医学生用颈动脉超声目视检测无脉的前瞻性观察研究
这项横断面研究纳入432名超声经验极少或无经验的医学生,在观看10秒颈总动脉超声视频(B型、M型、彩色多普勒)后判断有无脉搏,视频包括有脉动(收缩压70–80 mmHg)和无脉动(体外循环手术、主动脉夹断)两种。共完成8640次判断。M型识别有脉动正确率96%(1244/1296),识别无脉动正确率95%(1231/1296);B型识别有脉动正确率仅69%(889/1296),识别无脉动正确率99%(2142/2160);彩色多普勒识别有脉动正确率99.5%(1290/1296),识别无脉动正确率99%(1281/1296)。作者认为,在受控研究条件下,医学生用颈总动脉二维超声似能高度准确识别无脉,彩色多普勒联合B型可能有助于心肺复苏时判断有无脉搏。
要点
- 彩色多普勒判断颈总动脉有脉动正确率99.5%(1290/1296),判断无脉动正确率99%(1281/1296),表现最均衡。
- M型判断有脉动正确率96%(1244/1296),判断无脉动正确率95%(1231/1296)。
- B型判断有脉动正确率仅69%(889/1296),31%(407/1296)误判为无脉动;判断无脉动正确率99%(2142/2160)。
- 观看视频时长10秒,对应心肺复苏时手动触脉的持续时间。
- 作者认为,心肺复苏中评估颈总动脉时,彩色多普勒联合B型可能有用。
适用人群与场景
- 超声经验极少或无经验的医学生,在受控研究条件下观看颈总动脉超声视频并判断有无脉搏。
- 有脉动视频取自收缩压70–80 mmHg的颈总动脉;无脉动视频取自体外循环手术、主动脉夹断的颈总动脉。
研究设计与关键结果
- 横断面研究,432名参与者完整完成20个病例的判断,共评估8640次颈总动脉脉搏「有」或「无」的决策。
- M型:有脉动视频中正确识别有脉动96%(1244/1296);无脉动视频中正确判断无脉动95%(1231/1296)。
- B型:有脉动视频中正确判断有脉动69%(889/1296),其余31%(407/1296)错误选择无脉动;无脉动视频中正确判断无脉动99%(2142/2160)。
- 彩色多普勒:有脉动视频中正确检测有脉动99.5%(1290/1296);无脉动视频中正确判断无脉动99%(1281/1296)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:前瞻性横断面观察研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,在受控研究条件下,医学生使用颈总动脉二维超声不同模式似能高度准确识别无脉;心肺复苏中评估颈总动脉时,彩色多普勒联合B型可能有用。
- B型判断有脉动时错误选择无脉动的比例为31%(407/1296),提示单一B型模式判断有脉动准确性较低。
- 本研究为医学生在受控条件下观看视频的判断,非床旁心肺复苏场景。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: This cross-sectional study aimed to determine whether medical students with little to no ultrasound experience could correctly distinguish between 'pulsation present' and 'no pulsation present' after a short introductory video on the subject using ultrasound videos of the common carotid artery (CCA).
METHODS: Ultrasound videos (B-mode, M-mode, and Color Doppler) of pulsatile (systolic blood pressure 70-80 mmHg) and non-pulsatile (cardiopulmonary bypass surgery, clamped aorta) CCA were created. These were demonstrated to the medical students for a period of ten seconds - corresponding to the duration of the manual pulse palpation during cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). All participants viewed twenty of these videos in random order on a tablet and were asked to decide whether or not a CCA pulse was present.
RESULTS: 432 participants completed the study in full on 20 cases, enabling a total of 8640 decisions on CCA pulse 'present' or 'not present' to be evaluated. M-mode: in 96 % (1244/1296) of the cases, the participants correctly identified the presence of pulsatile CCA. In the videos without pulsatile CCA, the correct decision 'no pulsation present' was made in 95 % (1231/1296) of the cases. B-mode: the decision 'pulsation present' was made correctly in 69 % (889/1296) of the cases, and in the remaining 31 % (407/1296) the option 'no pulsation present' was incorrectly chosen, although a video with CCA pulsation was shown. In contrast, the correct decision 'no pulsation present' was selected in 99 % of the cases (2142/2160). Color Doppler: CCA pulsation was correctly detected in 99.5 % (1290/1296) of the cases. In the videos without CCA pulsation, 99 % (1281/1296) of the videos were correctly evaluated as 'no pulsation present'.
CONCLUSION: Medical students seem to be able to detect the absence of a pulse with a high degree of accuracy using 2D ultrasound of the CCA in a controlled study setting, using different ultrasound modes. The results of this study suggest that a combination of Color Doppler and B-mode may be useful when evaluating the CCA during CPR to answer the question 'pulsation present' or 'no pulsation present'.
参考来源
- Vojnar B, Holl A, Dinges HC, et al. Visual detection of pulselessness by carotid artery sonography - A prospective observational study among medical students. Resuscitation. 2024. PMID: 39701176. doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2024.110461
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。