英格兰创伤网络院前分诊决策的准确性——病例队列研究
本研究为诊断性病例队列研究,于2019年11月至2020年2月在英格兰4个区域创伤网络进行,纳入连续急性损伤患者及所有参考标准阳性病例,与英格兰国家严重创伤数据库匹配。指数检验为院前提供者分诊决策(阳性定义为转运时向严重创伤中心发出预警告电话),主要参考标准为需加速严重创伤中心救治的严重损伤共识定义。完全病例队列样本共2757例,其中主要参考标准阳性959例;主要参考标准定义的严重创伤患病率为3.1%(54/1722,95%CI 2.3-4.0)。实际院前分诊决策总体敏感性46.7%(446/959,95%CI 43.5-49.9),特异性94.5%(1703/1798,95%CI 93.4-95.6);从年轻到老年组,敏感性下降、特异性升高的趋势明显。院前分诊决策常与理论分诊工具结果不同,救护服务临床医生判断导致更高特异性。
要点
- 在英格兰4个区域创伤网络中,院前分诊决策对严重创伤的敏感性为46.7%(446/959,95%CI 43.5-49.9),特异性为94.5%(1703/1798,95%CI 93.4-95.6)。
- 主要参考标准定义的严重创伤患病率为3.1%(54/1722,95%CI 2.3-4.0)。
- 从年轻到老年组,院前分诊敏感性下降、特异性升高,趋势明显。
- 院前分诊决策常与理论分诊工具结果不同,救护服务临床医生判断导致更高特异性。
- 研究结论认为,高特异性、低敏感性与既往经济学评价中成本有效分诊的目标一致。
适用人群与场景
- 2019年11月至2020年2月在英格兰4个区域创伤网络就诊于参与救护服务的连续急性损伤患者,并与英格兰国家严重创伤数据库匹配。
- 纳入所有参考标准阳性病例;完全病例队列样本共2757例,其中主要参考标准阳性959例。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 主要参考标准:需加速严重创伤中心救治的严重损伤共识定义。
- 指数检验阳性:患者转运时向严重创伤中心发出预警告电话。
研究设计与关键结果
- 诊断性病例队列研究,于2019年11月至2020年2月在英格兰4个区域创伤网络进行,完全病例队列样本2757例,其中主要参考标准阳性959例。
- 主要参考标准定义的严重创伤患病率为3.1%(n=54/1722,95%CI 2.3-4.0)。
- 实际院前提供者分诊决策对主要参考标准的敏感性为46.7%(n=446/959,95%CI 43.5-49.9),特异性为94.5%(n=1703/1798,95%CI 93.4-95.6)。
- 从年轻到老年组,敏感性下降、特异性升高的趋势明显。
- 院前提供者分诊决策常与理论分诊工具结果不同,救护服务临床医生判断导致更高特异性。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:诊断性病例队列研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 研究结论认为,英格兰创伤网络中的院前分诊决策表现为高特异性、低敏感性,与既往经济学评价中成本有效分诊的目标一致。
- 研究结论指出,实际分诊决策与理论分诊工具结果不同,且从年轻到老年敏感性下降、特异性升高。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Care for injured patients in England is provided by inclusive regional trauma networks. Ambulance services use triage tools to identify patients with major trauma who would benefit from expedited Major Trauma Centre (MTC) care. However, there has been no investigation of triage performance, despite its role in ensuring effective and efficient MTC care. This study aimed to investigate the accuracy of prehospital major trauma triage in representative English trauma networks.
METHODS: A diagnostic case-cohort study was performed between November 2019 and February 2020 in 4 English regional trauma networks as part of the Major Trauma Triage Study (MATTS). Consecutive patients with acute injury presenting to participating ambulance services were included, together with all reference standard positive cases, and matched to data from the English national major trauma database. The index test was prehospital provider triage decision making, with a positive result defined as patient transport with a pre-alert call to the MTC. The primary reference standard was a consensus definition of serious injury that would benefit from expedited major trauma centre care. Secondary analyses explored different reference standards and compared theoretical triage tool accuracy to real-life triage decisions.
RESULTS: The complete-case case-cohort sample consisted of 2,757 patients, including 959 primary reference standard positive patients. The prevalence of major trauma meeting the primary reference standard definition was 3.1% (n=54/1,722, 95% CI 2.3 - 4.0). Observed prehospital provider triage decisions demonstrated overall sensitivity of 46.7% (n=446/959, 95% CI 43.5-49.9) and specificity of 94.5% (n=1,703/1,798, 95% CI 93.4-95.6) for the primary reference standard. There was a clear trend of decreasing sensitivity and increasing specificity from younger to older age groups. Prehospital provider triage decisions commonly differed from the theoretical triage tool result, with ambulance service clinician judgement resulting in higher specificity.
CONCLUSIONS: Prehospital decision making for injured patients in English trauma networks demonstrated high specificity and low sensitivity, consistent with the targets for cost-effective triage defined in previous economic evaluations. Actual triage decisions differed from theoretical triage tool results, with a decreasing sensitivity and increasing specificity from younger to older ages.
参考来源
- Fuller G, Baird J, Keating S, et al. The accuracy of prehospital triage decisions in English trauma networks - a case-cohort study. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med. 2024. PMID: 38773613. doi:10.1186/s13049-024-01219-9
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。