不明确的轨迹与不确定的获益:用德尔菲共识流程为危重或晚期疾病患者的临床不确定性创建词库
本研究采用德尔菲共识法,邀请全国多机构照护危重或晚期疾病患者的医生,围绕临床不确定性的定义进行多轮协作,确定哪些词能在临床记录中表达不确定性。19名医生参与了至少2轮德尔菲流程,经5轮达成对44个词或短语的共识。主题分析显示,医生使用这些词记录和梳理诊断思维、寻求帮助、标识信息不完整,并如实反映存在的不确定性。该词库可用于从病历中规模化提取不确定性数据。
要点
- 19名医生参与至少2轮德尔菲流程,经5轮对44个词或短语达成共识。
- 医生使用不确定性词记录诊断思维过程、寻求帮助、标识信息不完整并如实反映不确定性。
- 医生尤其ICU医生对不确定性感到自在,并频繁记录不确定性词以传达危重病的复杂与模糊。
- 该共识词库可用于从医疗记录中提取不确定性数据。
适用人群与场景
- 照护危重患者或晚期疾病患者的医生,来自全国多机构。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 德尔菲共识流程中,参与者依据给定的临床不确定性定义,经多轮协作确定哪些词代表临床记录中的不确定性。
研究设计与关键结果
- 德尔菲共识研究:19名医生参与至少2轮德尔菲流程,经5轮对44个词或短语达成共识。
- 主题分析:医生使用不确定性词记录和梳理诊断思维过程、寻求帮助、标识信息不完整并如实反映存在的不确定性。
- 医生对使用不确定性词感到自在,并频繁记录以传达危重病中普遍存在的复杂与模糊。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:德尔菲共识研究;局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 该词库可用于从病历中规模化提取不确定性数据。
- 医生尤其ICU医生对不确定性感到自在,并频繁记录不确定性词,以传达危重病的复杂与模糊。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Clinical uncertainty is associated with increased resource utilization, worsened health-related quality of life for patients, and provider burnout, particularly during critical illness. Existing data are limited, because determining uncertainty from notes typically requires manual, qualitative review. We sought to develop a consensus list of descriptors of clinical uncertainty and then, using a thematic analysis approach, describe how respondents consider their use in intensive care unit (ICU) notes, such that future work can extract uncertainty data at scale.
DESIGN: We conducted a Delphi consensus study with physicians across multiple institutions nationally who care for critically ill patients or patients with advanced illnesses. Participants were given a definition for clinical uncertainty and collaborated through multiple rounds to determine which words represent uncertainty in clinician notes. We also administered surveys that included open-ended questions to participants about clinical uncertainty. Following derivation of a consensus list, we analyzed participant responses using thematic analysis to understand the role of uncertainty in clinical documentation.
RESULTS: Nineteen physicians participated in at least 2 of the Delphi rounds. Consensus was achieved for 44 words or phrases over 5 rounds of the Delphi process. Clinicians described comfort with using uncertainty terms and used them in a variety of ways: documenting and processing the diagnostic thinking process, enlisting help, identifying incomplete information, and practicing transparency to reflect uncertainty that was present.
CONCLUSIONS: Using a consensus process, we created an uncertainty lexicon that can be used for uncertainty data extraction from the medical record. We demonstrate that physicians, particularly in the ICU, are comfortable with uncertainty and document uncertainty terms frequently to convey the complexity and ambiguity that is pervasive in critical illness.
HIGHLIGHTS: Question: What words do physicians caring for critically ill patients use to document clinical uncertainty, and why?Findings: A consensus list of 44 words or phrases was identified by a group of experts. Physicians expressed comfort with using these words in the electronic health record.Meaning: Physicians are comfortable with uncertainty words and document them frequently to convey the complexity and ambiguity that is pervasive in critical illness.
参考来源
- McGowan SK, Corrales-Martinez MJ, Brender T, et al. Unclear Trajectory and Uncertain Benefit: Creating a Lexicon for Clinical Uncertainty in Patients with Critical or Advanced Illness Using a Delphi Consensus Process. Med Decis Making. 2024. PMID: 39559986. doi:10.1177/0272989X241293446
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。