儿童创伤救治中的低价值临床实践
该回顾性多中心队列研究纳入加拿大省级创伤系统2016年4月1日至2022年3月31日收治的10711例16岁以下儿童,基于儿童创伤临床实践指南的系统评价识别低价值实践并评估其发生率和医院间变异。共识别19项低价值实践,其中14项(74%)可通过创伤登记数据评估;5项实践频率中至高且存在医院间变异:低风险儿童头颅CT 7.1%(33例/1000例入院,组内相关系数8.6%)、有明确转院指征儿童的转院前CT 67.6%(4例/1000例入院,组内相关系数5.7%)、无临床重要颅内病变儿童神经外科会诊11.6%(13例/1000例入院,组内相关系数15.8%)、孤立性轻度创伤性脑损伤住院38.8%(98例/1000例入院,组内相关系数12.4%)、孤立性轻度钝性腹部创伤住院10%(5例/1000例入院,组内相关系数31%)。作者认为这些低价值实践频繁且存在医院间变异,可能作为去实施干预的优先目标,尤其因其可通过常规收集数据测量。
要点
- 低风险儿童头颅CT使用率7.1%(33例/1000例入院),组内相关系数8.6%,提示存在医院间变异。
- 有明确转院指征的儿童转院前CT使用率67.6%(4例/1000例入院),组内相关系数5.7%。
- 无临床重要颅内病变儿童接受神经外科会诊的比例为11.6%(13例/1000例入院),组内相关系数15.8%。
- 孤立性轻度创伤性脑损伤住院率38.8%(98例/1000例入院),组内相关系数12.4%。
- 孤立性轻度钝性腹部创伤住院率10%(5例/1000例入院),组内相关系数31%,为变异程度最高的实践。
适用人群与场景
- 加拿大省级创伤系统内59家创伤中心收治的16岁以下儿童,收治时间为2016年4月1日至2022年3月31日。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 低价值实践定义为潜在危害超过潜在获益的实践,来源于儿童创伤临床实践指南的系统评价。
- 频率分级:低为≤10%且≤10例,中为>10%或>10例,高为>10%且>10例。
- 医院间变异按组内相关系数分级:低为<5%,中为5%-20%,高为>20%。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为回顾性多中心队列研究,纳入10711例儿童(平均[标准差]年龄7.4[4.9]岁;6645例[62%]为男孩)。
- 共识别19项低价值实践,涉及影像学、液体复苏、住院/重症监护病房入住、专科会诊、深静脉血栓预防和实体器官损伤的外科管理;其中14项(74%)可通过创伤登记数据评估。
- 5项实践频率中至高且存在医院间变异:低风险儿童头颅CT 7.1%(33例/1000例入院,组内相关系数8.6%);有明确转院指征儿童的转院前CT 67.6%(4例/1000例入院,组内相关系数5.7%);无临床重要颅内病变儿童神经外科会诊11.6%(13例/1000例入院,组内相关系数15.8%);孤立性轻度创伤性脑损伤住院38.8%(98例/1000例入院,组内相关系数12.4%);孤立性轻度钝性腹部创伤住院10%(5例/1000例入院,组内相关系数31%)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:回顾性多中心队列研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,这些低价值实践频繁且存在医院间变异,可能作为去实施干预的优先目标,尤其因其可通过常规收集数据测量。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: Reducing low-value care has the potential to improve patient experiences and outcomes and decrease the unnecessary use of health care resources. Research suggests that low-value practices (ie, the potential for harm exceeds the potential for benefit) in adult trauma care are frequent and subject to interhospital variation; evidence on low-value practices in pediatric trauma care is lacking.
OBJECTIVE: To estimate the incidence of low-value practices in pediatric trauma care and evaluate interhospital practice variation.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: A retrospective multicenter cohort study in a Canadian provincial trauma system was conducted. Children younger than 16 years admitted to any of the 59 provincial trauma centers from April 1, 2016, to March 31, 2022, were included.
MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Low-value practices were identified from systematic reviews of clinical practice guidelines on pediatric trauma. The frequencies of low-value practices were evaluated by estimating incidence proportions and cases per 1000 admissions (low if ≤10% and ≤10 cases, moderate if >10% or >10 cases, and high if >10% and >10 cases) were identified. Interhospital variation with intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were assessed (low if <5%, moderate if 5%-20%, and high if >20%).
RESULTS: A total of 10 711 children were included (mean [SD] age, 7.4 [4.9] years; 6645 [62%] boys). Nineteen low-value practices on imaging, fluid resuscitation, hospital/intensive care unit admission, specialist consultation, deep vein thrombosis prophylaxis, and surgical management of solid organ injuries were identified. Of these, 14 (74%) could be evaluated using trauma registry data. Five practices had moderate to high frequencies and interhospital variation: head computed tomography in low-risk children (7.1%; 33 per 1000 admissions; ICC, 8.6%), pretransfer computed tomography in children with a clear indication for transfer (67.6%; 4 per 1000 admissions; ICC, 5.7%), neurosurgical consultation in children without clinically important intracranial lesions (11.6%; 13 per 1000 admissions; ICC, 15.8%), hospital admission in isolated mild traumatic brain injury (38.8%; 98 per 1000 admissions; ICC, 12.4%), and hospital admission in isolated minor blunt abdominal trauma (10%; 5 per 1000 admissions; ICC, 31%).
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this cohort study, low-value practices appeared to be frequent and subject to interhospital variation. These practices may represent priority targets for deimplementation interventions, particularly as they can be measured using routinely collected data.
参考来源
- Deshommes T, Freire G, Yanchar N, et al. Low-Value Clinical Practices in Pediatric Trauma Care. JAMA Netw Open. 2024. PMID: 39470640. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.40983
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。