向极早产儿父母传达预后时乐观与悲观信息框架的比较:COPE随机临床试验
这项在德国单中心进行的交叉随机临床试验纳入220名出生体重低于1500g的存活早产儿父母,通过视频 vignette 比较乐观框架(生存概率和无损害概率)与悲观框架(死亡风险和损害生存风险)对父母偏好、状态焦虑和数字回忆的影响。结果显示89.1%的父母偏好乐观框架(偏好比值11.0,95%CI 6.28-19.10,P<.001),乐观框架下对生存数字的回忆更准确(OR 4.00,95%CI 1.64-9.79,P=.002),但对损害数字的回忆无显著差异(OR 1.50,95%CI 0.85-2.63,P=.16)。状态焦虑在两组基线相似,观看第一个视频后均等升高,第二个视频后乐观框架在后时焦虑下降而悲观框架在后时不变。作者认为乐观框架可能更受偏好,并可能使生存预期更现实,但对损害预期无此效果。
要点
- 在220名极早产儿父母中,196名(89.1%)偏好乐观框架,24名(10.1%)偏好悲观框架(偏好比值11.0,95%CI 6.28-19.10,P<.001)。
- 乐观框架下父母对生存数字估计的回忆更准确(OR 4.00,95%CI 1.64-9.79,P=.002),对损害数字的回忆无显著差异(OR 1.50,95%CI 0.85-2.63,P=.16)。
- 状态焦虑在两组基线相似(均数差-0.34,95%CI -1.18至0.49,P=.42),观看第一个视频后均等升高(均数差-0.55,95%CI -1.79至0.69,P=.39)。
- 第二个视频后,乐观框架在后时焦虑下降,悲观框架在后时焦虑不变(均数差2.15,95%CI 0.91至3.39,P<.001)。
- 作者认为,向极早产儿父母传达严重并发症预后时,乐观框架可能更受偏好,并可能使生存预期更现实,但对损害预期无此效果。
适用人群与场景
- 德国单中心大学医学中心新生儿重症监护室中,出生体重低于1500g的存活早产儿的父母。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:交叉随机临床试验,单中心,2021年6月至10月纳入220名父母(142名母亲,64.5%;母亲平均年龄39.1岁,SD 5.6;父亲平均年龄42.7岁,SD 6.9)。
- 干预:交替观看2段脚本化视频 vignette,展示新生儿科医生与父母关于假设的极早产儿伴严重脑室内出血预后的标准化对话,视频将相同数字结果分别框架为乐观(生存概率和无损害概率)或悲观(死亡风险和损害生存风险)。
- 主要终点:196名(89.1%)偏好乐观框架,24名(10.1%)偏好悲观框架(偏好比值11.0,95%CI 6.28-19.10,P<.001)。
- 偏好乐观框架在第二个呈现时比第一个呈现时更明显(偏好比值5.41,95%CI 1.77-16.48,P=.003)。
- 状态焦虑:基线两组相似(均数差-0.34,95%CI -1.18至0.49,P=.42);第一个视频后均等升高(均数差-0.55,95%CI -1.79至0.69,P=.39);第二个视频后,乐观框架在后时焦虑下降,悲观框架在后时焦虑不变(均数差2.15,95%CI 0.91至3.39,P<.001)。
- 数字回忆:乐观框架下对生存数字回忆更准确(OR 4.00,95%CI 1.64-9.79,P=.002),对损害数字回忆无显著差异(OR 1.50,95%CI 0.85-2.63,P=.16)。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:交叉随机临床试验。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,向极早产儿父母传达严重并发症预后时,乐观框架可能更受偏好,并可能使生存预期更现实,但对损害预期无此效果。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「诊断标准与关键阈值」「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: In the neonatal intensive care unit, there is a lack of understanding about how best to communicate the prognosis of a serious complication to parents.
OBJECTIVE: To examine parental preferences and the effects of optimistic vs pessimistic message framing when providing prognostic information about a serious complication.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This crossover randomized clinical trial was conducted at a single German university medical center between June and October 2021. Eligible participants were parents of surviving preterm infants with a birth weight under 1500 g. Data were analyzed between October 2021 and August 2022.
INTERVENTIONS: Alternating exposure to 2 scripted video vignettes showing a standardized conversation between a neonatologist and parents, portrayed by professional actors, about the prognosis of a hypothetical very preterm infant with severe intraventricular hemorrhage. The video vignettes differed in the framing of identical numerical outcome estimates as either probability of survival and probability of nonimpairment (optimistic framing) or a risk of death and impaired survival (pessimistic framing).
MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: The primary outcome was preference odds (ratio of preference for optimistic vs pessimistic framing). Secondary outcomes included state anxiety, perceptions of communication, and recall of numerical estimates.
RESULTS: Of 220 enrolled parents (142 [64.5%] mothers; mean [SD] age: mothers, 39.1 [5.6] years; fathers, 42.7 [6.9] years), 196 (89.1%) preferred optimistic and 24 (10.1%) preferred pessimistic framing (preference odds, 11.0; 95% CI, 6.28-19.10; P < .001). Preference for optimistic framing was more pronounced when presented second than when presented first (preference odds, 5.41; 95% CI, 1.77-16.48; P = .003). State anxiety scores were similar in both groups at baseline (mean difference, -0.34; -1.18 to 0.49; P = .42) and increased equally after the first video (mean difference, -0.55; 95% CI, -1.79 to 0.69; P = .39). After the second video, state anxiety scores decreased when optimistic framing followed pessimistic framing but remained unchanged when pessimistic framing followed optimistic framing (mean difference, 2.15; 95% CI, 0.91 to 3.39; P < .001). With optimistic framing, participants recalled numerical estimates more accurately for survival (odds ratio, 4.00; 95% CI, 1.64-9.79; P = .002) but not for impairment (odds ratio, 1.50; 95% CI, 0.85-2.63; P = .16).
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: When given prognostic information about a serious complication, parents of very preterm infants may prefer optimistic framing. Optimistic framing may lead to more realistic expectations for survival, but not for impairment.
TRIAL REGISTRATION: German Clinical Trials Register (DRKS): DRKS00024466.
参考来源
- Forth FA, Hammerle F, König J, et al. Optimistic vs Pessimistic Message Framing in Communicating Prognosis to Parents of Very Preterm Infants: The COPE Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Netw Open. 2024. PMID: 38393728. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.0105
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。