引导临床医生促进危重患者严重疾病沟通:一项实用性整群随机试验
这项4臂实用性阶梯整群随机试验纳入10家医院17个ICU的3500例次成人慢性严重疾病机械通气≥48小时患者,比较两种电子病历提示干预(记录6个月功能预后、记录是否提供舒适导向治疗替代或未提供原因)与常规护理。主要终点住院时间(死亡编码为第99百分位)在各干预组与常规护理组间无差异(调整后中位差值95%CI均含0);医院死亡率调整后风险差95%CI均含0。治疗替代组临终关怀出院率高于常规护理(10.9% vs 7.3%;调整后RD 6% [95%CI 1%-10%]),联合组亦更高(8.9% vs 7.3%;调整后RD 6% [95%CI 0%-12%]);治疗替代干预使舒适护理医嘱更早(3.6 vs 4.5天;调整后HR 1.42 [95%CI 1.06-1.92])。其余20项次要终点未受干预影响。提示电子引导可行但未减少住院时间。
要点
- 电子病历提示ICU医生记录6个月功能预后及是否提供舒适导向治疗替代,可行性好(总体文档完成率75.0%,n=1714),但未缩短住院时间。
- 治疗替代组临终关怀出院率高于常规护理组(10.9% vs 7.3%;调整后RD 6% [95%CI 1%-10%])。
- 联合组临终关怀出院率亦高于常规护理组(8.9% vs 7.3%;调整后RD 6% [95%CI 0%-12%])。
- 治疗替代干预使舒适护理医嘱更早(3.6 vs 4.5天;调整后HR 1.42 [95%CI 1.06-1.92])。
- 主要终点住院时间(死亡编码为第99百分位)各干预组与常规护理组调整后中位差值95%CI均含0, hospital mortality调整后风险差95%CI均含0。
适用人群与场景
- 成人慢性严重疾病患者,在ICU接受机械通气至少48小时;来自10家医院17个内科、外科、专科或混合ICU,涵盖社区、农村和城市环境。
处置流程与药物剂量
- 干预为临床医生导向的电子病历提示,要求记录6个月功能预后以及是否提供舒适导向治疗替代或未提供的原因。
研究设计与关键结果
- 4臂实用性阶梯整群随机试验,2018年2月1日至2020年10月31日进行,随访至2021年4月29日,分析于2023年12月至2024年1月;纳入3500例次成人慢性严重疾病机械通气≥48小时患者(3250例患者,平均[SD]年龄63.2[13.5]岁,46.1%女性),3384例次(96.7%)有完整基线数据纳入风险调整分析。
- 总体干预文档完成率为75.0%(n=1714),各组相似;观察到的医院死亡率为35.7%(n=1249),中位观察住院时间为8.93天(IQR 4.64-16.23)。
- 主要终点住院时间(死亡编码为第99百分位)在各干预组与常规护理组间无差异(调整后中位差值95%CI均含0);医院死亡率调整后风险差95%CI均含0。
- 治疗替代组临终关怀出院率高于常规护理组(10.9% vs 7.3%;调整后RD 6% [95%CI 1%-10%]);联合组亦高于常规护理组(8.9% vs 7.3%;调整后RD 6% [95%CI 0%-12%])。
- 治疗替代干预使舒适护理医嘱更早(3.6 vs 4.5天;调整后HR 1.42 [95%CI 1.06-1.92])。
- 其余20项次要终点未受干预影响;敏感性分析将死亡编码为第5百分位及不排序死亡时结果相似。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:实用性阶梯整群随机试验;试验注册号ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03139838。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 电子病历提示ICU医生遵循沟通指南可行,但未减少住院时间;治疗替代提示可提高临终关怀出院率并更早启动舒适护理医嘱。
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: Guidelines recommend that intensive care unit (ICU) clinicians consider prognosis and offer a comfort-focused treatment alternative to patients with limited prognoses to promote preference-sensitive treatment decisions.
OBJECTIVE: To determine whether nudging ICU clinicians to adhere to communication guidelines improves outcomes among critically ill patients at high risk of death or severe functional impairment.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This 4-arm pragmatic, stepped-wedge, cluster randomized trial (conducted February 1, 2018-October 31, 2020, follow-up through April 29, 2021, and analyses December 2023-January 2024) involved 3500 encounters of adults with chronic serious illness receiving mechanical ventilation for at least 48 hours at 10 hospitals comprising 17 medical, surgical, specialty, or mixed ICUs in community, rural, and urban settings.
INTERVENTIONS: Two clinician-directed electronic health record nudge interventions were each compared with usual care alone and combined: document of 6-month functional prognosis and whether a comfort-focused treatment alternative was offered or a reason why not.
MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The primary outcome was hospital length of stay, with death coded at the 99th percentile. Secondary end points included 22 measures of acute care utilization, end-of-life care processes, and mortality.
RESULTS: Of 3500 patient encounters among 3250 patients (mean [SD] age, 63.2 [13.5] years; 46.1% female), 3384 encounters (96.7%) had complete baseline data and were included in risk-adjusted analyses. The overall intervention document completion rate for all patients was 75.0% (n = 1714) and similar across groups. Among the 3500 encounters, observed hospital mortality was 35.7% (n = 1249), and the median observed length of stay was 8.93 days (IQR, 4.64-16.23). The median length of stay with deaths coded as the 99th percentile did not differ between any intervention and usual care groups (for length of stay, all adjusted median difference 95% CIs include 0; for hospital mortality, all adjusted risk difference [RD] 95% CIs include 0). Results were similar in sensitivity analyses with death coded as low at the fifth percentile and without ranking deaths. Compared with usual care, a higher percentage of patients were discharged to hospice in the treatment alternative group (10.9% vs 7.3%; adjusted RD, 6% [95% CI, 1%-10%]) and the combined group (8.9% vs 7.3%; adjusted RD, 6% [95% CI, 0%-12%]). The treatment alternative intervention led to earlier comfort-care orders (3.6 vs 4.5 days; adjusted hazard ratio, 1.42 [95% CI, 1.06-1.92]). The 20 other secondary end points were unaffected by the interventions.
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: This cluster randomized clinical trial found that electronically nudging ICU clinicians to adhere to communication guidelines was feasible but did not reduce hospital length of stay.
TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT03139838.
参考来源
- Courtright KR, Singh J, Dress EM, et al. Nudging Clinicians to Promote Serious Illness Communication for Critically Ill Patients: A Pragmatic Cluster Randomized Trial. JAMA Intern Med. 2025. PMID: 40094649. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2025.0090
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。