建立用于早期发展阶段院前急救系统评价工具(PECSET)的核心要素:德尔菲共识
该共识旨在为亚洲低资源地区开发院前急救系统评价工具(PECSET),以定义可实现的基础要素。研究采用4阶段改良德尔菲法,纳入12个亚洲国家的32名院前急救专家,对前期范围综述、焦点小组讨论和调查确定的32项要素进行投票;前两轮回答「要素在低资源环境中是否重要且可行」,后两阶段回答「是否应优先作为工具核心」。4轮投票后确定12项核心要素,但参与者决定将全部32项要素按同意百分比分组纳入工具,形成面向早期、中期和高级院前急救系统的分层方法。优先理由包括需要聚焦基础建设和在资源紧张系统中建立韧性。该结果将用于指导南亚和东南亚低资源国家质量保证与监测工具的开发。
要点
- 4轮投票后确定12项核心要素:调度辅助指导、筛查分诊与目的地方案、医疗指导、标准化培训项目、最低救护车标准、运营指标、质量保证、运营安全方案、基本患者护理记录、病历管理、公众意识与教育、通用急救号码。
- 参与者决定将全部32项要素纳入工具,按同意百分比归入更宽泛的类别,形成早期、中期和高级院前急救系统的分层方法。
- 优先理由包括需要聚焦基础建设,以及在资源紧张系统中建立韧性。
- 共识纳入12个亚洲国家的32名院前急救专家,采用4阶段改良德尔菲法,投票通过匿名网络应用进行并辅以面对面小组讨论。
- 该发现将指导南亚和东南亚低资源国家质量保证与监测工具的开发。
适用人群与场景
- 亚洲低资源环境中处于早期发展阶段的院前急救系统,以及南亚和东南亚低资源国家的院前急救系统。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 工具要素分为核心要素与非核心要素:12项被确定为核心要素,全部32项要素按同意百分比归入更宽泛类别,用于早期、中期和高级院前急救系统的分层方法。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为4阶段改良德尔菲共识,纳入来自12个亚洲国家的32名院前急救专家,对32项要素投票。
- 前两轮投票回答「要素在低资源环境中是否重要且可行」,后两阶段回答「是否应优先作为工具核心」。
- 4轮投票后确定12项核心要素:调度辅助指导、筛查分诊与目的地方案、医疗指导、标准化培训项目、最低救护车标准、运营指标、质量保证、运营安全方案、基本患者护理记录、病历管理、公众意识与教育、通用急救号码。
- 参与者决定将全部32项要素纳入工具,按同意百分比分组为更宽泛类别,形成面向早期、中期和高级院前急救系统的分层方法。
- 优先理由的主题分析显示,需要聚焦基础建设,并在资源紧张系统中建立韧性。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型为4阶段改良德尔菲共识(指南类),纳入12个亚洲国家的32名院前急救专家。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 该共识确定的12项核心要素和全部32项要素的分层框架,可用于亚洲低资源院前急救系统的质量保证与监测工具开发。
- 作者认为,这些发现将指导南亚和东南亚低资源国家质量保证与监测工具的开发。
指南或共识出处
- Prehospital Emergency Care(期刊来源);共识名称为Prehospital Emergency Care Systems Evaluation Tool(PECSET)核心要素德尔菲共识。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: International Prehospital Emergency Care (PEC) standards have been primarily developed by and for high resource settings. Most PEC systems in Asia, which are still in the early stages of development, struggle to achieve these standards. There is a need for an evaluation tool which can define achievable basic building blocks for PEC systems in low resource settings to improve quality of PEC. We aimed to identify the core, basic elements (building blocks of a PEC system) for a Prehospital Emergency Care Systems Evaluation Tool (PECSET) for low resource settings in Asia.
METHODS: A 4-stage modified Delphi consensus method was used to engage 32 PEC experts from 12 Asian countries. Participants voted on 32 elements identified from a prior scoping review, focus group discussions, and survey. Each round of voting was conducted through an anonymous, web-based application and followed by face-to-face group discussions. The first two rounds aimed to answer, "Is the element important and feasible in a low resource setting?" The last two stages aimed to answer "Should this element be prioritized as core in the tool?" A thematic analysis of the recorded and transcribed discussions was used to identify participants' rationale for prioritization.
RESULTS: After four rounds of voting, 12 elements were identified as core elements: (1) dispatch assisted instructions, (2) protocols for screening, triage and destination, (3) medical direction, (4) standardized training programs, (5) minimum ambulance standards, (6) operational metrics, (7) quality assurance, (8) operational safety protools, (9) essential patient care documentation, (10) medical records management, (11) layperson awareness and education and (12) universal access emergency number. However, the participants decided to include all 32 elements in the tool grouped into broader categories by percent agreement for a tiered approach for early, intermediate, and advanced PEC systems. Rationales for prioritization included a need for focus on basic infrastructure and building resilience in resource-stretched systems.
CONCLUSIONS: Through a Delphi consensus process, stakeholders identified core elements for PEC systems in low resource settings. These findings will inform the development of a tool for quality assurance and monitoring in low resource settings in South and Southeast Asian countries.
参考来源
- Nadarajan GD, Pek PP, Blewer AL, et al. Establishing Core Elements for a Prehospital Emergency Care Systems Evaluation Tool (PECSET) for Systems in Early Stages of Development: A Delphi Consensus. Prehosp Emerg Care. 2025. PMID: 39700053. doi:10.1080/10903127.2024.2443472
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。