申请者性别对肺与危重症医学专科培训推荐信的影响:一项多中心研究
该研究纳入2021年向美国五个地区(南部、中西部、东部、东北部、西部)PCCM专科培训项目提交的全部推荐信共9,153封,对申请者人口学与成就、写信者性别进行抽象,并用语言 inquiry 与词数统计(LIWC)分析形容词类型频率。采用多因素线性回归校正申请者人口学、成就及写信者性别后,女性申请者的推荐信在五个项目中的三个支持性词语显著更多(中西部多2.4词,95%CI 0.5-4.3,P=0.01;南部多1.9词,95%CI 0.1-3.6,P=0.03;东北部多2.5词,95%CI 0.2-4.9,P=0.04),在两个项目中篇幅更长(南部多40.1词,95%CI 12.3-68.0,P=0.005;中西部多29.8词,95%CI 0.7-58.9,P=0.045)。结论认为推荐信长度与支持度随申请者性别和地区而异,需进一步探究差异原因及选拔委员会如何解读这些信息。
要点
- 共分析9,153封2021年PCCM专科培训推荐信,申请者多数为男性(64.1%,n=1,703/2,658),写信者多数为男性(72.1%,n=6,603/9,152)。
- 校正申请者人口学、成就及写信者性别后,女性申请者推荐信在中西部多2.4个支持性词(95%CI 0.5-4.3,P=0.01)、南部多1.9个(95%CI 0.1-3.6,P=0.03)、东北部多2.5个(95%CI 0.2-4.9,P=0.04)。
- 女性申请者推荐信在南部篇幅多40.1词(95%CI 12.3-68.0,P=0.005)、中西部多29.8词(95%CI 0.7-58.9,P=0.045)。
- 推荐信长度与支持度随申请者性别和地区而异,五个项目中仅部分项目达到统计学显著。
- 作者认为需进一步探究这些差异的原因及选拔委员会如何解读推荐信信息。
适用人群与场景
- 2021年向美国五个地区(南部、中西部、东部、东北部、西部)PCCM专科培训项目提交申请的全部推荐信。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为多中心研究,分析9,153封PCCM专科培训推荐信;申请者多数为男性(64.1%,n=1,703/2,658),写信者多数为男性(72.1%,n=6,603/9,152)。
- 校正申请者人口学、成就及写信者性别后,女性申请者推荐信支持性词语更多:中西部多2.4词(95%CI 0.5-4.3,P=0.01)、南部多1.9词(95%CI 0.1-3.6,P=0.03)、东北部多2.5词(95%CI 0.2-4.9,P=0.04)。
- 女性申请者推荐信篇幅更长:南部多40.1词(95%CI 12.3-68.0,P=0.005)、中西部多29.8词(95%CI 0.7-58.9,P=0.045)。
- 结论:推荐信长度与支持度随申请者性别和地区而异。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:多中心研究(多机构推荐信分析)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为需进一步探究推荐信差异的原因及选拔委员会如何解读这些信息。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Background: Letters of recommendation (LORs) are crucial for fellowship applications, but implicit biases can affect their quality. Objective: The aim of this study was to examine sex-based differences among multiinstitutional pulmonary and critical care medicine (PCCM) fellowship LORs. Methods: All 2021 PCCM fellowship applications submitted to five regional U.S. programs (South, Midwest, East, Northeast, and West) were deidentified, and applicant demographics and accomplishments were abstracted. The letter writer's gender was identified through an online search of professional websites. Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count was used to identify the frequency of adjective types (e.g., grindstone, communal). We measured the associations between applicant sex and the outcomes of total word count and degree of support using multivariable linear regression models adjusting for applicant demographics, accomplishments, and letter writer's gender for each program. Results: In total, 9,153 LORs were included in the analysis. The majority of applicants (64.1% [n = 1,703 of 2,658]) were male, and most letter writers (72.1% [n = 6,603 of 9,152]) identified as men. When adjusting for applicant demographics and accomplishments and letter writer's gender, female applicants' LORs had significantly more supportive words compared with those of male applicants in three of the five programs (Midwest, 2.4 more words [95% confidence interval (CI), 0.5-4.3; P = 0.01]; South, 1.9 more words [95% CI, 0.1-3.6; P = 0.03]; Northeast, 2.5 more words [95% CI, 0.2-4.9; P = 0.04]) and longer letters in two programs (South, 40.1 more words [95% CI, 12.3-68.0; P = 0.005]; Midwest, 29.8 more words [95% CI, 0.7-58.9; P = 0.045]). Conclusion: The length and supportiveness of PCCM fellowship applicants' LORs varied by applicant sex and region. Further work should explore why these differences exist and how the information garnered from them is viewed by fellowship selection committees.
参考来源
- Byrd KM, Spiegel M, Kilb EF, et al. The Impact of Applicant Sex on Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine Fellowship Letters of Recommendation: A Multisite Study. ATS Sch. 2025. PMID: 39909018. doi:10.34197/ats-scholar.2024-0074OC
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。