ICU家庭会议中临床医生对选择框架的使用
该研究对来自前瞻性多中心队列研究的101份录音转录会议进行二次序贯内容分析,识别出202个偏好敏感决策片段,涉及机械通气(20.3%)、总体照护目标(19.3%)、肾脏替代治疗(14.4%)、出院后照护(14.4%)等。临床医生使用默认框架的比例最高(127/202,62.9%),其次为是非问句(43/202,21.3%),且更常同时呈现潜在损失与获益。作者认为默认框架和是非问句均为强助推,未来应设计干预促进这些及其他常用选择框架的知情使用。
要点
- 202个偏好敏感决策片段中,默认框架使用127次(62.9%),为最常用选择框架。
- 是非问句(接受或拒绝特定照护选择)用于43个决策片段(21.3%)。
- 临床医生更常同时呈现潜在损失与获益,而非单独呈现其一。
- 讨论主题中机械通气占20.3%、总体照护目标19.3%、肾脏替代治疗14.4%、出院后照护14.4%。
- 作者认为默认框架和是非问句是强助推,未来应设计干预促进其知情使用。
适用人群与场景
- 来自前瞻性多中心队列研究的101份代理决策者与临床医生之间的录音转录会议,涉及无决策能力的危重成人。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 偏好敏感决策片段由四名编码者识别,主题包括机械通气、肾脏替代治疗和总体照护目标等,具体主题基于先前重症监护文献确定。
- 选择框架类型基于决策科学文献预先选定。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究设计为二次序贯内容分析,共分析101份录音转录会议,识别出202个决策片段。
- 决策片段主题分布:机械通气20.3%、总体照护目标19.3%、肾脏替代治疗14.4%、出院后照护(如专业护理机构等出院地点)14.4%、其余其他主题32.1%。
- 默认框架(若另一选项未被主动选择则将执行的选项)使用127次,占决策片段的62.9%,高于任何其他选择框架。
- 是非问句(接受或拒绝特定照护选择的「是或否问题」)用于43个决策片段(21.3%)。
- 临床医生更常同时呈现强调潜在损失和获益的选项,而非单独呈现损失或获益。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:二次序贯内容分析。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,临床医生在与代理决策者讨论偏好敏感选择时频繁使用默认框架和是非问句,二者均为强助推;未来工作应聚焦于设计干预,促进对这些及执业临床医生最常用的其他选择框架的知情使用。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To quantify the frequency and patterns of clinicians' use of choice frames when discussing preference-sensitive care with surrogate decision-makers in the ICU.
DESIGN: Secondary sequential content analysis.
SETTING: One hundred one audio-recorded and transcribed conferences between surrogates and clinicians of incapacitated, critically ill adults from a prospective, multicenter cohort study.
SUBJECTS: Surrogate decision-makers and clinicians.
INTERVENTIONS: None.
MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Four coders identified preference-sensitive decision episodes addressed in the meetings, including topics such as mechanical ventilation, renal replacement, and overall goals of care. Prior critical care literature provided specific topics identified as preference-sensitive specific to the critical care context. Coders then examined each decision episode for the types of choice frames used by clinicians. The choice frames were selected a priori based on decision science literature. In total, there were 202 decision episodes across the 101 transcripts, with 20.3% of the decision episodes discussing mechanical ventilation, 19.3% overall goals of care, 14.4% renal replacement therapy, 14.4% post-discharge care (i.e., discharge location such as a skilled nursing facility), and the remaining 32.1% other topics. Clinicians used default framing, in which an option is presented that will be carried out if another option is not actively chosen, more frequently than any other choice frame (127 or 62.9% of decision episodes). Clinicians presented a polar interrogative, or a "yes or no question" to accept or reject a specific care choice, in 43 (21.3%) decision episodes. Clinicians more frequently presented options emphasizing both potential losses and gains rather than either in isolation.
CONCLUSIONS: Clinicians frequently use default framing and polar questions when discussing preference-sensitive choices with surrogate decision-makers, which are known to be powerful nudges. Future work should focus on designing interventions promoting the informed use of these and the other most common choice frames used by practicing clinicians.
参考来源
- Hart JL, Malik L, Li C, et al. Clinicians' Use of Choice Framing in ICU Family Meetings. Crit Care Med. 2024. PMID: 38912880. doi:10.1097/CCM.0000000000006360
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。