谁需要止血带?谁不需要?俄乌战争中止血带使用回顾的经验教训
该文回顾了俄乌战争中止血带使用相关并发症及美国民用和乌克兰无医学指征止血带使用的发生率,并于2023年12月在波兰华沙举行美乌止血带工作组面对面会议。结果显示,乌克兰作战部队中因无指征使用止血带叠加长后送时间,正在发生不必要的截肢和危及生命的长时间止血带应用综合征;具体并发症数字属机密信息不可得,但乌克兰军队医疗人员与美方顾问多来源一致认为问题严重。结论认为美军在未来多种后送延迟的战斗场景中也可能发生不必要的止血带相关并发症;院前创伤培训(包括战术战伤救治)对避免无医学指征时留置止血带强调不足,未来TCCC和民用急救者课程应加强此方面。
要点
- 止血带在民用和军事环境中均已证明可救命,急救者应继续对危及生命的肢体出血创伤患者使用。
- 并非每处肢体伤口都需要止血带;识别何种程度出血需要止血带、何种不需要,是控制致命性肢体出血的最重要方面之一。
- 多项军事和民用研究显示,止血带常在无医学指征时被使用;在伊拉克、阿富汗近期冲突及美国城市民用环境中,止血带过度使用未导致额外发病率。
- 在长时间后送条件下,无医学指征使用止血带可使其从救命干预变为可能导致可避免截肢及一系列代谢紊乱和急性肾损伤(统称长时间止血带应用综合征)的干预。
- 乌克兰作战部队中因无指征使用止血带叠加长后送时间,正在发生不必要的截肢和危及生命的长时间止血带应用综合征。
适用人群与场景
- 急救者面对的创伤患者,尤其是战斗场景中伤员和急救者可能同时面临敌方火力威胁的危及生命肢体出血。
- 乌克兰作战部队中接受止血带使用的伤员。
- 美国民用环境及未来可能后送延迟的美军战斗场景。
红旗征与不能漏的情况
- 危及生命的肢体出血需使用止血带。
- 无医学指征使用止血带在长时间后送时可导致可避免截肢和长时间止血带应用综合征(代谢紊乱和急性肾损伤)。
研究设计与关键结果
- 乌克兰作战部队中因无指征使用止血带联合俄乌战争中的长后送时间,正在发生不必要的截肢和危及生命的长时间止血带应用综合征。
- 乌克兰部队在当前冲突中止血带使用并发症的具体数字属机密信息不可得,但乌克兰军队医疗人员与美方顾问多来源一致认为问题严重。
- 2023年12月在波兰华沙举行了美乌止血带工作组面对面会议。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:治疗/护理管理;证据等级:Level V。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,院前创伤培训项目(包括但不限于战术战伤救治)对避免无医学指征时留置止血带强调不足;此方面应在未来战术战伤救治(TCCC)和民用急救者课程开发中予以强调。
- 作者指出,关于此主题的临时特别培训方案可在本文提到的网站获取,未来近期可能推出额外培训模式。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Extremity tourniquets have proven to be lifesaving in both civilian and military settings and should continue to be used by first responders for trauma patients with life-threatening extremity bleeding. This is especially true in combat scenarios in which both the casualty and the first responder may be confronted by the imminent threat of death from hostile fire as the extremity hemorrhage is being treated. Not every extremity wound, however, needs a tourniquet. One of the most important aspects of controlling life-threatening extremity bleeding with tourniquets is to recognize what magnitude of bleeding requires this intervention and what magnitude of bleeding does not. Multiple studies, both military and civilian, have shown that tourniquets are often applied when they are not medically indicated. Overuse of extremity tourniquets has not caused excess morbidity in either the recent conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan or in the US urban civilian setting. In the presence of prolonged evacuation, however, applying a tourniquet when it is not medically indicated changes tourniquet application from being a lifesaving intervention to one that may cause an avoidable amputation and the development of an array of metabolic derangements and acute kidney injury collectively called prolonged tourniquet application syndrome.
METHODS: The recent literature was reviewed for papers that documented the complications of tourniquet use resulting from the prolonged casualty evacuation times being seen in the current Russo-Ukrainian war. The literature was also reviewed for the incidence of tourniquet application that was found to not be medically indicated, in both the US civilian setting and from Ukraine. Finally, an in-person meeting of the US/Ukraine Tourniquet Working Group was held in Warsaw, Poland, in December of 2023.
RESULTS: Unnecessary loss of extremities and life-threatening episodes of prolonged tourniquet application syndrome are currently occurring in Ukrainian combat forces because of nonindicated tourniquet use combined with the prolonged evacuation time seen in the Russo-Ukrainian war. Specific numbers of the complications experienced as a result of tourniquet use by Ukrainian forces in the current conflict are treated as classified information and are not available, but multiple sources from the Ukrainian military medical personnel and from the US advisors providing medical assistance to Ukraine have all agreed that the problem is substantial.
CONCLUSION: Unnecessary tourniquet morbidity might also occur in US forces in a variety of potential future combat scenarios in which evacuation to surgical care is delayed. Prehospital trauma training programs, including but not limited to tactical combat casualty care, place insufficient emphasis on the need to avoid leaving tourniquets in place when they are not medically indicated. This aspect of training should receive emphasis in future Tactical Combat Casualty Care (TCCC) and civilian first responder curriculum development. An interim ad hoc training solution on this topic is available at the websites noted in this articles. Additional training modalities may follow in the near future.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic/Care Management; Level V.
参考来源
- Butler F, Holcomb JB, Dorlac W, et al. Who needs a tourniquet? And who does not? Lessons learned from a review of tourniquet use in the Russo-Ukrainian war. J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2024. PMID: 38996420. doi:10.1097/TA.0000000000004395
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。