哪些因素影响救护车临床医生预先通知急诊科的决定:英国救护车服务与急诊科预先通知实践的定性探索
该定性研究通过34名救护车临床医生和40名急诊科人员的半结构化访谈,以及在六家接收急诊科对143次预先通知(从呼叫到交接)进行的162小时观察,探讨预先通知决策实践。结果显示决策涉及基于生理观察、临床判断和恶化风险的快速评估,并参考预先通知指南;临床经验(模式识别与直觉)和信心帮助判断哪些患者需要到达后立即急诊救治或恶化风险最高。救护车临床医生主要通过「在岗」学习和非正式反馈机制学习预先通知,临床决策支持的可用性和获取途径不一,且不同救护车服务与急诊科之间预先通知标准的差异给决策带来困难,对经验较少的临床医生尤为挑战。作者认为,实践中的一致性可能通过更大程度的指南与方案标准化、培训、绩效反馈获取以及跨服务协作来改善,以尽量减少潜在紧张来源。
要点
- 预先通知决策基于生理观察、临床判断和感知的恶化风险进行快速临床风险评估,并参考预先通知指南。
- 临床经验(模式识别与直觉)和信心帮助救护车临床医生识别需要到达后立即急诊救治或恶化风险最高的患者。
- 救护车临床医生主要通过「在岗」学习和非正式反馈机制(包括急诊科对既往预先通知的反应)学习预先通知。
- 临床决策支持的可用性和获取途径不一,临床医生在利用指南与方案和保留临床判断与自主性之间进行平衡。
- 不同救护车服务与急诊科之间预先通知标准的差异造成决策困难,对经验较少的临床医生尤为挑战。
适用人群与场景
- 来自三个救护车服务的34名救护车临床医生和来自六家接收急诊科的40名急诊科人员。
- 在六家急诊科对预先通知(n=143,从呼叫到交接)的反应进行162小时观察。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:定性研究,采用半结构化访谈和观察法。
- 样本量:访谈34名救护车临床医生(来自三个救护车服务)和40名急诊科人员(来自六家接收急诊科);观察162小时,涉及143次预先通知(从呼叫到交接),在六家急诊科进行。
- 预先通知决策涉及基于生理观察、临床判断和感知的恶化风险进行快速临床风险评估,并参考预先通知指南。
- 临床经验(模式识别和直觉)和信心帮助救护车临床医生理解哪些患者需要到达后立即急诊救治或恶化风险最高。
- 救护车临床医生主要通过「在岗」学习和非正式反馈机制(包括急诊科对既往预先通知的反应)学习预先通知。
- 临床决策支持的可用性和获取途径不一,临床医生在利用指南和方案与担忧保留临床判断和自主性之间进行平衡。
- 不同救护车服务与急诊科之间预先通知标准的差异造成决定是否预先通知的困难,对经验较少的临床医生尤为挑战。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:定性研究(半结构化访谈和观察)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,实践中的一致性可能通过更大程度的指南和方案标准化、培训、绩效反馈获取以及跨服务协作来改善,以尽量减少潜在紧张来源。
- 作者指出,识别到的决策中可能存在可避免的变异,对患者护理和急救资源有影响,并可能在服务之间造成紧张。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Ambulance clinicians use pre-alerts to inform receiving hospitals of the imminent arrival of a time-critical patient considered to require immediate attention, enabling the receiving emergency department (ED) or other clinical area to prepare. Pre-alerts are key to ensuring immediate access to appropriate care, but unnecessary pre-alerts can divert resources from other patients and fuel 'pre-alert fatigue' among ED staff. This research aims to provide a better understanding of pre-alert decision-making practice.
METHODS: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 34 ambulance clinicians from three ambulance services and 40 ED staff from six receiving EDs. Observation (162 hours) of responses to pre-alerts (n=143, call-to-handover) was also conducted in the six EDs. Interview transcripts and observation notes were imported into NVIVO and analysed using thematic analysis.
FINDINGS: Pre-alert decisions involve rapid assessment of clinical risk based on physiological observations, clinical judgement and perceived risk of deterioration, with reference to pre-alert guidance. Clinical experience (pattern recognition and intuition) and confidence helped ambulance clinicians to understand which patients required immediate ED care on arrival or were at highest risk of deterioration. Ambulance clinicians primarily learnt to pre-alert 'on the job' and via informal feedback mechanisms, including the ED response to previous pre-alerts. Availability and access to clinical decision support was variable, and clinicians balanced the use of guidance and protocols with concerns about retention of clinical judgement and autonomy. Differences in pre-alert criteria between ambulance services and EDs created difficulties in deciding whether to pre-alert and was particularly challenging for less experienced clinicians.
CONCLUSION: We identified potentially avoidable variation in decision-making, which has implications for patient care and emergency care resources, and can create tension between the services. Consistency in practice may be improved by greater standardisation of guidance and protocols, training and access to performance feedback and cross-service collaboration to minimise potential sources of tension.
参考来源
- O'Hara R, Sampson FC, Long J, et al. What influences ambulance clinician decisions to pre-alert emergency departments: a qualitative exploration of pre-alert practice in UK ambulance services and emergency departments. Emerg Med J. 2024. PMID: 39153848. doi:10.1136/emermed-2023-213849
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。