跨性别与性别多元院前患者的照护:NAEMSP 立场声明与资源文件
该立场声明由 NAEMSP 发布,针对跨性别与性别多元(TGD)患者在院前急救中面临的照护障碍提出系列推荐。声明指出 TGD 人群长期面临安全获取医疗服务的显著障碍,性别肯定照护已被显示可显著改善自杀倾向和抑郁等健康结局;院前场景中的性别肯定照护体现为尊重患者认同的性别并维持安全环境以促进积极治疗关系。由于 EMS 临床人员缺乏 TGD 专项培训、TGD 专项研究匮乏以及部分人员对培训的抵触,许多 EMS 系统面临挑战。NAEMSP 据此提出涵盖文化能力、文化谦逊、术语与语言、隐私保护、社会转型与性别肯定治疗理解、创伤知情方法、教育培训、工作场所政策及未来研究等推荐。
要点
- EMS 临床人员应保持对 TGD 人群的基本文化能力,包括熟悉 TGD 相关健康与医疗差异、将 TGD 人群视为服务不足人群、理解污名与跨性别恐惧在造成差异中的核心作用。
- EMS 临床人员应在直接照护、交接和文书记录中使用患者认同的姓名和代词等恰当语言,并理解基本 TGD 专用术语。
- EMS 临床人员应将患者的 TGD 状态视为敏感健康信息,未经患者明确许可不得无意泄露。
- EMS 临床人员应对 TGD 社区展现文化谦逊,包括自我评估知识缺口并开放接受不同生活经验者的新观点与建议。
- EMS 教育与培训应纳入全面照护 TGD 患者的学习领域,提供促进公平照护所需的具体知识与技能。
适用人群与场景
- 跨性别与性别多元(TGD)院前患者
- EMS 临床人员(作为照护提供者与受训对象)
- EMS 工作场所与 EMS 教育/培训体系
处置流程与药物剂量
- EMS 临床人员应保持对 TGD 人群的基本文化能力,包括熟悉 TGD 相关健康与医疗差异、将 TGD 人群视为服务不足人群、理解污名与跨性别恐惧在造成差异及其他使 TGD 人群日常生活复杂化的挑战中的核心作用。
- EMS 临床人员应对 TGD 社区展现文化谦逊,包括自我评估知识缺口,以及开放接受来自不同生活经验者的新观点、信息和建议。
- EMS 临床人员应理解基本 TGD 专用术语,并在直接患者照护、交接和文书记录中使用恰当语言,包括患者认同的姓名和代词。
- EMS 临床人员应将患者的 TGD 状态视为敏感健康信息,注意未经患者明确许可不得无意泄露此信息。
- EMS 临床人员应对社会转型以及性别肯定的内科和外科治疗有基本了解。
- EMS 临床人员在照护 TGD 患者时应采用创伤知情方法。
- EMS 教育与培训应纳入涉及 TGD 患者全面照护的学习领域,教育内容应提供促进公平照护所需的具体知识和技能。
- EMS 工作场所应实施改善 TGD 人员招聘与留任的政策,涵盖骚扰保护、非歧视实践、包容性工作环境、平等晋升机会和定制员工福利。
研究设计与关键结果
- 制定机构:NAEMSP;方法:立场声明与资源文件;证据分级体系:原文未报告具体分级体系。
- TGD 人群长期面临安全获取医疗服务的显著障碍,尤其是性别肯定照护,后者已被显示可显著改善自杀倾向和抑郁等健康结局。
- 院前场景中,性别肯定照护相当于尊重 TGD 患者认同的性别并维持安全环境,以在整个接诊过程中促进积极治疗关系。
- 许多 EMS 系统面临挑战,原因包括 EMS 临床人员缺乏 TGD 专项培训、缺乏 TGD 专项研究以指导 EMS 教育和临床照护,以及部分情况下 EMS 临床人员对这类培训的抵触。
- TGD 人群正面临获取基本医疗服务法律途径的倒退。
- NAEMSP 与其他专业医学会一道提供改善 TGD 患者照护的推荐,从而 affirming TGD 个体作为真实自我存在的权利,以及他们与顺性别同龄人一样获得同等高质量院前医疗照护的权利。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:立场声明与资源文件(指南/共识)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 在抢救室与 ICU 床旁交接及文书记录中,使用患者认同的姓名和代词。
- 未经患者明确许可,不向他人泄露其 TGD 状态。
- 照护 TGD 患者时采用创伤知情方法。
- EMS 教育与培训纳入全面照护 TGD 患者的学习领域。
- EMS 工作场所实施改善 TGD 人员招聘与留任的政策,涵盖骚扰保护、非歧视实践、包容性工作环境、平等晋升机会和定制员工福利。
指南或共识出处
- NAEMSP 立场声明与资源文件:Caring for Transgender and Gender Diverse Prehospital Patients: A NAEMSP Position Statement and Resource Document(Prehosp Emerg Care)
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Transgender and gender diverse (TGD) people have long faced significant barriers to safely accessing medical care-especially gender-affirming care, which has been shown to strikingly improve health outcomes like suicidality and depression. In the prehospital setting, gender-affirming care amounts to showing respect for the TGD patient's identified gender and maintaining a safe environment that fosters a positive therapeutic relationship throughout the encounter. This represents a challenge for many Emergency Medical Services (EMS) systems due to the lack of TGD-specific training for EMS clinicians, a paucity of TGD-specific research to inform EMS education and clinical care, and in some cases the resistance of EMS clinicians to such training. Transgender and gender diverse people are facing a regression in legal access to essential medical care. With this position statement, NAEMSP joins other professional medical societies in providing recommendations to improve care for TGD patients, thereby affirming TGD individuals' right to exist as their authentic selves, as well as their entitlement to the same high-quality prehospital medical care as their cisgender peers.
NAEMSP RECOMMENDSEMS clinicians should maintain basic cultural competency regarding TGD populations, including familiarity with TGD-related health and health care disparities, consideration of TGD populations as underserved, and understanding the centrality of stigma and transphobia in creating disparities and other challenges which complicate daily life for TGD people.EMS clinicians should demonstrate cultural humility toward the TGD community, which includes self-assessment of knowledge gaps, as well as openness to new or unfamiliar ideas, information, and advice from those with different lived experiences.EMS clinicians should understand basic TGD-specific terminology and use appropriate language–including patient-identified names and pronouns–during direct patient care, in handoffs, and in documentation.EMS clinicians should treat a patient’s TGD status as sensitive health information and take care not to inadvertently disclose this information without the patient’s express permission.EMS clinicians should have a basic understanding of social transitioning and of gender-affirming medical and surgical treatments.EMS clinicians should employ a trauma-informed approach when caring for TGD patients.EMS education and training should incorporate learning domains that address comprehensive care for TGD patients, with educational content providing the specific knowledge and skills required to promote equitable care.EMS workplaces should implement policies to improve recruitment and retention of TGD personnel, covering harassment protection, nondiscrimination practices, inclusive working environments, equal advancement opportunity, and tailored employee benefits.Future EMS research should focus on elucidating the disparities in and barriers to prehospital care of the TGD patient population with emphasis on patient experience and education of prehospital clinicians.
参考来源
- Hong T, Case V, Farcas AM, et al. Caring for Transgender and Gender Diverse Prehospital Patients: A NAEMSP Position Statement and Resource Document. Prehosp Emerg Care. 2024. PMID: 39422378. doi:10.1080/10903127.2024.2411723
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。