器官捐献对话中的家属关切:一项定性嵌入式多案例研究
该定性嵌入式多案例研究在荷兰八家医院实时观察器官捐献对话,基于29次捐献对话的录音和直接观察以及对相关家属(n=24)的访谈进行主题分析,探讨捐献过程中出现哪些家属关切、这些关切在对话中及对话后如何表现、临床医生如何回应。结果显示关切集中于六个主题:亲属死亡这一生活事件、善终、对捐献的紧张与恐惧、时间体验、程序清晰性、纳入(不在场)家属;多数关切出现在主题1和2。临床医生多通过提供信息或即时解决方案回应,有时仅需认可;当关切情绪强烈时,回应较少契合家属需求;表达不清晰的线索得到的后续关注较少,关切常持续存在或再次出现。
要点
- 在荷兰八家医院实时观察29次器官捐献对话并访谈相关家属(n=24),识别出六类家属关切。
- 关切集中于两个主题:亲属死亡这一生活事件、善终;其余为对捐献的紧张与恐惧、时间体验、程序清晰性、纳入(不在场)家属。
- 临床医生多通过提供信息或即时解决方案回应关切,有时仅需认可。
- 当关切情绪强烈时,临床医生的回应较少契合家属需求。
- 表达不清晰的关切线索得到的后续关注较少,关切常持续存在或再次出现。
适用人群与场景
- 荷兰八家医院中参与器官捐献对话的家属(n=24)及进行对话的临床医生,研究场景为器官与组织捐献的捐献对话过程。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:定性嵌入式多案例研究;地点:荷兰八家医院;方法:对29次捐献对话进行录音和直接观察,并对相关家属(n=24)进行访谈,采用主题分析。
- 家属关切聚为六个主题:1)亲属死亡这一生活事件;2)善终;3)对捐献的紧张与恐惧;4)时间体验;5)程序清晰性;6)纳入(不在场)家属;多数关切出现在主题1和2。
- 临床医生多通过提供信息或即时解决方案回应关切,有时仅需认可即可。
- 当关切情绪强烈时,临床医生的回应较少契合家属需求;表达不清晰的关切线索得到的后续关注较少,关切常持续存在或再次出现。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:定性嵌入式多案例研究(主题分析);局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者建议临床医生以好奇、探询的态度展开对话,以促进围绕关切的交流。
- 作者建议临床医生对表达不清晰的关切加以展开,并识别家属的信息需求。
- 研究提示当关切情绪强烈时临床医生的回应较少契合家属需求,表达不清晰的关切线索得到的后续关注较少,关切常持续存在或再次出现。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Listening and responding to family concerns in organ and tissue donation is generally considered important, but has never been researched in real time. We aimed to explore in real time, (a) which family concerns emerge in the donation process, (b) how these concerns manifest during and after the donor conversation, and (c) how clinicians respond to the concerns during the donor conversation.
METHODS: A qualitative embedded multiple-case study in eight Dutch hospitals was conducted. Thematic analysis was performed based on audio recordings and direct observations of 29 donor conversations and interviews with the family members involved (n = 24).
RESULTS: Concerns clustered around six topics: 1) Life-event of a relative's death, 2) Dying well, 3) Tensions and fears about donation, 4) Experiences of time, 5) Procedural clarity, and 6) Involving (non-)present family. Most concerns occurred in topics 1 and 2. Clinicians mostly responded to concerns by providing information or immediate solutions, while sometimes acknowledgement sufficed. When concerns were highly charged with emotion, the clinicians' responses were less frequently attuned to families' needs. Cues of less clearly articulated concerns gained less follow-up. Then, concerns often remained or reappeared.
CONCLUSION: The identified concerns and the distinction between clearly and less clearly articulated concerns may prove valuable for clinicians to improve family support. We advise clinicians to engage with a curious, probing attitude to enhance the dialogue around concerns, elaborate on less clearly articulated concerns and identify the informational needs of the family.
参考来源
- van Oosterhout SPC, van der Niet AG, Abdo WF, et al. Family concerns in organ donor conversations: a qualitative embedded multiple-case study. Crit Care. 2024. PMID: 39731096. doi:10.1186/s13054-024-05198-2
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。