为下一次大流行做准备:佛罗里达州的反思与建议
该研究对佛罗里达州政府、学术界和私营部门的现任及前任领导者共25人进行半结构化访谈,询问COVID-19期间遇到的挑战及对未来大流行的考虑,采用定性内容分析(QCA)分析访谈转录和笔记。结果归纳为未来行动建议、大流行防范与应对挑战、COVID-19应对的成功与失败四大类,下设公共卫生系统能力、疾病传播减缓、角色与关系、信息传达与传播、最小化大流行的其他不良影响、公共卫生文化六个亚类。考虑到现有大流行计划被忽视及决策中的管辖张力,参与者提出实施大流行行动手册,明确相关机构职责及豁免标准程序的流程;部分人建议关闭和限制措施,另一些人则质疑此类策略应实施到何种程度。结论指出本研究与跨意识形态分歧建立共识的需求相符,揭示了联邦、州、县实体之间以及州级机构之间的张力,参与者将成功的大流行应对定义为不仅包括减缓疾病传播,还包括最小化不良社会和经济影响。
要点
- 对佛罗里达州政府、学术界和私营部门25名现任及前任领导者进行半结构化访谈,采用定性内容分析。
- 参与者提出实施大流行行动手册,明确相关机构职责及豁免标准程序的流程。
- 部分参与者建议关闭和限制措施以避免疾病传播,另一些人质疑此类策略应实施到何种程度。
- 参与者将成功的大流行应对定义为不仅减缓疾病传播,还包括最小化不良社会和经济影响。
- 研究揭示联邦、州、县实体之间以及州级机构之间的张力,强调跨意识形态分歧建立共识的需求。
适用人群与场景
- 佛罗里达州政府、学术界和私营部门的现任及前任领导者(共25人)
处置流程与药物剂量
- 参与者提出实施大流行行动手册,明确相关机构职责及豁免标准程序的流程。
- 部分参与者建议关闭和限制措施以避免疾病传播,另一些人质疑此类策略应实施到何种程度。
- 参与者讨论了未来大流行采取统一、良好协调的方法,平衡健康与经济关切。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:定性研究,对佛罗里达州政府、学术界和私营部门25名现任及前任领导者进行半结构化访谈,采用定性内容分析(QCA)。
- 结果归纳为四大类(未来行动建议、大流行防范与应对挑战、COVID-19应对的成功与失败),下设六个亚类:公共卫生系统能力、疾病传播减缓、角色与关系、信息传达与传播、最小化大流行的其他不良影响、公共卫生文化。
- 参与者提出实施大流行行动手册,明确相关机构职责及豁免标准程序的流程;部分人建议关闭和限制措施,另一些人质疑此类策略应实施到何种程度。
- 参与者将成功的大流行应对定义为不仅包括减缓疾病传播,还包括最小化不良社会和经济影响;研究揭示了联邦、州、县实体之间以及州级机构之间的张力。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:定性研究(半结构化访谈),采用定性内容分析(QCA)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,应考虑制定大流行行动手册,明确相关机构职责及豁免标准程序的流程。
- 作者认为,未来大流行应对需采取统一、良好协调的方法,平衡健康与经济关切。
- 参与者对关闭和限制措施的实施程度存在分歧,部分人建议此类措施,另一些人质疑其应实施到何种程度。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
CONTEXT: The COVID-19 emergency warrants reflection on how to improve future infectious disease pandemic preparedness and response (PPR). U.S. States took diverse approaches to COVID-19, with Florida's approach characterized by fewer restrictions on businesses and individuals. Despite the profound effects of the pandemic, there is a dearth of stakeholder-informed recommendations for PPR at the state level. This study aims to empirically examine stakeholder perspectives on PPR in Florida.
METHODS: 25 semi-structured interviews were conducted with former and current leaders from government, academia, and the private sector in Florida. Participants were asked about challenges encountered during COVID-19 and considerations for what should be done for future pandemics. Interview transcripts and notes were analyzed using qualitative content analysis (QCA).
FINDINGS: Results were organized into four main categories (recommendations for future actions, challenges in PPR, successes and failures during the COVID-19 response), across which six sub-categories were identified: public health systems capacities; mitigation of disease transmission; roles and relationships; messaging and information dissemination; minimizing other adverse effects of a pandemic; and public health culture. Considering the neglect of existing pandemic plans and jurisdictional tensions around decision-making during COVID-19, participants proposed implementing a pandemic playbook that delineates the responsibilities of relevant agencies and processes of waiving standard procedures. While many suggested closures and restrictions to avoid the spread of disease, others questioned the extent to which such strategies should be implemented.
CONCLUSIONS: This study corresponds with the need for consensus-building across ideological divisions, revealing tensions among federal, state, and county-level entities, as well as across state-level agencies. Participants defined successful pandemic response as not only comprising the mitigation of disease transmission, but also the minimization of adverse social and economic effects. Participants discussed strategies for a unified, well-coordinated approach to future pandemics that balances health and economic concerns.
参考来源
- Liu A, Waldman RN, Deal B, et al. Preparing for the next pandemic: Reflections and recommendations from Florida. PLoS One. 2024. PMID: 39621704. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0314570
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。