急诊科可持续工作条件的关键因素:EUSEM发起的欧洲范围共识调查
该EUSEM发起的欧洲多国Delphi调查纳入比利时、芬兰、德国、意大利、罗马尼亚和英国六国18名急诊医学领导层专家,覆盖小、中、大三种医院规模。第一轮为结构化访谈,第二轮对第一轮整合的条目(急诊工作系统因素、提供者健康结局、急诊工作生活干预方法)进行相关性评分。结果在四类急诊工作条件类别上获得近乎一致的共识,包括积极条件(如工作挑战、个人动机、病例复杂性)和消极条件(如拥挤、工作流程中断/多任务处理、医疗差错);高度相关的个人不良健康事件包括身体疲劳、精疲力竭和职业倦怠;干预实践方面专家提供了广泛的机会但共识较少。作者结论认为工作系统条件对欧洲急诊提供者工作生活产生正负效应,改善策略应聚焦各国共有的系统相关外部压力源,并为未来地方和系统层面的干预研究奠定科学基础。
要点
- 18名来自六国(比利时、芬兰、德国、意大利、罗马尼亚、英国)的急诊领导层专家参与两轮Delphi调查,覆盖小、中、大三种医院规模。
- 四类急诊工作条件类别获近乎一致共识:积极条件如工作挑战、个人动机、病例复杂性;消极条件如拥挤、工作流程中断/多任务处理、医疗差错。
- 高度相关的个人不良健康事件包括身体疲劳、精疲力竭和职业倦怠。
- 干预实践方面专家提供广泛机会但共识较少,作者认为改善策略应聚焦各国共有的系统相关外部压力源。
适用人群与场景
- 欧洲六国(比利时、芬兰、德国、意大利、罗马尼亚、英国)急诊医学领导层专家,覆盖小、中、大三种医院规模。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为EUSEM发起的欧洲多国两轮Delphi调查,18名来自六国的急诊领导层专家参与,覆盖小、中、大三种医院规模。
- 第一轮为结构化访谈,第二轮对第一轮整合的条目(分为急诊工作系统因素、提供者健康结局、急诊工作生活干预方法)进行相关性评分。
- 在四类急诊工作条件类别上获得近乎一致的共识:积极条件如工作挑战、个人动机、病例复杂性;消极条件如拥挤、工作流程中断/多任务处理、医疗差错。
- 高度相关的个人不良健康事件包括身体疲劳、精疲力竭和职业倦怠。
- 干预实践方面专家提供了广泛的机会但共识较少。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:EUSEM发起的欧洲多国Delphi共识调查(专家意见)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为工作系统条件对欧洲急诊提供者工作生活产生正负效应,改善策略应聚焦各国共有的系统相关外部压力源。
- 作者认为本研究为未来地方和系统层面的干预研究奠定科学基础。
指南或共识出处
- EUSEM发起的欧洲范围共识调查(Eur J Emerg Med)。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND IMPORTANCE: Modern emergency medicine (EM) is a complex, demanding, and occasionally stressful field of work. Working conditions, provider well-being, and associated health and performance outcomes are key factors influencing the establishment of a sustainable emergency department (ED) working environment.
OBJECTIVES: This multinational European Delphi survey aimed to identify unequivocal major factors for good and poor ED working conditions and their possible effects on health care provider well-being.
DESIGN/SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: A total of 18 experts from six European countries (Belgium, Finland, Germany, Italy, Romania, and the UK) covering three different hospital sizes (small, medium, and large) in their respective countries participated in the two-round Delphi survey. All panelists held leadership roles in EM.
OUTCOME MEASURES AND ANALYSIS: The first step involved conducting an extensive literature search on ED working conditions. The second step involved the first Delphi round, which consisted of structured interviews with the panelists. The survey was designed to obtain information concerning important working conditions, comments regarding work-life factors identified from the literature, and ratings of their importance. Interviews were transcribed and analyzed following a standardized protocol. In the second Delphi round, experts rated the relevance of items consolidated from the first Delphi round (classified into ED work system factors, provider health outcomes, and ED work-life intervention approaches).
RESULTS: A nearly unequivocal consensus was obtained in four ED work condition categories, including positive (e.g. job challenges, personal motivation, and case complexities) and negative (e.g. overcrowding, workflow interruptions/multitasking, medical errors) ED work conditions. The highly relevant adverse personal health events identified included physical fatigue, exhaustion, and burnout. Concerning intervention practices, the panelists offered a wide spectrum of opportunities with less consensus.
CONCLUSION: Work system conditions exert positive and negative effects on the work life of ED providers across Europe. Although most European countries have varying health care systems, the expert-based survey results presented herein strongly suggest that improvement strategies should focus on system-related external stressors common in various countries. Our findings lay the scientific groundwork for future intervention studies at the local and systemic levels to improve ED provider work life.
参考来源
- Weigl M, Lifschitz M, Dodt C, et al. Key factors for sustainable working conditions in emergency departments: an EUSEM-initiated, Europe-wide consensus survey. Eur J Emerg Med. 2024. PMID: 39012362. doi:10.1097/MEJ.0000000000001159
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。