机械与人工心肺复苏:当代系统评价的总括综述及新增系统评价
该总括综述纳入2014年1月至2022年3月发表的11篇系统评价,并额外对2021年4月1日至2024年2月15日发表的8项原始研究做新的系统评价,比较机械CPR与人工CPR在IHCA和OHCA中的效果。主要结局包括ROSC、入院存活、出院存活、30天存活及出院时神经功能良好存活。合并结果未显示机械CPR优于人工CPR(少数亚组除外);3项研究显示男性使用机械CPR的机会更高,2项研究显示年轻患者接受机械治疗更多,但研究未按性别或年龄评论结局。多数系统评价和原始研究质量为低至中等,异质性和方法学局限明显。
要点
- 总括综述纳入11篇系统评价(2014年1月—2022年3月),新增系统评价纳入8项原始研究(2021年4月1日—2024年2月15日),比较机械与人工CPR。
- 合并结果未显示机械CPR优于人工CPR,仅在少数选定亚组中可能更优;多数系统评价和原始研究质量为低至中等。
- 3项研究显示男性患者使用机械CPR的机会显著更高;2项研究显示年轻患者接受机械治疗多于老年患者,但研究未按性别或年龄评论结局。
- 作者结论:因异质性显著和方法学局限,现有证据不能确定机械CPR优于人工CPR;在无法实施高质量人工CPR的特定情形下,机械CPR可能更合适。
适用人群与场景
- 纳入院内心搏骤停(IHCA)和院外心搏骤停(OHCA)的系统评价及原始研究,比较机械CPR与人工CPR。
研究设计与关键结果
- 总括综述分析11篇系统评价(2014年1月—2022年3月),并新纳入8项未包含于既往系统评价的原始研究(2021年4月1日—2024年2月15日)进行深入分析。
- 分析的结局包括ROSC、入院存活、出院存活、30天存活及出院时神经功能良好存活。
- 合并结果未显示机械CPR优于人工CPR,仅在少数选定亚组中例外。
- 3项研究显示男性患者使用机械CPR的机会显著更高;2项研究显示年轻患者接受机械治疗多于老年患者;研究未按性别或年龄评论结局。
- 多数系统评价和原始研究质量为低至中等。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:总括综述(umbrella review)及新增系统评价;采用AMSTAR-2和GRADE评估纳入系统评价/研究的质量。
- 多数系统评价和原始研究质量为低至中等。
- 局限:异质性显著、方法学局限,作者认为现有证据不能确定机械CPR优于人工CPR。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为:因异质性显著和方法学局限,现有证据不能确定机械CPR优于人工CPR。
- 作者认为:在无法实施高质量人工CPR的特定情形下,机械CPR可能更合适。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: High-quality cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) can restore spontaneous circulation (ROSC) and neurological function and save lives. We conducted an umbrella review, including previously published systematic reviews (SRs), that compared mechanical and manual CPR; after that, we performed a new SR of the original studies that were not included after the last published SR to provide a panoramic view of the existing evidence on the effectiveness of CPR methods.
METHODS: PubMed, EMBASE, and Medline were searched, including English in-hospital (IHCA) and out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) SRs, and comparing mechanical versus manual CPR. A Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews (AMSTAR-2) and GRADE were used to assess the quality of included SRs/studies. We included both IHCA and OHCA, which compared mechanical and manual CPR. We analyzed at least one of the outcomes of interest, including ROSC, survival to hospital admission, survival to hospital discharge, 30-day survival, and survival to hospital discharge with good neurological function. Furthermore, subgroup analyses were performed for age, gender, initial rhythm, arrest location, and type of CPR devices.
RESULTS: We identified 249 potentially relevant records, of which 238 were excluded. Eleven SRs were analyzed in the Umbrella review (January 2014-March 2022). Furthermore, for a new, additional SR, we identified eight eligible studies (not included in any prior SR) for an in-depth analysis between April 1, 2021, and February 15, 2024. The higher chances of using mechanical CPR for male patients were significantly observed in three studies. Two studies showed that younger patients received more mechanical treatment than older patients. However, studies did not comment on the outcomes based on the patient's gender or age. Most SRs and studies were of low to moderate quality. The pooled findings did not show the superiority of mechanical compared to manual CPR except in a few selected subgroups.
CONCLUSIONS: Given the significant heterogeneity and methodological limitations of the included studies and SRs, our findings do not provide definitive evidence to support the superiority of mechanical CPR over manual CPR. However, mechanical CPR can serve better where high-quality manual CPR cannot be performed in selected situations.
参考来源
- El-Menyar A, Naduvilekandy M, Rizoli S, et al. Mechanical versus manual cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR): an umbrella review of contemporary systematic reviews and more. Crit Care. 2024. PMID: 39080740. doi:10.1186/s13054-024-05037-4
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。