基于客观评估的院内应急反应能力影响因素分析
该横断面研究于2021年12月在中日友好医院纳入75名医护人员(ICU 50名,含医生24名、护士26名;普通内科病房25名,含医生10名、护士15名),采用美国心脏协会(AHA)复苏质量改进(RQI)模型在成人和婴儿模拟人上评估胸外按压和面罩通气技能。ICU人员成人按压评分82.5(66.0,96.5)vs普通内科65.0(52.5,74.5),成人通气评分82.0(68.8,98.0)vs 61.0(48.0,82.0),均P<0.01;护士成人按压评分77.0(68.5,89.5)vs医生63.0(40.8,90.3)、婴儿按压评分54.4±25.1 vs 41.5±18.5,均P<0.05;婴儿按压评分48(29,65)vs成人76(58,90)、婴儿通气评分56(42,75)vs成人76(60,96),均P<0.01;施救者位于模型右侧时成人按压评分79.0(65.0,92.0)vs 65.0(51.3,77.0),P<0.05;ICU人员传统主观评分成人按压88.8(79.4,92.5)vs RQI客观评分82.5(66.0,95.5)、成人通气95.0(80.0,98.1)vs 82.0(68.8,98.0),均P<0.01。作者认为丰富的急救经验与CPR技能提升相关,从成人模型右侧进行胸外按压更有效,基于RQI模型的客观评分可能更准确反映受训者表现。
要点
- ICU人员成人按压评分82.5(66.0,96.5)vs普通内科65.0(52.5,74.5),成人通气82.0(68.8,98.0)vs 61.0(48.0,82.0),均P<0.01。
- 护士成人按压评分77.0(68.5,89.5)vs医生63.0(40.8,90.3),婴儿按压评分54.4±25.1 vs 41.5±18.5,均P<0.05。
- 婴儿按压评分48(29,65)vs成人76(58,90),婴儿通气评分56(42,75)vs成人76(60,96),均P<0.01。
- 施救者位于模型右侧时成人按压评分79.0(65.0,92.0)vs 65.0(51.3,77.0),P<0.05。
- ICU人员传统主观评分成人按压88.8(79.4,92.5)vs RQI客观评分82.5(66.0,95.5),成人通气95.0(80.0,98.1)vs 82.0(68.8,98.0),均P<0.01。
适用人群与场景
- 2021年12月在中日友好医院纳入ICU和普通内科病房的医护人员共75名,其中ICU 50名(医生24名、护士26名),普通内科病房25名(医生10名、护士15名)。
研究设计与关键结果
- 横断面研究,共纳入75名医护人员,采用AHA的RQI模型在成人和婴儿模拟人上评估胸外按压和面罩通气技能。
- ICU人员成人按压评分82.5(66.0,96.5)vs普通内科65.0(52.5,74.5),成人通气评分82.0(68.8,98.0)vs 61.0(48.0,82.0),均P<0.01。
- 护士成人按压评分77.0(68.5,89.5)vs医生63.0(40.8,90.3),婴儿按压评分54.4±25.1 vs 41.5±18.5,均P<0.05。
- 婴儿按压评分48(29,65)vs成人76(58,90),婴儿通气评分56(42,75)vs成人76(60,96),均P<0.01。
- 施救者位于模型右侧时成人按压评分79.0(65.0,92.0)vs 65.0(51.3,77.0),P<0.05。
- ICU人员传统主观评分成人按压88.8(79.4,92.5)vs RQI客观评分82.5(66.0,95.5),成人通气95.0(80.0,98.1)vs 82.0(68.8,98.0),均P<0.01。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 横断面研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为丰富的急救经验与CPR技能提升相关,从成人模型右侧进行胸外按压更有效,基于RQI模型的客观评分可能更准确反映受训者表现。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To analyze the factors affecting the quality of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) performed by medical staff in hospital and to explore the training methods to enhance their in-hospital emergency response capabilities.
METHODS: A cross-sectional study was conducted, involving medical staff of intensive care unit (ICU) and general internal medicine wards in China-Japan Friendship Hospital in December 2021. The American Heart Association (AHA) resuscitation quality improvement (RQI) model was used to evaluate the skills of the subjects in performing external chest compressions and bag-mask ventilation on adult and infant simulators. While ICU subjects were undergoing RQI model objective assessment, two instructors also provided subjective scoring for their operations. The study compared the differences in RQI model objective assessment scores between ICU and general internal medicine ward subjects, between doctors and nurses, in the RQI model objective scoring for adult and infant resuscitation, in the scoring differences of different positions for chest compressions, and the differences between traditional subjective scoring and RQI objective scoring when ICU subjects were assessed for compression and ventilation.
RESULTS: A total of 75 medical staffs were enrolled, consisting of 50 from the ICU (including 24 doctors and 26 nurses) and 25 from the general internal medicine wards (including 10 doctors and 15 nurses). The ICU medical staff's scores for adult resuscitation skills were significantly higher than those of the general internal medicine ward medical staff [adult compression score: 82.5 (66.0, 96.5) vs. 65.0 (52.5, 74.5), adult ventilation score: 82.0 (68.8, 98.0) vs. 61.0 (48.0, 82.0), both P < 0.01]. The nursing group's compression scores for both adult and infant were significantly higher than those of the doctor group [adult compression score: 77.0 (68.5, 89.5) vs. 63.0 (40.8, 90.3), infant compression score: 54.4±25.1 vs. 41.5±18.5, both P < 0.05]. The compression and ventilation scores for the infant were significantly lower than those for adult resuscitation [compression score: 48 (29, 65) vs. 76 (58, 90), ventilation score: 56 (42, 75) vs. 76 (60, 96), both P < 0.01]. When the rescuer was positioned on the right side of the model, the compression score for the adult significantly increased [79.0 (65.0, 92.0) vs. 65.0 (51.3, 77.0), P < 0.05]. The ICU medical staff's traditional subjective scores of compression and ventilation assessments for adult were significantly higher than the RQI model objective scores [adult compression score: 88.8 (79.4, 92.5) vs. 82.5 (66.0, 95.5), adult ventilation score: 95.0 (80.0, 98.1) vs. 82.0 (68.8, 98.0), both P < 0.01].
CONCLUSIONS: Rich experience in emergency rescue is related to the improvement of CPR skills, and performing chest compressions from the right side of the adult model is more effective. Objective scoring of resuscitation skills based on the RQI model may more accurately reflect the performance of the trainees.
参考来源
- Cong L, Zhai S, Wang H, et al. [Analysis of factors affecting in-hospital emergency response capability based on objective assessment]. Zhonghua Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue. 2024. PMID: 38991967. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn121430-20240131-00106
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。