文献速递重症综合管理与镇静镇痛消化、代谢与肾脏急症

指导医生改善成人住院患者潜在过度治疗中的伦理决策:CODE阶梯楔形整群随机对照试验

Coaching doctors to improve ethical decision-making in adult hospitalized patients potentially receiving excessive treatment. The CODE stepped-wedge cluster randomized controlled trial.
PubMed 文献 · Intensive Care Med · 2024-09-04
一句话结论指导医生进行团队伦理决策可安全提高住院潜在过度治疗患者书面不插管/不尝试心肺复苏医嘱的发生率,但未改善伦理氛围质量。

本研究在Ghent大学医院医疗ICU及9个内科病房开展阶梯楔形整群随机对照试验,评估指导医生伦理决策是否能改善目标导向医疗(以书面不插管/不尝试心肺复苏医嘱为操作指标)及伦理氛围质量。结果显示,在潜在过度治疗患者中,干预组书面医嘱发生率为29.7% vs 对照组19.6%(OR 4.24,95%CI 4.21-4.27;P<0.001);总体人群中为3.4% vs 1.9%(OR 1.65,95%CI 1.12-2.43;P=0.011)。1年死亡率在潜在过度治疗患者中为85% vs 83.7%(HR 2.76,95%CI 1.26-6.04;P=0.011),总体人群为14.5% vs 15.1%(HR 0.89,95%CI 0.72-1.09;P=0.251)。伦理决策氛围问卷前后平均差异为0.02分(95%CI -0.18至0.23;P=0.815)。结论提示指导医生伦理决策可安全改善目标导向医疗,但未同时改善伦理氛围质量。

要点

  • 在潜在过度治疗患者中,指导医生伦理决策使书面不插管/不尝试心肺复苏医嘱发生率从19.6%升至29.7%(OR 4.24,95%CI 4.21-4.27;P<0.001)。
  • 总体住院人群中,干预组书面医嘱发生率为3.4% vs 对照组1.9%(OR 1.65,95%CI 1.12-2.43;P=0.011)。
  • 潜在过度治疗患者1年死亡率为85% vs 83.7%(HR 2.76,95%CI 1.26-6.04;P=0.011),总体人群为14.5% vs 15.1%(HR 0.89,95%CI 0.72-1.09;P=0.251)。
  • 伦理决策氛围问卷(EDMCQ)研究前后平均差异为0.02分(95%CI -0.18至0.23;P=0.815),无显著改善。
  • 93名医生中50名(53.7%)参与指导,平均4.36(标准差2.55)次课程;7254名患者中125名(1.7%)被识别为潜在过度治疗。

适用人群与场景

  • 成人住院患者,入住医疗ICU或9个转诊内科病房,被临床医生通过电子警报匿名识别为潜在过度治疗(PET)者。
  • 研究纳入Ghent大学医院医疗ICU及9个内科病房的住院患者,研究期间为2022年2月至2023年2月。
  • 排除:研究开始时已有书面不插管/不尝试心肺复苏医嘱的患者(PET中26例,总体人群624例)不纳入主要分析。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 潜在过度治疗(PET)由医生和护士通过电子警报匿名识别。
  • 主要终点指标为书面不插管/不尝试心肺复苏(DNI-DNACPR)医嘱的发生率。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 干预为对医生进行伦理决策指导,为期4个月;所有科室随机分配至4个月指导期,比较至少1个月指导与少于1个月指导及常规护理。
  • 医生和护士在研究前后填写伦理决策氛围问卷(EDMCQ)。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 研究类型:阶梯楔形整群随机对照试验;地点:Ghent大学医院医疗ICU及9个内科病房;时间:2022年2月至2023年2月。
  • 研究前后分别有442名和423名临床医生工作,分别有270名(61%)和261名(61.7%)填写EDMCQ。
  • 93名医生中50名(53.7%)参与指导,平均(标准差)4.36(2.55)次课程。
  • 7254名患者中125名(1.7%)被识别为PET,其中16例缺失结局数据。
  • PET患者中26例、总体人群中624例在研究开始时已有书面DNI-DNACPR医嘱,主要分析纳入83例PET患者,事后分析纳入6614例总体患者。
  • 主要终点:PET患者中干预组 vs 对照组书面DNI-DNACPR医嘱估计发生率分别为29.7% vs 19.6%(OR 4.24,95%CI 4.21-4.27;P<0.001);总体人群中为3.4% vs 1.9%(OR 1.65,95%CI 1.12-2.43;P=0.011)。
  • 次要终点:PET患者1年死亡率干预组 vs 对照组为85% vs 83.7%(HR 2.76,95%CI 1.26-6.04;P=0.011);总体人群为14.5% vs 15.1%(HR 0.89,95%CI 0.72-1.09;P=0.251)。
  • EDMCQ研究前后平均差异为0.02分(95%CI -0.18至0.23;P=0.815)。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:阶梯楔形整群随机对照试验。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,指导医生进行团队伦理决策可安全改善住院潜在过度治疗患者的目标导向医疗(以书面DNI-DNACPR医嘱为操作指标),但未同时改善伦理氛围质量。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to assess whether coaching doctors to enhance ethical decision-making in teams improves (1) goal-oriented care operationalized via written do-not-intubate and do-not attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation (DNI-DNACPR) orders in adult patients potentially receiving excessive treatment (PET) during their first hospital stay and (2) the quality of the ethical climate.

METHODS: We carried out a stepped-wedge cluster randomized controlled trial in the medical intensive care unit (ICU) and 9 referring internal medicine departments of Ghent University Hospital between February 2022 and February 2023. Doctors and nurses in charge of hospitalized patients filled out the ethical decision-making climate questionnaire (ethical decision-making climate questionnaire, EDMCQ) before and after the study, and anonymously identified PET via an electronic alert during the entire study period. All departments were randomly assigned to a 4-month coaching. At least one month of coaching was compared to less than one month coaching and usual care. The first primary endpoint was the incidence of written DNI-DNACPR decisions. The second primary endpoint was the EDMCQ before and after the study period. Because clinicians identified less PET than required to detect a difference in written DNI-DNACPR decisions, a post-hoc analysis on the overall population was performed. To reduce type I errors, we further restricted the analysis to one of our predefined secondary endpoints (mortality up to 1 year).

RESULTS: Of the 442 and 423 clinicians working before and after the study period, respectively 270 (61%) and 261 (61.7%) filled out the EDMCQ. Fifty of the 93 (53.7%) doctors participated in the coaching for a mean (standard deviation [SD]) of 4.36 (2.55) sessions. Of the 7254 patients, 125 (1.7%) were identified as PET, with 16 missing outcome data. Twenty-six of the PET and 624 of the overall population already had a written DNI-DNACPR decision at study entry, resulting in 83 and 6614 patients who were included in the main and post hoc analysis, respectively. The estimated incidence of written DNI-DNACPR decisions in the intervention vs. control arm was, respectively, 29.7% vs. 19.6% (odds ratio 4.24, 95% confidence interval 4.21-4.27; P < 0.001) in PET and 3.4% vs. 1.9% (1.65, 1.12-2.43; P = 0.011) in the overall study population. The estimated mortality at one year was respectively 85% vs. 83.7% (hazard ratio 2.76, 1.26-6.04; P = 0.011) and 14.5% vs. 15.1% (0.89, 0.72-1.09; P = 0.251). The mean difference in EDMCQ before and after the study period was 0.02 points (- 0.18 to 0.23; P = 0.815).

CONCLUSION: This study suggests that coaching doctors regarding ethical decision-making in teams safely improves goal-oriented care operationalized via written DNI-DNACPR decisions in hospitalized patients, however without concomitantly improving the quality of the ethical climate.

来源:Intensive Care Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Benoit DD, De Pauw A, Jacobs C, et al. Coaching doctors to improve ethical decision-making in adult hospitalized patients potentially receiving excessive treatment. The CODE stepped-wedge cluster randomized controlled trial. Intensive Care Med. 2024. PMID: 39230678. doi:10.1007/s00134-024-07588-0

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。