重症监护病房中全面无反应性评分与格拉斯哥昏迷量表的预测效度比较:系统评价
该系统评价前瞻性注册于PROSPERO(CRD42023420528),系统检索CINAHL、MEDLINE和Embase,纳入20项在ICU成人中同时评估GCS和FOUR评分并收集死亡率或经验证的功能结局指标的前瞻性观察性研究,排除仅研究创伤性脑损伤患者的研究。质量评估采用预后研究质量工具,由两名评价者完成。结果显示FOUR评分预测死亡率的ROC曲线下面积高于GCS,且预测ICU死亡率的ROC曲线下面积显著更高;两种昏迷量表预测「不良」功能结局的准确性相似。FOUR评分在ICU中似乎比GCS反应性更好,多数GCS评分为3分的患者FOUR评分在1至8分之间,反映脑干功能保留。作者认为FOUR评分在ICU环境中预测死亡率可能优于GCS,需进一步开展有足够把握度、评估方法与结局指标明确可靠的研究来阐明两种昏迷量表在ICU中的预测性能;纳入镇静患者可能提高在普通ICU人群中的推广性。
要点
- 该系统评价纳入20项质量差至中等的 sécurité prospective observational studies,许多研究仅纳入神经系统疾病患者并排除镇静患者,尽管插管患者比例高。
- FOUR评分预测死亡率的ROC曲线下面积高于GCS,且预测ICU死亡率的ROC曲线下面积显著高于GCS。
- 两种昏迷量表预测「不良」功能结局的准确性相似。
- FOUR评分在ICU中似乎比GCS反应性更好:多数GCS评分为3分的患者FOUR评分在1至8分之间,因脑干功能保留。
- 作者认为FOUR评分在ICU环境中预测死亡率可能优于GCS,需进一步开展有足够把握度、评估方法与结局指标明确可靠的研究来阐明两种评分在ICU中的预测性能。
适用人群与场景
- 成人ICU患者,在入ICU期间同时评估GCS和FOUR评分,并收集死亡率和/或经验证的功能结局指标。
- 排除仅研究创伤性脑损伤患者的研究。
- 许多纳入研究仅纳入神经系统疾病患者并排除镇静患者,尽管插管患者比例高。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:系统评价,前瞻性注册于PROSPERO(CRD42023420528),系统检索CINAHL、MEDLINE和Embase,纳入20项前瞻性观察性研究,质量差至中等。
- FOUR评分预测死亡率的ROC曲线下面积高于GCS。
- FOUR评分预测ICU死亡率的ROC曲线下面积显著高于GCS。
- 两种昏迷量表预测「不良」功能结局的准确性相似。
- FOUR评分在ICU中似乎比GCS反应性更好:多数GCS评分为3分的患者FOUR评分在1至8分之间,因脑干功能保留。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:系统评价,纳入前瞻性观察性研究,质量评估采用预后研究质量工具,由两名评价者完成筛选、数据提取和质量评估。
- 作者认为FOUR评分在ICU环境中预测死亡率可能优于GCS;需进一步开展有足够把握度、评估方法与结局指标明确可靠的研究来阐明两种昏迷量表在ICU中的预测性能;纳入镇静患者可能提高在普通ICU人群中的推广性。
- 局限:纳入研究质量差至中等;许多研究仅纳入神经系统疾病患者并排除镇静患者,尽管插管患者比例高。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为FOUR评分在ICU环境中预测死亡率可能优于GCS;需进一步开展有足够把握度、评估方法与结局指标明确可靠的研究来阐明两种昏迷量表在ICU中的预测性能。
- 纳入镇静患者可能提高在普通ICU人群中的推广性。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
The Full Outline of UnResponsiveness (FOUR) score was developed to overcome the limitations of the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) when assessing individuals with impaired consciousness. We sought to review the evidence regarding the predictive validity of the GCS and FOUR score in intensive care unit (ICU) settings. This review was prospectively registered in PROSPERO (CRD42023420528). Systematic searches of CINAHL, MEDLINE, and Embase were undertaken. Prospective observational studies were included if both GCS and FOUR score were assessed in adults during ICU admission and if mortality and/or validated functional outcome measure scores were collected. Studies were excluded if they exclusively investigated patients with traumatic brain injury. Screening, data extraction, and quality assessment using the Quality in Prognosis Studies tool were conducted by two reviewers. Twenty studies of poor to moderate quality were included. Many studies only included patients with neurological illness and excluded sedated patients, despite high proportions of intubated patients. The FOUR score achieved higher area under the receiver operating characteristic curve values for mortality prediction compared with the GCS, and the FOUR score achieved significantly higher area under the receiver operating characteristic curve values for predictions of ICU mortality. Both coma scales showed similar accuracy in predicting "unfavorable" functional outcome. The FOUR score appeared to be more responsive than the GCS in the ICU, as most patients with a GCS score of 3 obtained FOUR scores between 1 and 8 due to preserved brainstem function. The FOUR score may be superior to the GCS for predicting mortality in ICU settings. Further adequately powered studies with clear, reliable methods for assessment of index and outcome scores are required to clarify the predictive performance of both coma scales in ICUs. Inclusion of sedated patients may improve generalizability of findings in general ICU populations.
参考来源
- Schey JE, Schoch M, Kerr D, et al. The Predictive Validity of the Full Outline of UnResponsiveness Score Compared to the Glasgow Coma Scale in the Intensive Care Unit: A Systematic Review. Neurocrit Care. 2024. PMID: 39496882. doi:10.1007/s12028-024-02150-8
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。