基于传统出行时间与实际感知出行时间的美沙酮/阿片类治疗项目可及性比较
这项横断面研究整合高分辨率公交时刻表和阿片类治疗项目(OTP)营业时间,构建「实际感知可及性」指标,并与传统可及性指标比较。研究以康涅狄格州2019年1018例阿片类药物过量死亡者的居住地址作为阿片类药物使用障碍(OUD)患者治疗需求的代理。结果:1018人中264人(26%)无法在180分钟内到达OTP;能到达者单程平均出行时间45.6分钟,约70%花费在车外出行环节。传统可及性评分中位数为5.0(范围0.0-17.0),实际感知可及性评分中位数为1.0(范围0.0-10.0),后者提示传统指标低估出行负担及可及性不公平。作者认为,决策者应采用实际感知可及性指标,并建议通过开设新OTP站点或延长现有站点营业时间来减轻出行负担。
要点
- 在1018例阿片类药物过量死亡者中,264人(26%)无法在180分钟内通过公共交通到达阿片类治疗项目(OTP)。
- 能到达OTP者单程平均出行时间为45.6分钟,其中约70%的出行时间花在车外环节(如步行和等待)。
- 传统可及性评分(120分钟公交出行时间内的OTP数量)中位数为5.0(范围0.0-17.0),实际感知可及性评分中位数为1.0(范围0.0-10.0)。
- 传统可及性指标低估了个人到OTP的出行负担以及可及性的不公平程度,与「实际感知可及性」指标相比存在差异。
- 出行时间和可及性随出发时间不同存在相当大的时间变化。
适用人群与场景
- 以康涅狄格州2019年1018例阿片类药物过量死亡者的居住地址作为阿片类药物使用障碍(OUD)患者治疗需求的代理。
- 研究分析使用公共交通前往阿片类治疗项目(OTP)的出行负担。
诊断标准与关键阈值
- 传统可及性评分:120分钟公交出行时间内可到达的OTP数量。
- 实际感知可及性评分:120分钟公交出行时间内可到达的OTP数量,并按车内外出行环节加权。
- 无法在180分钟内到达OTP的定义:样本中264人(26%)无法在180分钟内到达OTP。
研究设计与关键结果
- 研究类型:横断面研究,整合高分辨率公交时刻表和OTP营业时间,使用基尼指数和空间回归模型分析可及性不公平;数据分析时间为2023年5月至8月。
- 样本:1018例2019年康涅狄格州阿片类药物过量死亡者;死亡时平均(SD)年龄43.7(12.6)岁;784人(77%)为男性;111人(11%)为非裔美国人,889人(87%)为白人,其他种族和族裔类别18人(2%)。
- 主要结果:264人(26%)无法在180分钟内到达OTP;能到达者单程平均出行时间45.6分钟,约70%的出行时间花在车外环节。
- 传统可及性评分中位数(范围)为5.0(0.0-17.0);实际感知可及性评分中位数(范围)为1.0(0.0-10.0)。
- 传统可及性指标低估了个人到OTP的出行负担以及可及性的不公平程度,与「实际感知可及性」指标相比存在差异。
- 出行时间和可及性随出发时间不同存在相当大的时间变化。
证据类型、等级与局限
- 证据类型:横断面研究。
- 局限:原文未报告局限性。
对床旁实践的改变
- 作者认为,基于传统可及性指标得出的政策建议可能产生误导,决策者应使用能充分反映个人出行负担的实际感知可及性指标。
- 作者认为,在OTP可及性方面,开设新OTP站点以解决因距离服务点造成的可及性缺口,或延长现有站点的营业时间,可能减轻个人的出行负担。
提炼说明
- 本条依据论文摘要整理;摘要未涉及「处置流程与药物剂量」「红旗征与不能漏的情况」「指南或共识出处」,故未列出这些栏目;全文请点「阅读原文」。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
IMPORTANCE: Transportation barriers have long been associated with poorer health outcomes; this burden is especially acute for individuals with opioid use disorder (OUD), a chronic disease often associated with low socioeconomic status. Conventional travel time analyses may not fully account for experiential components of travel, thereby understating the true travel burden and overstating treatment accessibility to opioid treatment programs (OTPs).
OBJECTIVE: To develop a metric of feels-like accessibility for those using public transit to access OTPs that accounts for the realistic travel burden on individuals with OUD.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This cross-sectional study integrated high-resolution transit schedules and operating hours of OTPs to measure feels-like accessibility. Feels-like accessibility considers the differential outcomes of out-of-vehicle travel components and more realistically reflects individuals' transportation burden than conventional accessibility measures. Gini indices and spatial regression models were used to investigate inequities in accessibility. Geocoded data for residential addresses of 1018 overdose fatalities in Connecticut in 2019 were used as a proxy for the treatment needs of individuals with OUD. Data were analyzed between May and August 2023.
MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Conventional and feels-like accessibility scores.
EXPOSURES: Fluctuations in public transit frequencies over the course of the day and the limited operating hours of the OTPs.
RESULTS: Of the 1018 individuals in the study, the mean (SD) age at death was 43.7 (12.6) years, 784 individuals (77%) were men, 111 (11%) were African American, and 889 (87%) were White, with other racial and ethnic categories including 18 individuals (2%). A total of 264 individuals in the sample (26%) could not access an OTP within 180 minutes. For those who could access these facilities, the average 1-way travel time was 45.6 minutes, with individuals spending approximately 70% of their trip duration on out-of-vehicle travel components. The conventional accessibility metric underestimates individuals' travel burden to OTPs as well as the inequity in accessibility compared with the feels-like accessibility metric. For example, the median (range) conventional accessibility score, defined as the number of OTPs within 120 minutes of transit travel time, was 5.0 (0.0-17.0); the median (range) feels-like accessibility score, defined as the number of OTPs within 120 minutes of transit travel time weighted to account for in- and out-of-vehicle segments, was 1.0 (0.0-10.0). There is a considerable temporal variation in travel time and accessibility depending on the departure times.
CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this cross-sectional study of travel burdens, the calculated feels-like accessibility scores, which consider the differential outcomes of out-of-vehicle travel components (eg, walking and waiting), could better and more realistically reflect passengers' transportation burden. Policy recommendations derived from the conventional accessibility metric could be misleading, and decision-makers should use feels-like accessibility metrics that adequately capture individuals' travel burdens. In the context of access to OTPs, the findings from this study suggest that opening new OTP sites to address gaps in access due to distance to services or extending hours of operation at existing sites may ameliorate the travel burden for individuals.
参考来源
- Kim J, Lee J, Thornhill TA, et al. Accessibility of Opioid Treatment Programs Based on Conventional vs Perceived Travel Time Measures. JAMA Netw Open. 2024. PMID: 38376839. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.0209
供执业医师抢救与诊疗参考,不替代临床判断;剂量请结合体重、肝肾功能和本院药品规格复核,以指南原文为准。