围存活期伦理与实践:FIGO 建议
FIGO 发布围存活期伦理与实践建议,指出无法设定一个任意的存活孕周界限,临床应关注围存活期这一预后不确定的灰色区间。该区间内干预的获益与伤害平衡不确定,胎儿或新生儿无法行使自主权,医师与父母作为代理人;父母与医师意见不一致时应避免家长式态度,医师只提供而非推荐围产期干预,在医学可行且适当范围内尊重父母基于充分信息的选择。建议新生儿复苏决策应在出生前做出,不以出生时新生儿外观为条件,并确保出生前后一致;咨询应减少信息碎片化、以积极框架呈现预后、避免过度依赖统计数字。文章指出不同医师、中心和国家做法不同,无法提供全球共识,但合乎伦理的优质照护包括产科与新生儿团队早期参与,以形成一致、可理解、非家长式且平衡的照护计划。
要点
- 不能设定任意的存活孕周界限,临床应聚焦围存活期这一预后不确定的灰色区间。
- 医师与父母意见不一致时,应避免家长式态度,医师只提供而不推荐围产期干预。
- 建议新生儿复苏决策在出生前做出,不以出生时新生儿外观为条件,并确保出生前后一致。
- 咨询应减少信息碎片化或不一致,预后最好以积极框架呈现,避免过度依赖统计数字。
- 伦理委员会可提供咨询并在讨论中充当调解者,但不具有决策优先权。
适用人群与场景
- 处于围存活期(预后不确定的灰色区间)的胎儿与新生儿及其父母
- 参与围存活期决策的产科与新生儿团队
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 不能设定任意的存活孕周界限,应以围存活期这一预后不确定的灰色区间为焦点
处置流程与药物剂量
- 父母与医师意见不一致时,进行不带家长式态度的对话,医师只提供而不推荐围产期干预。
- 在医学可行且适当的范围内,尊重父母基于充分信息的选择。
- 专业指南可作为讨论框架和起点,但指南很少划定明确界线,许多情况下措辞模糊。
- 伦理委员会可提供咨询并在讨论中充当调解者,但不具有决策优先权。
- 咨询应考虑胎儿和母亲的具体特征以及父母的价值观,减少信息碎片化或不一致,预后最好以积极框架呈现,避免过度依赖统计数字。
- 建议围存活期新生儿复苏决策在出生前做出,不以出生时新生儿外观为条件;无论决策如何,确保出生前后一致。
- 产科与新生儿团队早期参与,以形成一致、可理解、非家长式且平衡的照护计划。
- 医师需将期望调整至当地标准、当地结局数据和当地新生儿支持可及性。
研究设计与关键结果
- FIGO 发布围存活期伦理与实践建议,指出无法设定任意的存活孕周界限,临床应关注围存活期这一预后不确定的灰色区间。
- 该区间内干预是否带来临床获益大于伤害存在相当大的不确定性,胎儿或新生儿无法行使自主权,医师和父母作为患者代理人。
- 不同医师、中心和国家对围存活期启动或放弃重症监护的决策方式不同,无法提供全球共识观点,也不存在统一的伦理、道德或实践策略。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:指南(FIGO 建议)
- 局限:原文未报告局限性
对床旁实践的改变
- 围存活期决策应让产科与新生儿团队早期共同参与,形成一致、可理解、非家长式且平衡的照护计划。
- 医师只提供而不推荐围产期干预,在医学可行且适当范围内尊重父母基于充分信息的选择。
- 新生儿复苏决策应在出生前做出,不以出生时新生儿外观为条件,并确保出生前后一致。
- 咨询中减少信息碎片化或不一致,预后最好以积极框架呈现,避免过度依赖统计数字。
- 医师需将期望调整至当地标准、当地结局数据和当地新生儿支持可及性。
指南或共识出处
- FIGO 建议:The ethics and practice of perinatal care at the limit of viability: FIGO recommendations(发表于 Int J Gynaecol Obstet)
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
An arbitrary gestational age limit of viability cannot be set, and in clinical practice the focus should be on a periviability interval-the so-called "gray zone" of prognostic uncertainty. For cases within this interval, the most appropriate decision-making process remains debatable and periviability has emerged as one of the greatest challenges in bioethics. Universally recognized ethical principles may be interpreted differently due to socioeconomic, cultural, and religious aspects. In the case of periviability, there is considerable uncertainty over whether interventions result in a greater balance of clinical good over harm. Furthermore, the fetus or neonate is unable to exercise autonomy and the physicians and parents will act as patient surrogates. When parents and physicians disagree about the infant's best interest, a dialogue without paternalistic attitudes is essential, whereby physicians should only offer, but not recommend, perinatal interventions. Parental choice, based on thorough information, should be respected within the limits of what is medically feasible and appropriate. When disagreements between parents and physicians occur, how is consensus to be achieved? Professional guidelines can be helpful as a framework and starting point for discussion. In reality, however, guidelines only rarely draw categorical lines and in many cases remain vague and ambiguously worded. Local ethics committees can provide counseling and function as moderators during discussions, but ethics committees do not have decision precedence. Counseling assumes the most significant role in periviability discussions, taking into consideration the particular fetal and maternal characteristics, as well as parental values. Several caveats should be observed relative to counseling: message fragmentation or inconsistence should be minimized, prognosis should preferably be presented in a positive framing, and overreliance on statistics should be avoided. It is recommended that decisions regarding neonatal resuscitation in the periviability interval be made before birth and not conditional on the newborn's appearance at birth. Regardless of decision, it is important to assure pre- and postnatal coherence. The present article describes how individual physicians, centers, and countries differ in the approach to the decision to initiate or forgo intensive care in the periviability interval. It is impossible to provide a global consensus view and there can be no unifying ethical, moral, or practical strategy. Nevertheless, ethically justified, quality care comprises early involvement of the obstetric and neonatal team to enable a coherent, comprehensible, nonpaternalistic, and balanced plan of care. Ultimately, physicians will need to adjust the expectations to the local standards, local outcome data, and local neonatal support availability.
参考来源
- Vidaeff AC, Capito L, Gupte S, et al. The ethics and practice of perinatal care at the limit of viability: FIGO recommendations. Int J Gynaecol Obstet. 2024. PMID: 38944691. doi:10.1002/ijgo.15744
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。