指南与共识儿科与产科急症

改良德尔菲研究确立儿童神经科住院医师教育共识:下一代培训

Modified Delphi Study to Establish Consensus About Child Neurology Residency Education: Next-Gen Training.
指南 / 共识 · Neurology · 2024-11-08
一句话结论美国多元专家组通过4轮改良德尔菲法,就儿童神经科住院医师培训的轮转科目与月数达成共识,总轮转要求46.5个月。

本研究采用改良德尔菲法,邀请48名美国儿童神经科医师(最终27人参与),经4轮匿名评估,就当前培训要求、核心轮转时长及必修亚专科轮转达成共识。共识轮转月数包括新生儿与儿科重症监护4个月、青少年医学0.5个月、急诊医学1.5个月、住院儿科3个月、门诊儿科3.5个月、住院儿童神经科9.5个月、门诊儿童神经科6个月、住院成人神经科3个月、门诊成人神经科2个月、遗传学2个月、脑电图/神经生理2个月、神经影像1个月、儿童精神科1个月及选修7.5个月,总轮转要求46.5个月。该共识为儿童神经科培训结构的现代化提供了专家共识基础。

要点

  • 共识轮转月数:住院儿童神经科9.5个月、门诊儿童神经科6个月、新生儿与儿科重症监护4个月。
  • 共识轮转月数:住院儿科3个月、门诊儿科3.5个月、急诊医学1.5个月、青少年医学0.5个月。
  • 共识轮转月数:住院成人神经科3个月、门诊成人神经科2个月、遗传学2个月、脑电图/神经生理2个月。
  • 共识轮转月数:神经影像1个月、儿童精神科1个月、选修7.5个月;总轮转要求46.5个月。
  • 第1轮118项中45项(38%)达成共识,第2轮87项中28项(32%),第3轮25项中16项(64%),第4轮1项中1项(100%)。

适用人群与场景

  • 美国儿童神经科住院医师培训项目;参与共识的27名儿童神经科医师来自不同地理区域、执业类型和亚专科。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 共识定义为7点李克特量表上≥75%同意或不同意;未达共识的陈述在后续轮次重新询问或修改。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 共识推荐的轮转月数:新生儿与儿科重症监护4个月、青少年医学0.5个月、急诊医学1.5个月、住院儿科3个月、门诊儿科3.5个月、住院儿童神经科9.5个月、门诊儿童神经科6个月、住院成人神经科3个月、门诊成人神经科2个月、遗传学2个月、脑电图/神经生理2个月、神经影像1个月、儿童精神科1个月、选修7.5个月。
  • 共识培训方案总轮转要求为46.5个月。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 改良德尔菲研究,邀请48名美国儿童神经科医师,27名同意参与,多数完成全部4轮。
  • 第1轮共识45/118项(38%),第2轮28/87项(32%),第3轮16/25项(64%),第4轮1/1项(100%)。
  • 对执业年龄范围和某些应必修的亚专科达成共识,但对时间要求最初未达成共识;至第4轮形成上述轮转月数共识。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:改良德尔菲共识研究;共识阈值:7点李克特量表≥75%同意或不同意。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,尽管儿童神经科医师观点存在分歧,多元专家组可通过多轮德尔菲过程就培训结构和认证要求的许多核心特征达成共识。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Rapid advances in diagnostics and treatments are shifting child neurology practice, but child neurology training requirements have been much slower to change. Previous literature confirms strong support for modernization, but no formal consensus exists regarding maintaining or changing training. We aimed to develop a holistic consensus regarding the optimal training pathway and requirements using a modified Delphi process.

METHODS: The authors invited 48 child neurologists as panelists, intentionally selecting to represent the diverse geography, practice type, subspecialties, and other demographics of child neurologists practicing in the United States. Panelists participated in an anonymized modified Delphi study with 4 rounds evaluating statements regarding current training requirements, core rotation durations, and mandatory subspecialty rotations with the option to agree or disagree. Statements were derived from current Accreditation Council of Graduate Medical Education, American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology, and American Board of Pediatrics requirements for child neurology training and recent literature. Statements that did not reach a predefined level of consensus (≥75% agreement or disagreement on a 7-point Likert scale) were re-queried or modified for subsequent rounds. Panelists had access to all previous anonymized results and comments. The final modifications were presented in round 4 as a comprehensive training proposal.

RESULTS: Twenty-seven panelists agreed to participate, with most completing all 4 rounds. In round 1, consensus was reached on 45 of 118 (38%) items; round 2, 28 of 87 (32%); round 3, 16 of 25 (64%); and round 4, 1 of 1 (100%). There was consensus regarding the age scope of practice and certain subspecialties that should be required, but no initial consensus regarding time-based requirements. By round 4, consensus emerged for the following rotations-months: neonatal and pediatric intensive care-4, adolescent medicine-0.5, emergency medicine-1.5, inpatient pediatrics-3, outpatient pediatrics-3.5, inpatient child neurology-9.5, outpatient child neurology-6, inpatient adult neurology-3, outpatient adult neurology-2, genetics-2, EEG/neurophysiology-2, neuroimaging-1, child psychiatry-1, and electives-7.5. The consensus schedule consists of 46.5 total months of requirements.

DISCUSSION: This study suggests that, despite diverging views prevalent among child neurologists, a diverse panel can, through a multiround Delphi process, arrive at consensus regarding many core features of the child neurology training structure and certification requirements.

来源:Neurology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Gottlieb-Smith R, Rogers D, Gilbert DL, et al. Modified Delphi Study to Establish Consensus About Child Neurology Residency Education: Next-Gen Training. Neurology. 2024. PMID: 39514828. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000210002

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。