探索医疗第一响应者对大规模伤亡事件场景培训的认知:关于学习条件与改进建议的定性研究
本研究采用定性归纳法,于2021年10月至2022年2月对来自四个组织(三个急救医疗服务机构和一支搜救组织)、代表四个欧盟国家的27名医疗第一响应者(17名急救医疗服务人员、10名搜救志愿者)进行半结构访谈,分析其对大规模伤亡事件场景培训的认知。结果识别出两大类别和七个亚类别影响学习效果:在模拟真实事件的背景下培训(包括事故现场风险评估、伤员真实呈现、课程融入场景多样性、跨机构协作、现场管理培训时的角色对齐)和使用教学框架(允许犯错、培训后评估的重要性)。结论重申传统大规模伤亡事件场景培训的价值并指出改进方向,主张采用逼真场景、跨机构协作、改进现场管理技能和彻底的培训后评估,建议转变培训概念与实施方式,并探讨虚拟现实技术作为培训方法补充的潜力,指出需进一步研究确定其长期有效性;培训方法的选择应考虑项目目标、目标人群和资源。
要点
- 27名医疗第一响应者(17名急救医疗服务人员、10名搜救志愿者)参与访谈,来自四个组织、代表四个欧盟国家。
- 影响学习效果的两大类别为:在模拟真实事件的背景下培训、使用教学框架。
- 逼真场景要素包括事故现场风险评估、伤员真实呈现、课程场景多样性、跨机构协作和现场管理角色对齐。
- 教学框架要素包括允许犯错和培训后评估的重要性。
- 作者主张采用逼真场景、跨机构协作、改进现场管理技能和彻底的培训后评估,并建议转变培训概念与实施方式。
适用人群与场景
- 参与大规模伤亡事件场景培训的医疗第一响应者,包括急救医疗服务人员和搜救志愿者;研究纳入17名急救医疗服务人员与10名搜救志愿者,来自四个组织(三个急救医疗服务机构和一个搜救组织),代表四个欧盟国家。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型为定性归纳研究,采用半结构访谈,访谈于2021年10月至2022年2月进行,数据采用定性内容分析。
- 共纳入27名医疗第一响应者(17名急救医疗服务人员、10名搜救志愿者),来自四个组织(三个急救医疗服务机构和一个搜救组织),代表四个欧盟国家。
- 识别出两大类别和七个亚类别影响学习效果:在模拟真实事件的背景下培训(事故现场风险评估、伤员真实呈现、课程融入场景多样性、跨机构协作、现场管理培训时的角色对齐)和使用教学框架(允许犯错、培训后评估的重要性)。
- 结论重申传统大规模伤亡事件场景培训的价值并指出改进方向,主张采用逼真场景、跨机构协作、改进现场管理技能和彻底的培训后评估。
- 建议转变大规模伤亡事件培训的概念与实施方式,并探讨虚拟现实技术作为培训方法补充的潜力,指出需进一步研究确定这些技术的长期有效性。
- 培训方法的选择应考虑项目目标、目标人群和资源。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:定性研究(半结构访谈+定性内容分析);原文未报告证据等级或推荐强度。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,大规模伤亡事件场景培训应纳入逼真场景、跨机构协作、改进现场管理技能和彻底的培训后评估。
- 作者建议转变大规模伤亡事件培训的概念与实施方式。
- 作者认为虚拟现实技术可作为培训方法的补充,但需进一步研究确定其长期有效性。
- 作者认为培训方法的选择应考虑项目目标、目标人群和资源。
- 原文未据此给出其他推荐。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Despite participating in scenario training, many medical first responders (MFRs) perceive themselves as inadequately prepared to respond to mass casualty incidents (MCIs). The objective of this study was to conduct a comprehensive examination of traditional MCI scenario training methods, focusing on their inherent strengths and limitations. An investigation into the perceptions of MFRs who had participated in MCI scenario training was carried out to identify potential areas for improvement and provide recommendations for refining MCI training protocols.
DESIGN: Qualitative inductive approach using semistructured interviews that took place between October 2021 and February 2022. Data were analysed with qualitative content analysis.
SETTING: MCI scenario training involving four organisations (three emergency medical services and one search-and-rescue organisation) tasked with responding to MCIs, collectively representing four European Union countries.
PARTICIPANTS: 27 MFRs (17 emergency medical services personnel and 10 search-and-rescue volunteers) were recruited to participate in the study.
RESULTS: Two categories and seven associated subcategories (shown in parentheses) were identified as influencing the learning outcomes for MFRs: Training in a context mirroring real-world incidents (conducting incident scene risk assessment, realistic representation in casualties, incorporating scenario variety into the curriculum, interagency collaboration, role alignment when training incident site management) and use of a pedagogical framework (allowing for mistakes, the importance of post-training evaluation).
CONCLUSIONS: This study reaffirms the value of traditional MCI scenario training and identifies areas for enhancement, advocating for realistic scenarios, interagency collaboration, improved incident site management skills and thorough post-training evaluation. It suggests a shift in MCI training conceptualisation and delivery. The potential of virtual reality technologies as a valuable addition to training methods is explored, with a note on the need for further research to ascertain the long-term effectiveness of these technologies. However, the selection of a training method should consider programme goals, target population and resources.
参考来源
- Schulz F, Nguyen Q, Baetzner A, et al. Exploring medical first responders' perceptions of mass casualty incident scenario training: a qualitative study on learning conditions and recommendations for improvement. BMJ Open. 2024. PMID: 38991686. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2024-084925
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。