构建芬兰电话分诊服务的绩效测量框架:基于名义群体技术的共识研究
本研究在芬兰20家最大联合急诊科中选取8名经验丰富的高级医师,采用名义群体技术(NGT)就电话分诊绩效测量达成共识。绩效指标先经2021年12月10日至12月27日(8名专家参与)及2021年12月29日至2022年1月23日(其中5名专家回复)的德尔菲法轮次识别,最终框架验证先于2022年2月13日至3月3日进行一轮(收到5份回复),因回复数量有限,又于2023年10月29日至11月7日增加一轮验证(新增2份回复,验证阶段总回复者达7人)。最终框架从服务可及性、患者体验、质量与安全、流程结局、每例成本五个维度评估电话分诊,并确立8项具体绩效指标。该框架为结构化、全面测量电话分诊服务整体绩效提供了方法。
要点
- 最终框架从服务可及性、患者体验、质量与安全、流程结局、每例成本五个维度评估电话分诊绩效。
- 确立8项绩效指标:电话应答指标、服务效用、随访照护类型与分布、ICPC-2分类的就诊原因、患者对随访照护的依从性、评估时病史回顾、每次通话服务成本。
- 研究识别出专业人员强烈希望实施统一的电话分诊绩效测量框架。
- 共识由芬兰20家最大联合急诊科的8名高级医师参与形成,这些急诊科服务超过90%人口的紧急照护。
- 最终框架验证阶段共7名回复者,其中2022年2月13日至3月3日一轮收到5份回复,2023年10月29日至11月7日追加一轮新增2份回复。
适用人群与场景
- 芬兰20家最大联合急诊科的高级医师,这些急诊科服务超过90%人口的紧急照护。
- 电话分诊服务绩效评估场景。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为基于名义群体技术(NGT)的共识研究,在芬兰开展,8名来自20家最大联合急诊科的经验丰富高级医师参与。
- 绩效指标经德尔菲法轮次识别:2021年12月10日至12月27日8名专家参与,2021年12月29日至2022年1月23日其中5名专家回复。
- 最终框架验证:2022年2月13日至3月3日一轮收到5份回复;因回复数量有限,2023年10月29日至11月7日追加一轮新增2份回复,验证阶段总回复者7人。
- 最终框架从五个维度评估电话分诊:服务可及性、患者体验、质量与安全、流程结局、每例成本。
- 确立8项具体绩效指标,包括电话应答指标、服务效用、随访照护类型与分布、ICPC-2分类的就诊原因、患者对随访照护的依从性、评估时病史回顾、每次通话服务成本。
- 研究识别出专业人员强烈希望实施统一的电话分诊绩效测量框架。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:基于名义群体技术(NGT)的共识研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为该框架提供了结构化、全面的方法来测量电话分诊服务的整体绩效,增强有效评估这些服务的能力。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: There has been a significant expansion in the measurement of healthcare system performance. However, there is a lack of a comprehensive performance measurement framework to assess the effects of telephone triage services on the urgent care system. The aim of our Delphi study was to construct and validate a performance measurement framework designed explicitly for telephone triage services.
METHODS: This study was conducted in Finland with a group of eight experienced senior physicians from the country's 20 largest joint emergency departments, serving over 90% of the population for urgent care. The Nominal Group Technique (NGT) was utilised to achieve consensus on measuring telephone triage performance. Initially, performance indicators (PIs) were identified through Delphi method rounds from December 10th to December 27th, 2021, with eight experts participating, and from December 29th, 2021, to January 23rd, 2022, where five of these experts responded. NGT further deepened these themes and perspectives, aiding in the development of a comprehensive performance measurement framework. The final framework validation began with an initial round from February 13th to March 3rd, 2022, receiving five responses. Due to the limited number of responses, an additional validation round was conducted from October 29th to November 7th, 2023, resulting in two more responses, increasing the total number of respondents in the validation phase to seven.
RESULTS: The study identified a strong desire among professionals to implement a uniform framework for measuring telephone triage performance. The finalised framework evaluates telephone triage across five dimensions: service accessibility, patient experience, quality and safety, process outcome, and cost per case. Eight specific PIs were established, including call response metrics, service utility, follow-up care type and distribution, ICPC-2 classified encounter reasons, patient compliance with follow-up care, medical history review during assessment, and service cost per call.
CONCLUSIONS: This study validated a performance measurement framework for telephone triage services, utilising existing literature and the NGT method. The framework includes five key dimensions: patient experience, quality and safety, outcome of the telephone triage process, cost per case, and eight PIs. It offers a structured and comprehensive approach to measuring the overall performance of telephone triage services, enhancing our ability to evaluate these services effectively.
参考来源
- Vainio H, Soininen L, Torkki P, et al. Building a performance measurement framework for telephone triage services in Finland: a consensus-making study based on nominal group technique. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med. 2024. PMID: 39138499. doi:10.1186/s13049-024-01243-9
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。