-dependent before the index trauma admission but another 419 patients (1.4%) became opioid dependent after their index trauma admissions. One hundred sixty-two patients (0.6%) had anxiety disorders before the index trauma admission; after the index trauma admissions, 896 patients (3.1%) who did not have anxiety disorders before developed anxiety disorders.
Associations Between Having a New Mental Health Condition After Trauma and Subsequent Risks of Suicide, Trauma Readmission, and All-Cause Mortality
(未能翻译,以下为原文)Having a new mental health condition after trauma was associated with subsequent trauma readmissions (adjusted hazard ratio [aHR] 1.30; 95% CI, 1.23-1.37; P < .001), suicide by hanging or drug overdose (aHR, 3.14; 95% CI, 2.00-4.91; P < .001), and all-cause mortality (aHR, 1.24; 95% CI, 1.12-1.38; P < .001) (Figure 2) after adjusting for age, sex, and whether the patients had a mental health condition before the index trauma admission (Table 3). See eFigure 1 and eFigure 2 in Supplement 1 for more details.
Factors Associated With Having a New Mental Health Condition After Trauma Among Those Without Any Mental Health Diagnosis Before Trauma
(未能翻译,以下为原文)Among 26 958 patients without any mental health condition before their index trauma admissions, young age, unemployment, single or divorced or separated status (vs married), Indigenous ethnicity, lower socioeconomic status, and traumatic brain injury were all associated with developing a new mental health condition after their first trauma admissions (eTable in Supplement 1). Subgroup analysis on those who had alcohol and smoking use data yielded similar results, and both smoking and alcohol use were significantly associated with an increased risk of developing a new mental health condition after index trauma admissions.
Discussion
(未能翻译,以下为原文)It is recognized that immediate medical care following trauma represents only a fractional aspect of what most injured patients may need.17 Understanding the long-term outcomes and why some individuals are at risk of having worse long-term outcomes after trauma are essential to optimize patients’ recovery from the injuries and ability to reintegrate into society. To our knowledge, this cohort study is the largest and longest longitudinal study describing mental health outcomes in severely injured patients to date.
(未能翻译,以下为原文)This study confirmed that new mental health conditions after trauma were common and associated with an increased risk of adverse long-term health outcomes, including a higher risk of trauma readmission, suicide, and all-cause mortality. These findings have some clinical relevance and require further discussion.
(未能翻译,以下为原文)First, the patient characteristics in our cohort, including relatively young age (median age, 42 years) and male patients being overrepresented, were similar to previous studies.15,16,17 Similar to the Ontario study by Evans et al,16 patients with mental health conditions before index trauma admission accounted for approximately 7% of the study cohort. More importantly, the trajectories of our patients followed a multiphasic pattern. Approximately 13% of all patients discharged alive after trauma had died subsequently, and nearly one-third of our patients had subsequent trauma readmissions after a median follow-up period of 99.8 months.
(未能翻译,以下为原文)Second, our results showed that a significant number of patients with trauma developed a new mental health condition after their first trauma admission. Aside from PTSD, there was a high incidence of drug dependence, other neurotic disorders, and mood disorders. Patients with trauma are at risk of having chronic pain, functional limitations, and reduced physical health, and these issues could contribute to the development of new mental health conditions.13 A previous study by Heimke et al19 found that mental illness and recreational drug use were factors associated with trauma recidivism. It is, therefore, not surprising that the patients who developed new mental health conditions following trauma have higher risk of trauma readmissions, drug overdoses, and suicides. Our study showed that patients who developed a new mental health condition after trauma had a 3-fold increase in the risk of dying by suicide by either hanging or drug overdoses. Because having new mental health conditions after trauma was associated with an increased risk of repeated trauma hospitalizations and suicides, a higher risk for all-cause mortality was, therefore, also not surprising.
(未能翻译,以下为原文)Third, because trauma outcomes follow a multiphasic trajectory beyond the immediate hospitalization for trauma,17 identification of which groups may benefit the most from intervention after trauma center discharge is of pivotal importance. Our study showed that some patient factors are associated with their risk of developing a new mental health condition after trauma among those without any mental health condition before the index trauma admissions. Younger age, unemployment, being single or divorced and/or separated (vs married), Indigenous ethnicity, lower socioeconomic status, and traumatic brain injury were all associated with the development of a new mental health condition after their trauma admission. It is increasingly clear that mental health conditions are related to multiple upstream causes, including socioeconomic factors.20 On the other hand, occurrence of trauma and trauma outcomes are also related to socioeconomic factors.21,22 As such, mental health conditions, trauma, and socioeconomic factors are likely all interrelated like a triad, with a potential to exacerbate the adverse effects of each domain on patient outcomes including long-term mortality.
Limitations
(未能翻译,以下为原文)We need to acknowledge the limitations of this study. The Western Australian State Trauma Registry captures the majority of trauma admissions and virtually all major trauma admissions to the public health care system in Western Australia. However, patients who remained in regional hospitals due to minor injuries that did not require specialized care were not included in this study. We might, therefore, underestimate the importance of rurality as a risk factor for developing mental health conditions after trauma. By capturing only injuries requiring inpatient admissions (excluding patients with minor injuries treated in an emergency department and discharged home, which can constitute a meaningful fraction of patients seen at many trauma hospitals), and only capturing mental health conditions diagnosed at a subsequent hospitalization (excluding patients who have mental health conditions diagnosed by an outpatient practitioner, which may be a relatively large cohort), both of these limitations may lead to underestimation of the incidence and impact of these postinjury mental health conditions. This makes the work presented here all the more important, as the problem described is likely even larger than reported. Because data regarding prescriptive drug use, active substance abuse, and recreational drug use were not well captured by this database, we were unable to determine whether substance use beyond smoking and alcohol may be a risk factor in developing mental health conditions following trauma, nor its association with the risk of suicide and all-cause mortality.
结论
(未能翻译,以下为原文)In this cohort study of 29 191 patients with trauma, we found that mental health conditions after trauma were common and associated with an increased risk of adverse long-term outcomes. Trauma outcomes clearly followed a multiphasic pattern beyond immediate trauma care. Identifying groups who may benefit the most from interventions after trauma center discharge is important. Given the burden of new-onset mental conditions after trauma and their substantive long-term impact on the risk of trauma readmission, suicide, and all-cause mortality, there is potential to improve long-term outcomes for patients with trauma if appropriate mental health care resources are in place to offer follow-up and targeted interventions, including smoking cessation, alcohol use counseling, and treatment of opioid dependence, particularly for vulnerable subgroups of patients with trauma.
参考来源
- Yaw LK, Burrell M, Ho KM, et al. Long-Term Outcomes and Determinants of New-Onset Mental Health Conditions After Trauma. JAMA Netw Open. 2025. PMID: 40063026. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2025.0349
- 全文:PMC11894494(PMC 开放获取,CC BY)https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11894494/
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。