幕后:COVID-19大流行期间制定州级稀缺资源分配计划的促进因素与障碍
该研究通过2022年2月至9月对计划作者和州领导进行的半结构化访谈,按扎根理论原则定性分析COVID-19大流行期间州级稀缺重症监护资源分配计划的制定与采纳过程。34个州36名参与者中,2020年前已有计划的24州里17州因COVID-19修订并采纳,6州全新制定,其余州未能制定或采纳;13州因残疾或年龄偏见投诉或需求演变继续修订。成功制定与采纳的促进因素包括州卫生部门协调或支持及与关键社区伙伴的既有关系,障碍包括缺乏采纳计划的政治意愿和在公共卫生紧急状态下制定。作者认为各州应通过社区参与制定或修订计划,并考虑维持具有多元成员和内容专长的常设委员会定期复审计划。
要点
- 2020年前已有稀缺资源分配计划的24个州中,17个州因COVID-19修订并采纳计划,6个州全新制定,其余州未能制定或采纳。
- 13个州因残疾或年龄偏见投诉或为回应演变需求而继续修订计划。
- 成功制定与采纳的促进因素包括州卫生部门协调或支持,以及与老龄和残疾权利团体、少数化社区等关键社区伙伴的既有关系。
- 障碍包括缺乏采纳计划的政治意愿以及在公共卫生紧急状态下制定计划。
- 作者认为各州应通过社区参与制定或修订计划,并考虑维持具有多元成员和内容专长的常设委员会定期复审计划并向州官员提供大流行防范建议。
适用人群与场景
- 2022年2月至9月完成半结构化访谈的36名计划作者和州领导,来自美国34个州,分布覆盖所有美国区域。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究设计为半结构化访谈的定性分析,按扎根理论原则分析计划制定与采纳相关主题;36名参与者来自34个州,覆盖所有美国区域。
- 2020年前已有计划的24个州中,17个州因COVID-19修订并采纳计划,6个州全新制定计划,其余州未能制定或采纳计划。
- 13个州因残疾或年龄偏见投诉或为回应演变需求而继续修订计划。
- 许多参与者表示大流行早期的紧迫性阻碍了理想的制定过程。
- 成功制定和采纳计划的促进因素包括州卫生部门的协调或支持,以及与老龄和残疾权利团体、少数化社区等关键社区伙伴的既有关系。
- 障碍包括缺乏采纳计划的政治意愿以及在公共卫生紧急状态下制定计划。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:定性研究(半结构化访谈,扎根理论分析)。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,为避免重复COVID-19应对早期的错误,各州应通过社区参与制定或修订计划。
- 作者认为,各州可考虑维持具有多元成员和内容专长的常设委员会,定期复审计划并就大流行防范向州官员提供建议。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: In response to COVID-19, many states revised, developed, or attempted to develop plans to allocate scarce critical care resources in the event that crisis standards of care were triggered. To our knowledge, no prior analysis has assessed this plan development process, including whether plans were successfully adopted.
RESEARCH QUESTION: How did states develop or revise scarce resource allocation plans during the COVID-19 pandemic, and what were the barriers and facilitators to their development and adoption at the state level?
STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Plan authors and state leaders completed a semistructured interview February to September 2022. Interview transcripts were qualitatively analyzed for themes related to plan development and adoption according to the principles of grounded theory.
RESULTS: Thirty-six participants from 34 states completed an interview, from states distributed across all US regions. Among participants' states with plans that existed prior to 2020 (n = 24), 17 were revised and adopted in response to COVID-19. Six states wrote a plan de novo, with the remaining states failing to develop or adopt a plan. Thirteen states continued to revise their plans in response to disability or aging bias complaints or to respond to evolving needs. Many participants expressed that urgency in the early days of the pandemic prevented an ideal development process. Facilitators of successful plan development and adoption include: coordination or support from the state department of health and existing relationships with key community partners, including aging and disability rights groups and minoritized communities. Barriers include: lack of perceived political will to adopt a plan and development during a public health emergency.
INTERPRETATION: To avoid repeating mistakes from the early days of the COVID-19 response, states should develop or revise plans with community engagement and consider maintaining a standing committee with diverse membership and content expertise to periodically review plans and advise state officials on pandemic preparedness.
参考来源
- Riggan KA, Nguyen NV, Ennis JS, et al. Behind the Scenes: Facilitators and Barriers to Developing State Scarce Resource Allocation Plans for the COVID-19 Pandemic. Chest. 2024. PMID: 38710464. doi:10.1016/j.chest.2024.04.006
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。