数据共享与协调的指导原则:美国重症医学会数据科学运动系统评价与改良德尔菲法的结果
本研究旨在建立重症医学数据共享与协调的指导原则,聚焦真实世界数据(RWD)与真实世界证据(RWE)以改善患者结局与研究效率。通过系统检索MEDLINE与Web of Science等数据库,初筛8150篇文章,257篇纳入,提取322条陈述,经内容验证与主题分析后整合为24条候选指导原则。随后采用三阶段改良德尔菲法(概念组、审阅组、德尔菲组),由专家对原则的可接受性、重要性和可行性进行评分,第2、3轮就相关性与适用性达成高度共识。最终形成24条指导原则,覆盖数据生成、存储、获取与使用全生命周期,旨在促进更有效、公平的数据实践,对人工智能决策支持工具与临床研究具有意义。
要点
- 系统检索MEDLINE与Web of Science等数据库初筛8150篇文章,257篇纳入,提取322条陈述,经内容验证与主题分析后整合为24条候选指导原则。
- 采用三阶段改良德尔菲法(概念组、审阅组、德尔菲组),专家对原则的可接受性、重要性和可行性评分,第2、3轮就相关性与适用性达成高度共识。
- 最终形成24条指导原则,覆盖真实世界数据与真实世界证据的生成、存储、获取与使用全生命周期。
- 原则旨在促进更有效、公平的数据实践,对人工智能决策支持工具与临床研究具有相关性。
- 原则强调伦理与公平,同时承认不同机构间资源的差异性。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为系统评价联合改良德尔菲法,由美国重症医学会数据科学运动发起。
- 系统检索MEDLINE与Web of Science等数据库,初筛8150篇文章,257篇纳入,提取322条陈述。
- 剔除无关定义与偏离主题内容后,232条陈述接受内容验证与主题分析,经专家小组严格审阅与共识构建后整合为24条候选指导原则。
- 改良德尔菲法分三阶段:第一阶段专家确定系统评价的关键主题与检索词;第二阶段验证与提炼候选指导原则;第三阶段德尔菲专家组对原则的可接受性、重要性和可行性评分。
- 第2、3轮就24条指导原则的相关性与适用性达成高度共识。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为系统评价联合改良德尔菲法共识。
- 纳入标准聚焦健康信息学、真实世界数据/真实世界证据使用推荐、数据共享与协调原则的出版物。
- 排除标准包括非人类研究、病例研究、会议摘要、2013年前发表的文章以及非英文文献。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
指南或共识出处
- 美国重症医学会数据科学运动(Society of Critical Care Medicine Data Science Campaign)
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「适用人群与场景」「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「对床旁实践的改变」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to establish a set of guiding principles for data sharing and harmonization in critical care, focusing on the use of real-world data (RWD) and real-world evidence (RWE) to improve patient outcomes and research efficacy. The principles were developed through a systematic literature review and a modified Delphi process, with the goal of enhancing data accessibility, standardization, and interoperability across critical care settings.
DATA SOURCES: Data sources included a comprehensive search of peer-reviewed literature, specifically studies related to the use of RWD and RWE in healthcare, guidelines, best practices, and recommendations on data sharing and harmonization. A total of 8150 articles were initially identified through databases such as MEDLINE and Web of Science, with 257 studies meeting inclusion criteria.
STUDY SELECTION: Inclusion criteria focused on publications discussing health-related informatics, recommendations for RWD/RWE usage, data sharing, and harmonization principles. Exclusion criteria ruled out non-human studies, case studies, conference abstracts, and articles published before 2013, as well as those not available in English.
DATA EXTRACTION: From the 257 selected studies, 322 statements were extracted. After removing irrelevant definitions and off-topic content, 232 statements underwent content validation and thematic analysis. These statements were then consolidated into 24 candidate guiding principles after rigorous review and consensus-building among the expert panel.
DATA SYNTHESIS: A three-phase modified Delphi process was employed, involving a conceptualization group, a review group, and a Delphi group. In phase 1, experts identified key themes and search terms for the systematic review. Phase 2 involved validating and refining the prospective guiding principles, while phase 3 employed a Delphi panel to rate principles on acceptability, importance, and feasibility. This process resulted in 24 guiding principles, with high consensus achieved in rounds 2 and 3 on their relevance and applicability.
CONCLUSIONS: The systematic review and Delphi process resulted in 24 guiding principles to improve data sharing and harmonization in critical care. These principles address challenges across the data lifecycle, including generation, storage, access, and usage of RWD and RWE. This framework is designed to promote more effective and equitable data practices, with relevance for the development of artificial intelligence-based decision support tools and clinical research. The principles are intended to guide the responsible use of data science in critical care, with emphasis on ethics and equity, while acknowledging the variability of resources across settings.
参考来源
- Armaignac DL, Heavner SF, Rausen M, et al. Guiding Principles for Data Sharing and Harmonization: Results of a Systematic Review and Modified Delphi From the Society of Critical Care Medicine Data Science Campaign. Crit Care Med. 2025. PMID: 39982146. doi:10.1097/CCM.0000000000006578
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。