文献速递创伤与烧伤重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

2023-24年加沙地带军事袭击期间通过全球远程医疗倡议支持创伤救治:病例系列

Trauma care supported through a global telemedicine initiative during the 2023-24 military assault on the Gaza Strip, occupied Palestinian territory: a case series.
PubMed 文献 · Lancet · 2024-01-01
一句话结论在加沙纳赛尔医院,外科团队通过WhatsApp国际远程医疗群对12例武器伤患者进行多学科会诊,但92%失访,凸显极端环境下远程医疗作用有限。

本文报告2023年10月7日后加沙地带纳赛尔医院外科团队通过WhatsApp国际远程医疗群分享的12例武器伤病例系列,患者于2024年1月28日至2月12日收治,多为穿透伤(11/12,92%),包括儿童(4/12,33%)。远程医疗群发展为超过15个专科和损伤导向亚组、超过1000名成员,通过非靶向社交媒体外展和滚雪球招募加入。所有病例经患者口头同意后以多学科团队方式讨论。大多数患者失访(11/12,92%),受以色列国防军入侵医院影响,医院随后停止运作,1例患者死亡。作者认为远程医疗增强了团队处理大规模伤亡的能力,但受人员不足、服务不足和围困的医疗系统选择极其有限。

要点

  • 纳赛尔医院外科团队通过WhatsApp国际远程医疗群对2024年1月28日至2月12日收治的12例武器伤患者进行多学科会诊,其中穿透伤11例(92%)。
  • 12例患者中女性4例(33%)、男性8例(67%),儿童(<18岁)4例(33%),年龄范围3岁至70岁,中位年龄25岁。
  • 损伤部位:头颈部4例(33%)、腹部4例(33%)、胸部3例(25%)、骨盆2例(17%)、四肢1例(8%)。
  • 远程医疗群有超过15个专科和损伤导向亚组、超过1000名成员,通过非靶向社交媒体外展和滚雪球招募加入。
  • 大多数患者失访(11/12,92%),受以色列国防军入侵医院影响,医院随后停止运作,1例患者死亡。

适用人群与场景

  • 2024年1月28日至2月12日收治于加沙纳赛尔医院(Nasser Medical Complex)的武器伤患者,共12例纳入病例系列。
  • 患者年龄范围3岁至70岁,中位年龄25岁;女性4例(33%),男性8例(67%),儿童(<18岁)4例(33%)。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 外科团队通过WhatsApp(Meta;美国加州门洛帕克)端到端加密智能手机应用,在国际远程医疗群中分享武器伤病例进行咨询。
  • 所有病例在获得患者口头同意后分享,并通过多学科团队方式讨论。
  • 远程医疗群发展为超过15个专科和损伤导向亚组、超过1000名成员,成员通过非靶向社交媒体外展和滚雪球招募加入。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 病例系列包含12例精选患者,来自2024年1月28日至2月12日期间纳赛尔医院收治的数百名患者。
  • 损伤类型:穿透伤11例(92%),其中碎片伤6例、枪伤5例;直接爆炸伤1例。
  • 损伤部位:头颈部4例(33%)、腹部4例(33%)、胸部3例(25%)、骨盆2例(17%)、四肢1例(8%)。
  • 大多数患者失访(11/12,92%),受以色列国防军入侵医院影响,医院随后停止运作;1例患者死亡。
  • 2024年6月获得加沙当地赫尔辛基委员会伦理批准;此前因卫生部包括当地赫尔辛基委员会暂停所有运作,无法在加沙进行前瞻性注册和正式伦理批准。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:病例系列。
  • 局限:原文报告大多数患者失访(11/12,92%),受以色列国防军入侵医院影响,医院随后停止运作;前瞻性注册和正式伦理批准在加沙无法进行;远程医疗在极端严峻环境中效用可能降低。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,在加沙南部现已停止运作的纳赛尔医院,医疗团队调整了极低资源的分配和分发,并依赖智能手机进行专业远程医疗外展,这增强了医疗团队处理军事袭击大规模伤亡的能力,而很少有人受过此类训练。
  • 作者认为,尽管有此类远程医疗倡议,对于人员不足、服务不足和受围困的医疗系统,可用的选择极其有限。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: Hospitals, patients, and health-care workers are legally protected by international humanitarian law and the Geneva Convention. However, since Oct 7, 2023, the health-care system in the Gaza Strip, occupied Palestinian territory, has been under unprecedented direct military attacks by Israel, with support for patients proving to be challenging for the remaining health-care workers. Peer-to-peer telemedicine holds promise for assisting surgeons in high-risk, low-resource environments, but might be of reduced utility in extremely austere settings.

METHODS: We present a patient case series of traumatic injuries shared in an international telemedicine group by the surgical team at Nasser Medical Complex, also known as Nasser Hospital, the largest remaining partially functioning hospital in Gaza. WhatsApp (Meta; Menlo Park, CA, USA), a widely available and user-friendly end-to-end encrypted smartphone application, was used to facilitate consultations for weapon-inflicted injuries. All the presented patient cases were shared after obtaining verbal consent from the patients and discussed through a multidisciplinary team approach. The group was developed into a community with more than 15 specialty and injury-oriented subgroups and over 1000 members who joined through non-targeted social media outreach followed by snowball recruitment. Prospective registration and formal ethics approval in Gaza was impossible because the Ministry of Health, including the local Helsinki Committee, had suspended all operations. In June, 2024, we obtained ethics approval from the local Helsinki committee in Gaza.

FINDINGS: We present 12 select patient case studies from a pool of hundreds of patients admitted to Nasser Hospital between Jan 28 and Feb 12, 2024. Four (33%) of the 12 patients were female and eight (67%) were male, with four patients (33%) being children (younger than 18 years). The age range was between 3 years and 70 years, with a median age of 25 years. Most patients presented with penetrating injuries (11 [92%] of 12), with six patients presenting with wounds secondary to fragment injury, and five patients presenting with wounds due to gunshots. One patient presented with a direct blast injury. The site of reported injuries included head and neck areas (four [33%] of 12), abdomen (four [33%] of 12), chest (three [25%] of 12), pelvis (two [17%] of 12), and limbs (one [8%] of 12). Most patients were lost to follow-up (11 [92%] of 12) and were affected by the invasion of the hospital by the Israeli Defense Forces, which subsequently rendered the hospital non-functional. One patient died following their injury.

INTERPRETATION: The health-care team at the now non-functioning Nasser Hospital in southern Gaza adapted their allocation and distribution of extremely low resources and relied on smartphones for specialised telemedicine outreach purposes. This enhanced the capability of the medical teams in management of mass casualties of military assaults that few are trained to work in. Nonetheless, the options available to a health-care system that is under-staffed, under-served, and under siege, are extremely constrained, regardless of such telemedicine initiatives.

来源:Lancet,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Alser K, Mallah SI, El-Oun YRA, et al. Trauma care supported through a global telemedicine initiative during the 2023-24 military assault on the Gaza Strip, occupied Palestinian territory: a case series. Lancet. 2024. PMID: 39216977. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(24)01170-X

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。