指南与共识重症综合管理与镇静镇痛

指南专家组的多元化遴选方法——更新版成人重症超声指南所采用的流程

An Approach to Diversifying the Selection of a Guideline Panel-The Process Utilized for the Updated Adult Critical Care Ultrasound Guidelines.
指南 / 共识 · Crit Care Med · 2024-04-08
一句话结论通过透明且有意设计的遴选流程,更新版成人重症超声指南专家组由来自6个国家的33名成员组成,其中女性占45%,历史上被排斥的人群和群体占79%。

本文介绍更新版成人重症超声指南专家组组建的流程评价。方法包括明确专业能力定义、向重症医学会会员开放申请、指南领导层补充提名、候选人自愿披露预设多元化标准、对申请进行含多元化标准的独立评审,最终每位评审者对每位候选人给出总分并经公开论坛讨论达成共识。最终专家组由来自6个国家的33名成员组成,女性占45%,历史上被排斥的人群和群体占79%,涵盖非医师专业人员和患者权益倡导者,医疗专业人员覆盖早期、中期和晚期职业阶段。作者希望该做法能作为起点,推动学科更加包容和多元,制定具有全球代表性的指南。

要点

  • 更新版成人重症超声指南专家组共33名成员,来自6个国家,女性占45%,历史上被排斥的人群和群体占79%。
  • 遴选流程包括明确专业能力定义、向重症医学会会员开放申请、指南领导层补充提名、候选人自愿披露预设多元化标准,以及含多元化标准的独立评审。
  • 每位评审者对每位候选人给出总分,并经公开论坛讨论和最终共识确定人选。
  • 专家组包含非医师专业人员和患者权益倡导者,医疗专业人员覆盖早期、中期和晚期职业阶段。
  • 作者认为透明且有意的遴选方法使专家组在性别均衡及民族、种族和职业方面的多样性得到改善。

适用人群与场景

  • 创建更新版成人重症超声指南专家组的场景。

诊断标准与关键阈值

  • 预设多元化标准由潜在候选人自愿披露,纳入申请独立评审。
  • 每位评审者对每位候选人给出总分,经公开论坛讨论和最终共识确定人选。

处置流程与药物剂量

  • 第一步:明确专业能力定义。
  • 第二步:向重症医学会会员开放申请。
  • 第三步:指南领导层补充提名。
  • 第四步:候选人自愿披露预设多元化标准。
  • 第五步:对申请进行含多元化标准的独立评审。
  • 第六步:经公开论坛讨论和最终共识确定专家组人选。

研究设计与关键结果

  • 流程评价旨在了解实施透明且有意设计的指南专家组遴选方法是否能产生多元化的专家指南专家组。
  • 最终指南专家组由来自6个国家的33名成员组成:女性占45%,历史上被排斥的人群和群体占79%。
  • 专家组包含非医师专业人员和患者权益倡导者;医疗专业人员覆盖早期、中期和晚期职业阶段。

证据类型、等级与局限

  • 证据类型:流程评价。
  • 局限:原文未报告局限性。

对床旁实践的改变

  • 作者认为,透明且有意的遴选方法使专家组在性别均衡及民族、种族和职业方面的多样性得到改善,希望该做法能作为起点,推动学科更加包容和多元、制定具有全球代表性的指南。

指南或共识出处

  • 更新版成人重症超声指南(Adult Critical Care Ultrasound Guidelines)。

提炼说明

  • 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「红旗征与不能漏的情况」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: Clinical practice guidelines are essential for promoting evidence-based healthcare. While diversification of panel members can reduce disparities in care, processes for panel selection lack transparency. We aim to share our approach in forming a diverse expert panel for the updated Adult Critical Care Ultrasound Guidelines.

DESIGN: This process evaluation aims to understand whether the implementation of a transparent and intentional approach to guideline panel selection would result in the creation of a diverse expert guideline panel.

SETTING: This study was conducted in the setting of creating a guideline panel for the updated Adult Critical Care Ultrasound Guidelines.

PATIENTS: Understanding that family/patient advocacy in guideline creations can promote the impact of a clinical practice guideline, patient representation on the expert panel was prioritized.

INTERVENTIONS: Interventions included creation of a clear definition of expertise, an open invitation to the Society of Critical Care Medicine membership to apply for the panel, additional panel nomination by guideline leadership, voluntary disclosure of pre-identified diversity criteria by potential candidates, and independent review of applications including diversity criteria. This resulted in an overall score per candidate per reviewer and an open forum for discussion and final consensus.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: The variables of diversity were collected and analyzed after panel selection. These were compared with historical data on panel composition. The final guideline panel comprised of 33 panelists from six countries: 45% women and 79% historically excluded people and groups. The panel has representation from nonphysician professionals and patients advocates. Of the healthcare professionals, there is representation from early, mid, and late career stages.

CONCLUSIONS: Our intentional and transparent approach resulted in a panel with improved gender parity and robust diversity along ethnic, racial, and professional lines. We hope it can serve as a starting point as we strive to become a more inclusive and diverse discipline that creates globally representative guidelines.

来源:Crit Care Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

参考来源

  1. Nikravan S, Lanspa MJ, Ablordeppey E, et al. An Approach to Diversifying the Selection of a Guideline Panel-The Process Utilized for the Updated Adult Critical Care Ultrasound Guidelines. Crit Care Med. 2024. PMID: 38587423. doi:10.1097/CCM.0000000000006290

供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。